dovecot - Apr 2007 - LSUB "" "" vs LIST "" "" (hacked Apple Mail problem)

The LSUB command does not act like LIST when provided with an empty  
mask argument.  LIST responds with the hierarchy delimiter:

	* LIST (\Noselect) "." ""
	OK List completed.

whereas LSUB doesn't return anything useful:

	OK Lsub completed.

RFC 3501 doesn't specify what LSUB should do in this case, but  
Courier IMAP has LSUB act like LIST.  The attached patch modifies  
imap/cmd-list.c to make Dovecot do the same.


Why do I care about LSUB?  I'm using a hack for Apple Mail that  
replaces its LIST command with LSUB (something like what's described  
here: http://www.macosxhints.com/article.php? 
story=20040407062603804), to prevent it from syncing public folders  
from the Exchange server at the office.

The hack replaces _all_ LISTs with LSUBs, including the LIST ""
""
Mail.app sends to discover the hierarchy delimiter.  Since dovecot  
doesn't give it any information in response to LSUB ""
"", Mail.app
defaults to using "/" as a delimiter, which means that trying to  
access a subfolder only results in an "Invalid mailbox name" error.

While this isn't really a bug in Dovecot, it's not inconceivable that  
other people than me could be affected by this problem  
(macosxhints.com has a substantial readership).  It's also tricky to  
diagnose, especially since the "Invalid mailbox name" message
doesn't
include the invalid mailbox name, so any bug reports you get are  
likely to eventually be filed under "crazy [Mac] users".

In fact, while Googling to figure out why Dovecot wasn't working for  
me, I came across at least one poster to this mailing list who had  
discovered that Mail.app was using "/" as a delimiter.  I can't be
sure, but I'm guessing that his problem was related to mine.

Since the patch is tiny and doesn't hurt performance or make Dovecot  
do anything that contradicts the IMAP RFC, I hope you'll consider  
adding it to the official distribution.

-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: lsub-delimiter.patch
Type: application/octet-stream
Size: 1040 bytes
Desc: not available
URL:
<http://dovecot.org/pipermail/dovecot/attachments/20070424/2d8f6b14/attachment-0002.obj>
-------------- next part --------------


Eyvind Bernhardsen

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Eyvind Bernhardsen schrieb:
> The LSUB command does not act like LIST when provided with an empty mask
> argument.  LIST responds with the hierarchy delimiter:
> 
>     * LIST (\Noselect) "." ""
>     OK List completed.
> 
> whereas LSUB doesn't return anything useful:
> 
>     OK Lsub completed.
> 
> RFC 3501 doesn't specify what LSUB should do in this case, but Courier
> IMAP has LSUB act like LIST.  The attached patch modifies
> imap/cmd-list.c to make Dovecot do the same.
> 
> 
> Why do I care about LSUB?  I'm using a hack for Apple Mail that
replaces
> its LIST command with LSUB (something like what's described here:
> http://www.macosxhints.com/article.php?story=20040407062603804), to
> prevent it from syncing public folders from the Exchange server at the
> office.
> 
> The hack replaces _all_ LISTs with LSUBs, including the LIST ""
""
> Mail.app sends to discover the hierarchy delimiter.  Since dovecot
> doesn't give it any information in response to LSUB ""
"", Mail.app
> defaults to using "/" as a delimiter, which means that trying to
access
> a subfolder only results in an "Invalid mailbox name" error.
> 
> While this isn't really a bug in Dovecot, it's not inconceivable
that
> other people than me could be affected by this problem (macosxhints.com
> has a substantial readership).  It's also tricky to diagnose,
especially
> since the "Invalid mailbox name" message doesn't include the
invalid
> mailbox name, so any bug reports you get are likely to eventually be
> filed under "crazy [Mac] users".
> 
> In fact, while Googling to figure out why Dovecot wasn't working for
me,
> I came across at least one poster to this mailing list who had
> discovered that Mail.app was using "/" as a delimiter.  I
can't be sure,
> but I'm guessing that his problem was related to mine.
> 
> Since the patch is tiny and doesn't hurt performance or make Dovecot do
> anything that contradicts the IMAP RFC, I hope you'll consider adding
it
> to the official distribution.
> 
> 
> 
> Eyvind Bernhardsen
> 
Hi,
as i have one customer on courier only with apple mail
i got known of so many bugs with imap that i must say this is a broken
client in my eyes

- --
Mit freundlichen Gruessen
Best Regards

Robert Schetterer

https://www.schetterer.org
Munich/Bavaria/Germany
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.5 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with SUSE - http://enigmail.mozdev.org

iD8DBQFGL5i6fGH2AvR16oERAk69AKCARWEsgCfLg31M/dfhbkA3d7HxKACghUAZ
Iwf6pBuHOxxpzbHy0DGiv6M=sGPi
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----