thr3ads.net - Syslinux - [syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9 [Mar 2015]

If this information is useful, please help other people find it:
Share via:

Jorge Cisneros

2015-Mar-05 19:03 UTC

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

Hi All,

    My PXE configurations works fine for a bios PXE (the server in legacy
mode) but hangs in an EUFI mode. Look like  it can transfer the bootx64.efi
but not the next one ldlinux.e64


  Any ideas?

Thanks


Software>
syslinux ver 6.3
atftp 7.1


Log server side
>> Booting Embedded LOM 1 Port 1 : HP Ethernet 1Gb 4-port 331i Adapter -NIC (PXE IPv4)
>> Booting PXE over IPv4.  Station IP address is 10.1.136.65

  Server IP address is 10.7.63.247
  NBP filename is efipxe/bootx64.efi
  NBP filesize is 188000 Bytes
 Downloading NBP file...

  NBP file downloaded successfully.
Getting cached packet
My IP is 10.1.136.65

Log tftp side

Mar  5 12:57:17 tuxdhcp dhcpd: DHCPOFFER on 10.1.136.65 to
9c:b6:54:b6:7d:f0 via 10.7.64.77
Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp dhcpd: DHCPREQUEST for 10.1.136.65 (10.7.63.247)
from 9c:b6:54:b6:7d:f0 via 10.7.64.77
Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp dhcpd: DHCPACK on 10.1.136.65 to 9c:b6:54:b6:7d:f0
via 10.7.64.77
Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/bootx64.efi to
10.1.136.65:1436
Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/bootx64.efi to
10.1.136.65:1437
Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:21 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:22 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:22 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:23 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:24 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:25 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:25 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:25 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:26 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:26 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:27 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:27 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:27 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:27 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:28 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:28 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:29 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:29 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:30 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:30 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:30 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:30 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:31 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:31 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:32 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:32 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:32 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:32 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:32 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:33 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438
Mar  5 12:57:33 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:33 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:34 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:34 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:35 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:35 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: timeout: retrying...
Mar  5 12:57:35 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
10.1.136.65:1438

Ady

2015-Mar-05 23:58 UTC

head link

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

> Hi All,
> 
>     My PXE configurations works fine for a bios PXE (the server in legacy
> mode) but hangs in an EUFI mode. Look like  it can transfer the bootx64.efi
> but not the next one ldlinux.e64
> 
> 
>   Any ideas?
> 
> Thanks
>  
Latest updates (including firmware) for the HP ML350 Gen9 were released 
on 2014DEC19 (v1.21); I would suggest double-checking that you are 
using the latest (firmware and related tools) version, before starting 
any other troubleshooting procedures.

Have you tested with official upstream binaries already included in the 
official archives downloaded from kernel.org (not from some particular 
build / 'make', neither from some (Linux) distro packages)? Please be 
sure to test with the latest version from kernel.org (v6.03 stable 
release, ATM).

Please remember not to mix versions. The version of the ldlinux 
module(s) shall match the same exact version of the bootloader.

BTW, there was a report here during 2015FEB about problems with one Hp 
DL380p Gen9 server. In that case, a specific filter for a pcap report 
was suggested. Unfortunately, there is/was no feedback in this Syslinux 
Mailing List about a possible resolution following that pcap report.

Regards,
Ady.

Patrick Masotta

2015-Mar-12 11:15 UTC

head link

[syslinux] Problems PXE booting syslinux.efi on HP EliteBook 2560p / 8460p

Hi there,
I have experienced problems on HP Elitebook 2560p and 8460p 
latest firmware installed:
2560p 68SSU ver. F50. 08/04/2014 
8460p 68SCF ver. F50. 08/04/2014


PXE boot, syslinux.efi gets perfectly TFTP transferred, it nevers asks for
ldlinux.e64, and immediately gives up.

I have traced the problem to:

/syslinux-6.03/efi/udp.c\core_udp_open()
/syslinux-6.03/efi/main.c\efi_create_binding(&Udp4ServiceBindingProtocol,
&Udp4Protocol);
/syslinux-6.03/gnu-efi/gnu-efi-3.0/lib/hand.c\LibLocateHandle(ByProtocol, bguid,
NULL, &nr_handles, &handles);

When LibLocateHandle() try to locate EFI_UDP4_SERVICE_BINDING_PROTOCOL it fails
with
EFI_NOT_FOUND (14) which looks like an HP firmware issue. 
Newer versions of the HP Elitebook family like 2570p and 8470p PXE boot
syslinux.efi correctly.
Unfortunately this error does not display any error message on 6.0.3.

