Richard@roughage.com.au, Heycock@roughage.com.au
2006-Jul-27 05:11 UTC
[Xen-users] Poor performance running apache under xen
We''ve been seeing a fairly significant slow down of a fairly large, in
house java application based on apache tomcat, when running under xen.
In order to gain some insight into this I''ve run similar tests using
Apache2 and ApacheBench and we are seeing almost exactly the same slow
down of about 24% (23.8% for our application and 23.5% for apache).
The test consisted of sending one million reqests to the web server and
was run from a different machine over gigbit ethernet. During the tests
the driving machine did not go over 15% cpu load and the 1 min load avg
did not go over 2. The machine under test had nothing else running. The
results given are for the second of two runs after a reboot. The cpu
usage is the average over the entire run obtained from sar with a four
second average (sar 4 0). The cpu figure is of the machine running the
test. The /lib/tls directory was removed.
The tests where carried out using the following versions of software:
* Ubuntu 5.10 (Breezy Badger) using Debian 32bit kernels
* Xen 3.0.2
* Apache 2.0.54 using both the mpm-prefork (multi-process worker) and the
mpm-worker (hybrid multi-threaded multi-process worker)
* ApacheBench 2.0.41-dev
The different kernel configurations are:
Stock kernel: 2.6.16-2-686-smp #1 SMP
dom0 kernel: 2.6.16-1-xen-686 #1 SMP
domU kernel: 2.6.16-1-xen-686 #1 SMP
The throughput is:
Kernel throughput % cpu (user + system)
stock kernel (prefork): 5019.42 24.31
stock kernel (worker): 4800.20 30.37
dom0 kernel (prefork): 5029.60 22.37
dom0 kernel (worker): 4843.59 29.97
domU kernel (prefork): 3726.44 38.80
domU kernel (worker): 3704.95 41.32
The reason I tested both the mpm-prefork and mpm-worker is test to see
if the threading concurrency model made a big difference -- it didn''t!
Can anyone shed any light on these results? Is this the normal
performance that is to be expected from this type of application?
I''ve put all the results (ApacheBench results and the sar outputs) on
http://twosecondmemory.org/xen-performance/
rgh
_______________________________________________
Xen-users mailing list
Xen-users@lists.xensource.com
http://lists.xensource.com/xen-users
Adam Crews -X \(acrews - Xerox at Cisco\)
2006-Jul-27 17:38 UTC
RE: [Xen-users] Poor performance running apache under xen
This sounds similar to a problem I had. For my system setting "EnableSendfile off" in the apache config fixed things for me. -Adam | -----Original Message----- | From: xen-users-bounces@lists.xensource.com | [mailto:xen-users-bounces@lists.xensource.com] On Behalf Of | Richard@roughage.com.au | Sent: Wednesday, July 26, 2006 10:12 PM | To: xen-users@lists.xensource.com | Subject: [Xen-users] Poor performance running apache under xen | | We''ve been seeing a fairly significant slow down of a | fairly large, in | house java application based on apache tomcat, when running | under xen. | In order to gain some insight into this I''ve run similar tests using | Apache2 and ApacheBench and we are seeing almost exactly | the same slow | down of about 24% (23.8% for our application and 23.5% for apache). | | The test consisted of sending one million reqests to the | web server and | was run from a different machine over gigbit ethernet. | During the tests | the driving machine did not go over 15% cpu load and the 1 | min load avg | did not go over 2. The machine under test had nothing else | running. The | results given are for the second of two runs after a reboot. The cpu | usage is the average over the entire run obtained from sar | with a four | second average (sar 4 0). The cpu figure is of the machine | running the | test. The /lib/tls directory was removed. | | The tests where carried out using the following versions of | software: | | * Ubuntu 5.10 (Breezy Badger) using Debian 32bit kernels | * Xen 3.0.2 | * Apache 2.0.54 using both the mpm-prefork (multi-process | worker) and the | mpm-worker (hybrid multi-threaded multi-process worker) | * ApacheBench 2.0.41-dev | | The different kernel configurations are: | | Stock kernel: 2.6.16-2-686-smp #1 SMP | dom0 kernel: 2.6.16-1-xen-686 #1 SMP | domU kernel: 2.6.16-1-xen-686 #1 SMP | | The throughput is: | | Kernel throughput % cpu (user + system) | stock kernel (prefork): 5019.42 24.31 | stock kernel (worker): 4800.20 30.37 | dom0 kernel (prefork): 5029.60 22.37 | dom0 kernel (worker): 4843.59 29.97 | domU kernel (prefork): 3726.44 38.80 | domU kernel (worker): 3704.95 41.32 | | The reason I tested both the mpm-prefork and mpm-worker is | test to see | if the threading concurrency model made a big difference -- | it didn''t! | | Can anyone shed any light on these results? Is this the normal | performance that is to be expected from this type of application? | | I''ve put all the results (ApacheBench results and the sar | outputs) on | http://twosecondmemory.org/xen-performance/ | | rgh | | | _______________________________________________ | Xen-users mailing list | Xen-users@lists.xensource.com | http://lists.xensource.com/xen-users | _______________________________________________ Xen-users mailing list Xen-users@lists.xensource.com http://lists.xensource.com/xen-users