Hi,
I am trying to use ruby int an embedded web server. The environment
does not have the luxury of CGI or WebBrick. I find limited
documentation on how to get this to work. As a test program on windows,
I tried the code in the section below.
I have the issues.
1. Is public/dispatch.rb the right script to invoke a rails app? If
so, what is the right way to invoke dispatch.rb?
2. How can we clean up after the invocation, assuming multiple rails
app are running on the same server?
3. I understand ruby is unsafe for multithreaded invocation. Is
there a distribution that can handle multiple ruby VMs?
TIA.
--
SS
==SAMPLE CODE=
int main(int argc, char* argv[])
{
#if defined(NT)
NtInitialize(&argc, &argv);
#endif
ruby_init();
ruby_init_loadpath();
//chdir( "" );
::SetEnvironmentVariable( "SCRIPT_NAME", "/MyTest" );
::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_URI",
"http://localhost:3000/MyTest#index" );
::SetEnvironmentVariable( "QUERY_STRING", "" );
::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_METHOD", "GET" );
::SetEnvironmentVariable( "CONTENT_LENGTH", "0" );
//ruby_script("embed" );
//rb_load_file( "public\\dispatch.rb" );
rb_load_file( "public\\dispatch.rb" );
//ruby_exec();
ruby_run();
ruby_finalize();
return 0;
}
==OUTPUT=./public/../config/boot.rb:15:in `require'': no such file to
load --
rubygems (Lo
adError)
from ./public/../config/boot.rb:15
from ./public/../config/environment.rb:8
from public\dispatch.rb:3
Press any key to continue
--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/.
I can''t answer all 3 questions, but I can get you past the error you have listed. You just need a couple of envars set. This is what I use on my system; you''ll need to change to compensate for Windows and your path structure: export RUBYLIB=/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8 export GEM_PATH=/lib/ruby/gems/1.8 export GEM_HOME=/lib/ruby/gems/1.8 As far as question 3, instead of spawning multiple threads, why not create multiple processes? For low-volume sites this should be sufficient. Solves question 2, too, as soon as the process terminates. Calling Rails using embedded ruby wrote:> Hi, > I am trying to use ruby int an embedded web server. The environment > does not have the luxury of CGI or WebBrick. I find limited > documentation on how to get this to work. As a test program on windows, > I tried the code in the section below. > I have the issues. > 1. Is public/dispatch.rb the right script to invoke a rails app? If > so, what is the right way to invoke dispatch.rb? > 2. How can we clean up after the invocation, assuming multiple rails > app are running on the same server? > 3. I understand ruby is unsafe for multithreaded invocation. Is > there a distribution that can handle multiple ruby VMs? > TIA. > -- > SS > > ==SAMPLE CODE=> > int main(int argc, char* argv[]) > { > > #if defined(NT) > NtInitialize(&argc, &argv); > #endif > > > ruby_init(); > ruby_init_loadpath(); > > > //chdir( "" ); > > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "SCRIPT_NAME", "/MyTest" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_URI", > "http://localhost:3000/MyTest#index" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "QUERY_STRING", "" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_METHOD", "GET" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "CONTENT_LENGTH", "0" ); > > //ruby_script("embed" ); > //rb_load_file( "public\\dispatch.rb" ); > rb_load_file( "public\\dispatch.rb" ); > > //ruby_exec(); > ruby_run(); > > ruby_finalize(); > > return 0; > } > > ==OUTPUT=> ./public/../config/boot.rb:15:in `require'': no such file to load -- > rubygems (Lo > adError) > from ./public/../config/boot.rb:15 > from ./public/../config/environment.rb:8 > from public\dispatch.rb:3
run rake freeze_gems in this rails install to cut the dependency on rubygems> ==OUTPUT=> ./public/../config/boot.rb:15:in `require'': no such file to load -- > rubygems (Lo > adError) > from ./public/../config/boot.rb:15 > from ./public/../config/environment.rb:8 > from public\dispatch.rb:3 > Press any key to continue
Lou,
Thanks! I tried your second suggestion and started a process. This
seems to work fairly well. I ended up emulating a CGI environment with
all the variables. It seems that the startup is the cost I pay in most
cases.
I studied the ruby codebase quiet a bit and it seems the api has to
be worked to support multiple threads. I hope the maintaner for the
codebase reviews the API to put in place holders for enabling threads in
the future. If not, we may end up with a kludge work-aroud as in perl.
On a different note, is it true that rails gets confused when
multiple applications are running? What can be done to make rails handle
multiple apps in the same VM?
Lou Vanek wrote:> I can''t answer all 3 questions, but I can get you past the error
> you have listed. You just need a couple of envars set. This is what
> I use on my system; you''ll need to change to compensate for
Windows
> and your path structure:
>
> export RUBYLIB=/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8
> export GEM_PATH=/lib/ruby/gems/1.8
> export GEM_HOME=/lib/ruby/gems/1.8
>
> As far as question 3, instead of spawning multiple threads, why not
> create multiple processes? For low-volume sites this should be
> sufficient. Solves question 2, too, as soon as the process terminates.
--
Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/.
For future reference, this is what I ended up doing. ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "SCRIPT_NAME", "/MyTest" ); ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_URI", "http://localhost:3000/MyTest/index" ); ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "QUERY_STRING", "index" ); ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_METHOD", "GET" ); ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "CONTENT_LENGTH", "0" ); ::WinExec( "c:\\ruby\\bin\\ruby.exe public\\dispatch.rb", SW_SHOW ); Note that you have to set the current directory to the root of the rails app. We can improve by using CreateProcess() etc.. but this is a start. -- Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/.
