R help - Jan 2013 - deparse substitute

Hi,

I'm writing a function that needs the input names (as characterstrings) as
part of the output.
With deparse(substitute( ) ) that works fine, until I replace all zeros with
0.001 (log is calculated at some time):

tf <- function(input) { input[input==0] <- 0.001 ;  
deparse(substitute(input)) }
myguess <- 42
tf(myguess)     # not "myguess", but "42"


Now when I extract the input names before replacing the zeros, this works:

tf <- function(input) { out <- deparse(substitute(input)) ;  
input[input==0] <- 0.001 ;   out }
tf(myguess)     # correct: "myguess"
myguess <- 0 ; tf(myguess) # ditto


While I did find a workaround, I'm still wondering why this happens.
Any hints on where to start reading?

Thanks ahead,
Berry

PS: R version 2.15.1 (2012-06-22) -- "Roasted Marshmallows"
Windows 7  - Platform: x86_64-pc-mingw32/x64 (64-bit)



 		 	   		  
	[[alternative HTML version deleted]]

On 13-01-09 5:03 AM, Berry Boessenkool wrote:
>
>
> Hi,
>
> I'm writing a function that needs the input names (as characterstrings)
as part of the output.
> With deparse(substitute( ) ) that works fine, until I replace all zeros
with 0.001 (log is calculated at some time):
>
> tf <- function(input) { input[input==0] <- 0.001 ;  
deparse(substitute(input)) }
> myguess <- 42
> tf(myguess)     # not "myguess", but "42"
>
>
> Now when I extract the input names before replacing the zeros, this works:
>
> tf <- function(input) { out <- deparse(substitute(input)) ;  
input[input==0] <- 0.001 ;   out }
> tf(myguess)     # correct: "myguess"
> myguess <- 0 ; tf(myguess) # ditto
>
>
> While I did find a workaround, I'm still wondering why this happens.
> Any hints on where to start reading?
Probably the R Language definition, section 2.1.8.  The basic 
explanation for the behaviour you see is that deparse(substitute(input)) 
acts on the "input" promise object, looking at its expression slot.
It's
not doing any magic examination of the context in which it was 
originally defined.

Once you modify it, it is no longer a promise, and so it has no 
expression slot.

Duncan Murdoch