R help - Jan 2003 - Is R really an open source S+ ?

This is not a criticism.  I'm just curious.  Is there an effort to keep R
comparable to S+?
Or are the two languages diverging?  I am doing what probably legions have
done before me,
and legions will after me...using R on examples from text books written with
S+ code.  Most of the
time everything appears to be equivalent.  And then there are amazing
divergences in commands.  For
instance:
S:  stdev
R:  sd

why this difference?
Other examples...

S:  Bootstrap
R:  Boot

S:  Jackknife
R:  NA

S: T, F
R: TRUE, FALSE

For those who want to use open source R but still use the excellent S+
literature...these differences can be confusing.  I can also appreciate the
stress on authors attempting to express code that works in both languages.

REX

> From: Rex_Bryan at urscorp.com [mailto:RexBryan1 at attbi.com]
> 
>  This is not a criticism.  I'm just curious.  Is there an 
> effort to keep R
> comparable to S+?
> Or are the two languages diverging?  I am doing what probably 
> legions have
> done before me,
> and legions will after me...using R on examples from text 
> books written with
> S+ code.  Most of the
> time everything appears to be equivalent.  And then there are amazing
> divergences in commands.  For
> instance:
> S:  stdev
> R:  sd
In older versions of Splus (and R), neither existed.  People simply do
sqrt(var(...)).
 
> why this difference?
> Other examples...
> 
> S:  Bootstrap
> R:  Boot
> 
> S:  Jackknife
> R:  NA
Arguably these are differences in added functionalities, and not in the core
language.  BTW, have you look in the "bootstrap" package for R (ported
from
S)?  It does have bootstrap() and jackknife().
 
> S: T, F
> R: TRUE, FALSE
This (and other S/R differences) is covered in the R FAQ.  You *can* use T/F
in R, just not as safe as using TRUE/FALSE.

Andy
 
> For those who want to use open source R but still use the excellent S+
> literature...these differences can be confusing.  I can also 
> appreciate the
> stress on authors attempting to express code that works in 
> both languages.
> 
> REX
> 
> ______________________________________________
> R-help at stat.math.ethz.ch mailing list
> http://www.stat.math.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-help
> 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------