FMH
2009-Nov-12 14:13 UTC
[R] A comparison between span in lowess method and h in sm.regression
Dear All, I have fitted a bivariate and an additive model on a monthly temperature from 1987-2007 via nonparametric regression and would like to compare?between these models via F-test, but having difficulty in determining the possible values of span?with lowess method. For instance, these two models are defined in R as: ###################################################### bivariate.model <- sm.regression(c(month,year), Temperature, h = c(0.2,0.8))? additive.model <- gam(Temperature~lo(month, span=A) + lo(year,span=B)) ###################################################### However, i notice the sm.regression function uses h as a?smoothing parameter ?whilst the gam function uses span as a smoothing parameter, and these models can't just simply be compared?straight? forward,?but?few?adjustments should be made on the values of span in gam function,?corresponding to the values of h in sm.regression function. Could anyone please advice me ?the possible values of A and B in the gam function above? I'd would be very grateful for any idea and suggestion towards this issue. Thank you Fir