samba - Oct 2004 - winbind: using idmap only if user doesn't exist in UNIX getpw*(3) ?

Greetings all.

I have a requirement to use winbind to allocate UID/GIDs for
users but only if they aren't in the non-winbind nsswitch sources.

I.e, given
    smb.conf	; samba 3.0.7
	realm = DOMAIN
	workgroup = DOMAIN
	log level = 3 idmap:10 winbind:10
	idmap gid = 50000-59999
	idmap uid = 50000-59999
    ADS users:
	DOMAIN\adsuser1		; only in ADS, not NIS
	DOMAIN\adsuser2		; only in ADS, not NIS
	DOMAIN\user1
	DOMAIN\user2
    NIS passwd:
	user1:*:10001:20000:&:/home/user1:/bin/sh
	user2:*:10002:20000:&:/home/user2:/bin/sh


I want name<->uid loops to return "10001" for user1 and a
winbind allocated UID for adsuser* (e.g, 50000).

I have had no succes so far configuring samba 3.0.7 to do this.

What I've tried so far (stopping smbd/nmbd/winbindd and removing
winbindd_idmap.tdb between tests)

    a)
	nsswitch.conf
		passwd: files nis winbind
		group:  files nis winbind
	smb.conf
		winbind trusted domains only = no

	nsswitch test results:
		% id user1
		uid=10001(user1) gid=20000(group0) groups=20000(group0)
		% id adsuser1
		id: adsuser1: No such user
		% id 'DOMAIN\adsuser1'
		uid=50000(DOMAIN\adsuser1) gid=50005(DOMAIN\Domain Users)
		    groups=50005(DOMAIN\Domain Users)

	Accessing as DOMAIN\adsuser1 connects as uid=50000,gid=50005.
	This is expected; we want winbind to fake a UID/GID.

	Accessing as DOMAIN\user1 connects as uid=50001,gid=50005.
	This is NOT expected.
	As far as I can tell, it's because samba first tries
	getpwnam("DOMAIN\user1") which isn't found by NIS but
	winbind(8) fakes up an entry.

    b)
	nsswitch.conf
		passwd: files nis
		group:  files nis
	smb.conf
		winbind trusted domains only = no

	nsswitch test results:
		% id user1
		uid=10001(user1) gid=20000(group0) groups=20000(group0)
		% id adsuser1
		id: adsuser1: No such user
		% id 'DOMAIN\adsuser1'
		id: DOMAIN\adsuser1: No such user

	Accessing as DOMAIN\user1 connects as uid=10001,gid=20000.
	This is expected.

	Accessing as DOMAIN\adsuser1 fails, because there's no
	corresponding name->UID mapping in NIS.
	This is expected based on the nsswitch.conf configuration,
	but not what I want.

    c)
	nsswitch.conf
		passwd: files nis winbind
		group:  files nis winbind
	smb.conf
		winbind trusted domains only = yes

	nsswitch test results:
		% id user1
		uid=10001(user1) gid=20000(group0) groups=20000(group0)
		% id adsuser1
		id: adsuser1: No such user
		% id 'DOMAIN\adsuser1'
		id: DOMAIN\adsuser1: No such user

	Accessing as DOMAIN\user1 connects as uid=10001,gid=20000.
	This is expected.

	Accessing as DOMAIN\adsuser1 fails, because there's no
	corresponding name->UID mapping in NIS, and winbind
	refuses to fake one up:
		winbindd_getpwnam: My domain -- rejecting getpwnam()
		for DOMAIN\ADSUSER1
	What can I do to get winbind to fake one up?


At this point, I'm lost for a solution based on existing functionality.
I am considering hacking in another option which changes the
behaviour of "winbind trusted domains only" so that winbind will
provide a fallback mapping for users in the trusted domain that
aren't found by getpwnam(3) (i.e, the other UNIX getpw*() nsswitch
sources, such as "files nis".).
Is there any way to achieve what I want, or do I need to hack the
functionality into samba?

Thanks,
Luke.
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 186 bytes
Desc: not available
Url :
http://lists.samba.org/archive/samba/attachments/20041027/7a2d40d4/attachment.bin

On Wed, Oct 27, 2004 at 01:23:43PM -0500, Gerald (Jerry) Carter wrote:
  | On Wed, 27 Oct 2004, Luke Mewburn wrote:
  | >
  | > I have a requirement to use winbind to allocate UID/GIDs for
  | > users but only if they aren't in the non-winbind nsswitch sources.
  | > 
  | > I have had no succes so far configuring samba 3.0.7 to do this.
  | 
  | Because winbindd is not designed to do this.  It's currently an all or 
  | none thing.

Ok.  I'm working on a solution for this in my private tree.
I'll feed back the changes if the samba team is interested.
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 186 bytes
Desc: not available
Url :
http://lists.samba.org/archive/samba/attachments/20041028/781548b7/attachment.bin