R help - Aug 2012 - bibtex::read.bib -- extracting bibentry keys

I have two versions of a bibtex database which have gotten badly out of 
sync. I need to find find all the entries in
bib2 which are not contained in bib1, according to their bibtex keys.
But I can't figure out how to extract a list of the bibentry keys in 
these databases.

A minor question: Is there someway to prevent read.bib from ignoring 
entries that do not contain all required fields?

A suggestion: it would be nice if bibtex provided some extractor 
functions for bibentry fields.

 > bib1 <- read.bib("C:/localtexmf/bibtex/bib/timeref.bib")
ignoring entry 'Donoho-etal:1988' (line 40) because :
A bibentry of bibtype ?InCollection? has to correctly specify the 
field(s): booktitle
... snipping other similar warnings ...

 > length(bib1)
[1] 628
 >
 > bib2 <- read.bib("W:/texmf/bibtex/bib/timeref.bib")
ignoring entry 'Donoho-etal:1988' (line 57) because :
A bibentry of bibtype ?InCollection? has to correctly specify the 
field(s): booktitle
... snipping other similar warnings ...

 > length(bib2)
[1] 611

# The first bibentry:
 > bib1[[1]]
Godfrey EH (1918). ?History and Development of Statistics in Canada.? In 
Koren J (ed.), pp.
179-198. Macmillan, New York.
 > str(bib1[[1]])
Class 'bibentry' hidden list of 1
$ :List of 9
..$ author :Class 'person' hidden list of 1
.. ..$ :List of 5
.. .. ..$ given : chr [1:2] "Ernest" "H."
.. .. ..$ family : chr "Godfrey"
.. .. ..$ role : NULL
.. .. ..$ email : NULL
.. .. ..$ comment: NULL
..$ title : chr "History and Development of Statistics in {Canada}"
..$ booktitle: chr "History of Statistics, their Development and 
Progress in Many Countries"
..$ publisher: chr "Macmillan"
..$ year : chr "1918"
..$ editor :Class 'person' hidden list of 1
.. ..$ :List of 5
.. .. ..$ given : chr "John"
.. .. ..$ family : chr "Koren"
.. .. ..$ role : NULL
.. .. ..$ email : NULL
.. .. ..$ comment: NULL
..$ pages : chr "179--198"
..$ address : chr "New York"
..$ crossref : chr "Koren:1918"
..- attr(*, "bibtype")= chr "InCollection"
..- attr(*, "key")= chr "Godfrey:1918"

So, I try to get the "key" attribute for this entry, but it returns 
NULL, and I don't understand why.
 > attr(bib1[[1]], "key")
NULL
 > attr(bib1[1], "key")
NULL

-Michael

-- 
Michael Friendly     Email: friendly AT yorku DOT ca
Professor, Psychology Dept.
York University      Voice: 416 736-2100 x66249 Fax: 416 736-5814
4700 Keele Street    Web:   http://www.datavis.ca
Toronto, ONT  M3J 1P3 CANADA

On Mon, 6 Aug 2012, Michael Friendly wrote:
> I have two versions of a bibtex database which have gotten badly out of 
> sync. I need to find find all the entries in bib2 which are not 
> contained in bib1, according to their bibtex keys. But I can't figure 
> out how to extract a list of the bibentry keys in these databases.
read.bib() returns a "bibentry" object so you can simply do this as
usual
for "bibentry" objects with $key:

x <- read.bib(...)
x$key

or maybe

unlist(x$key)

Whatever is more convenient for you. See ?bibentry for more details.
> A minor question: Is there someway to prevent read.bib from ignoring 
> entries that do not contain all required fields?
Also not really an issue with read.bib itself. read.bib() wants to return 
a "bibentry" object but bibentry() just allows to create objects that
are
valid BibTeX, i.e., have all required fields.
> A suggestion: it would be nice if bibtex provided some extractor functions 
> for bibentry fields.
So that only a subset of fields is read as opposed to all fields?

If you read all fields, you can easily subset afterwards (again using 
$-notation).

hth,
Z
>> bib1 <- read.bib("C:/localtexmf/bibtex/bib/timeref.bib")
> ignoring entry 'Donoho-etal:1988' (line 40) because :
> A bibentry of bibtype ?InCollection? has to correctly specify the field(s):
> booktitle
> ... snipping other similar warnings ...
>
>> length(bib1)
> [1] 628
>>
>> bib2 <- read.bib("W:/texmf/bibtex/bib/timeref.bib")
> ignoring entry 'Donoho-etal:1988' (line 57) because :
> A bibentry of bibtype ?InCollection? has to correctly specify the field(s):
> booktitle
> ... snipping other similar warnings ...
>
>> length(bib2)
> [1] 611
>
> # The first bibentry:
>> bib1[[1]]
> Godfrey EH (1918). ?History and Development of Statistics in Canada.? In 
> Koren J (ed.), pp.
> 179-198. Macmillan, New York.
>> str(bib1[[1]])
> Class 'bibentry' hidden list of 1
> $ :List of 9
> ..$ author :Class 'person' hidden list of 1
> .. ..$ :List of 5
> .. .. ..$ given : chr [1:2] "Ernest" "H."
> .. .. ..$ family : chr "Godfrey"
> .. .. ..$ role : NULL
> .. .. ..$ email : NULL
> .. .. ..$ comment: NULL
> ..$ title : chr "History and Development of Statistics in
{Canada}"
> ..$ booktitle: chr "History of Statistics, their Development and
Progress in
> Many Countries"
> ..$ publisher: chr "Macmillan"
> ..$ year : chr "1918"
> ..$ editor :Class 'person' hidden list of 1
> .. ..$ :List of 5
> .. .. ..$ given : chr "John"
> .. .. ..$ family : chr "Koren"
> .. .. ..$ role : NULL
> .. .. ..$ email : NULL
> .. .. ..$ comment: NULL
> ..$ pages : chr "179--198"
> ..$ address : chr "New York"
> ..$ crossref : chr "Koren:1918"
> ..- attr(*, "bibtype")= chr "InCollection"
> ..- attr(*, "key")= chr "Godfrey:1918"
>
> So, I try to get the "key" attribute for this entry, but it
returns NULL, and
> I don't understand why.
>> attr(bib1[[1]], "key")
> NULL
>> attr(bib1[1], "key")
> NULL
>
> -Michael
>
> -- 
> Michael Friendly     Email: friendly AT yorku DOT ca
> Professor, Psychology Dept.
> York University      Voice: 416 736-2100 x66249 Fax: 416 736-5814
> 4700 Keele Street    Web:   http://www.datavis.ca
> Toronto, ONT  M3J 1P3 CANADA
>
> ______________________________________________
> R-help at r-project.org mailing list
> https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-help
> PLEASE do read the posting guide
http://www.R-project.org/posting-guide.html
> and provide commented, minimal, self-contained, reproducible code.
>