What you really want to do is to get the C source for SCGI and add scgi support to your c based webserver. Its a very simple protocol and very performant. This will allow you to use rails, php and everything else. On 12/18/05, Sreekant Sreedharan <blue_panther-PkbjNfxxIARBDgjK7y7TUQ@public.gmane.org> wrote:> For future reference, this is what I ended up doing. > > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "SCRIPT_NAME", "/MyTest" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_URI", > "http://localhost:3000/MyTest/index" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "QUERY_STRING", "index" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "REQUEST_METHOD", "GET" ); > ::SetEnvironmentVariable( "CONTENT_LENGTH", "0" ); > > ::WinExec( "c:\\ruby\\bin\\ruby.exe public\\dispatch.rb", SW_SHOW ); > > > Note that you have to set the current directory to the root of the rails > app. We can improve by using CreateProcess() etc.. but this is a start. > > -- > Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/. > _______________________________________________ > Rails mailing list > Rails-1W37MKcQCpIf0INCOvqR/iCwEArCW2h5@public.gmane.org > http://lists.rubyonrails.org/mailman/listinfo/rails >-- Tobi http://jadedpixel.com - modern e-commerce software http://typo.leetsoft.com - Open source weblog engine http://blog.leetsoft.com - Technical weblog
Yeah, now that you mention it, I guess you are in essence writing a CGI server. I haven''t experienced or read about any innate Rails instability, but some http servers work better than others. [Hint: which server does script/server try to start by default?] The http server and judicious caching seems to have more of an affect on a stable app than any Rails or Ruby tweaking. There have been reports of problems, but it''s hard to say just yet where the root of the problem lies. The platform is still evolving, even the drivers and interface protocols btn Rails and the http/cgi server. I don''t know the answer to your last question. As long as all non-immutable shared resources (e.g. global vars, db connection pool) are accessed atomically there shouldn''t be cross-thread instability issues. Sreekant Sreedharan wrote:> Lou, > Thanks! I tried your second suggestion and started a process. This > seems to work fairly well. I ended up emulating a CGI environment with > all the variables. It seems that the startup is the cost I pay in most > cases. > I studied the ruby codebase quiet a bit and it seems the api has to > be worked to support multiple threads. I hope the maintaner for the > codebase reviews the API to put in place holders for enabling threads in > the future. If not, we may end up with a kludge work-aroud as in perl. > > On a different note, is it true that rails gets confused when > multiple applications are running? What can be done to make rails handle > multiple apps in the same VM? > > > Lou Vanek wrote: > >>I can''t answer all 3 questions, but I can get you past the error >>you have listed. You just need a couple of envars set. This is what >>I use on my system; you''ll need to change to compensate for Windows >>and your path structure: >> >>export RUBYLIB=/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8 >>export GEM_PATH=/lib/ruby/gems/1.8 >>export GEM_HOME=/lib/ruby/gems/1.8 >> >>As far as question 3, instead of spawning multiple threads, why not >>create multiple processes? For low-volume sites this should be >>sufficient. Solves question 2, too, as soon as the process terminates.
I plan to extend it to support SCGI. What I am trying to do is to develop an embedded application server that hosts various scripting environment, and I am constrained by a memory limitation on the server to about 20MB. (This is an embedded environment). For me, RoR is a great find. I like the agile capabilities on this platform. And I want to bring it to the embedded space. For now, CGI is a workaround. Thus, What I would like to do however is run ruby within the server and thread it. Ruby startup takes upto 2 seconds on my machine. I don''t think that is going away easily. The server itself is fast, and so is the startup of the CGI process (relatively speaking). There are a few optimizations in the interpreter also, that I found... for example, the symbol lookup could benifit from lookup caching. But these are minor tweaks compared to the benefit from the startup process. Tobi, could you explain.. how does ''run rake freeze_gems'' help? A question for you guys, I understand that there are multiple VMs out there. YARV for example... do you know of Rails working on other VMs? Has anyone done a compatibility matrix on all the VMs and its fit to RoR? Tobias Luetke wrote:> What you really want to do is to get the C source for SCGI and add > scgi support to your c based webserver. Its a very simple protocol and > very performant. This will allow you to use rails, php and everything > else. > > On 12/18/05, Sreekant Sreedharan <blue_panther-PkbjNfxxIARBDgjK7y7TUQ@public.gmane.org> wrote: >> >> > -- > Tobi > http://jadedpixel.com - modern e-commerce software > http://typo.leetsoft.com - Open source weblog engine > http://blog.leetsoft.com - Technical weblog-- Posted via http://www.ruby-forum.com/.
Sorry i should have been more specific. the rake task freeze_gems is part of a standard rails 1.0 project. it will copy all of rails into your projects directory ( vendor/rails/ to be specific ). When the rails app notices that vendor/rails exists during bootup it will load rails from there instead of trying to get it from rubygems. This should also improve startup times slightly.> Tobi, could you explain.. how does ''run rake freeze_gems'' help?> A question for you guys, I understand that there are multiple VMs out > there. YARV for example... do you know of Rails working on other VMs? > Has anyone done a compatibility matrix on all the VMs and its fit to > RoR?As far as i know the only VM which is close to implementing the full ruby syntax is yarv and its not quite there yet. During rubyconf earlier this year it was still missing some of the odder pieces of ruby syntax like: { |*params| ... } I expect that we will be able to run rails on yarv after modifications by the middle of next year. Yarv will be the VM which ships with ruby 2.0. -- Tobi http://jadedpixel.com - modern e-commerce software http://typo.leetsoft.com - Open source weblog engine http://blog.leetsoft.com - Technical weblog