I wonder if this problem with HP EFI firmware affecting current but not the
newest hardware it's not
somehow related to the recent thread "Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350
Gen9"
http://www.syslinux.org/archives/2015-March/023305.html
In this case the ldlinux.e64 is requested but never received even when offered
by the TFTP server.


Best,
Patrick

Gene Cumm

2015-Oct-09 10:44 UTC

head link

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

On Thu, Mar 5, 2015 at 2:03 PM, Jorge Cisneros via Syslinux
<syslinux at zytor.com> wrote:> Hi All,
>
>     My PXE configurations works fine for a bios PXE (the server in legacy
> mode) but hangs in an EUFI mode. Look like  it can transfer the bootx64.efi
> but not the next one ldlinux.e64
>
>
>   Any ideas?
My latest personally-published binaries.

git://github.com/geneC/syslinux.git
https://github.com/geneC/syslinux.git

Branch 1efipxe


https://sites.google.com/site/genecsyslinux/sl604p0g18-x64.tgz?attredirects=0&d=1
https://sites.google.com/site/genecsyslinux/sl604p0g18-bios.tgz?attredirects=0&d=1

> Thanks
>
>
> Software>
> syslinux ver 6.3
> atftp 7.1
>
>
> Log server side
>
>>> Booting Embedded LOM 1 Port 1 : HP Ethernet 1Gb 4-port 331i Adapter
-
> NIC (PXE IPv4)
>
>>> Booting PXE over IPv4.
>   Station IP address is 10.1.136.65
>
>   Server IP address is 10.7.63.247
>   NBP filename is efipxe/bootx64.efi
>   NBP filesize is 188000 Bytes
>  Downloading NBP file...
>
>   NBP file downloaded successfully.
> Getting cached packet
> My IP is 10.1.136.65
>
> Log tftp side
>
> Mar  5 12:57:17 tuxdhcp dhcpd: DHCPOFFER on 10.1.136.65 to
> 9c:b6:54:b6:7d:f0 via 10.7.64.77
> Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp dhcpd: DHCPREQUEST for 10.1.136.65 (10.7.63.247)
> from 9c:b6:54:b6:7d:f0 via 10.7.64.77
> Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp dhcpd: DHCPACK on 10.1.136.65 to 9c:b6:54:b6:7d:f0
> via 10.7.64.77
> Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/bootx64.efi to
> 10.1.136.65:1436
> Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/bootx64.efi to
> 10.1.136.65:1437
> Mar  5 12:57:20 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
> 10.1.136.65:1438
> Mar  5 12:57:21 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
> 10.1.136.65:1438
> Mar  5 12:57:22 tuxdhcp atftpd[29200]: Serving efipxe/ldlinux.e64 to
> 10.1.136.65:1438
Looks like the usual.

-- 
-Gene

Bruno Cornec

2015-Oct-22 17:28 UTC

head link

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

Gene Cumm via Syslinux said on Fri, Oct 09, 2015 at 06:44:33AM
-0400:>On Thu, Mar 5, 2015 at 2:03 PM, Jorge Cisneros via Syslinux
><syslinux at zytor.com> wrote:
>> Hi All,
>>
>>     My PXE configurations works fine for a bios PXE (the server in
legacy
>> mode) but hangs in an EUFI mode. Look like  it can transfer the
bootx64.efi
>> but not the next one ldlinux.e64
I had exactly that issue last week, and solved it by changing my tftp
server (which happened to be CentOS 6) to the one on RHEL7 (tftp-hpa
5.2). THat last one worked whereas the previous didn't, without changing
anything else.

Hope it helps,
Bruno.
-- 
Open Source Profession, Linux Community Lead WW  http://opensource.hp.com
HP EMEA EG Open Source Technology Strategist         http://hpintelco.net
FLOSS projects:     http://mondorescue.org     http://project-builder.org 
Musique ancienne? http://www.musique-ancienne.org http://www.medieval.org

Seemingly Similar Threads

Search for more possibly parallel threads

Syslinux - Mar 2015 - Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

[syslinux] Problems PXE booting syslinux.efi on HP EliteBook 2560p / 8460p

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

[syslinux] Problem boot PXE UEFI on HP ML350 Gen9

Seemingly Similar Threads