This seems to be a common topic but I haven't seen anyone ask this exact question and get a decent answer: I use virtual mailboxes with all of the db's in LDAP. Last night I upgraded to the latest CVS version of dovecot and dovecot-lda and got global sieve filtering working by setting the global_script_path to a sieve like /home/vmail/mydomain/sieve and it works great. Now I need to figure out how to get per-user sieve filtering to work. I googled on this and found: http://www.dovecot.org/list/dovecot/2005-August/008568.html How do I tell dovecot where the "virtual home directory" is? Yes, I could use /home/vmail/mydomain/user as my virtual home directory (that is where I originally tried to put .dovecot.sieve but it did not seem to work) but I don't see how I can tell dovecot about it. I see that in deliver.c #define SIEVE_SCRIPT_PATH "~/.dovecot.sieve" we hard code SIEVE_SCRIPT_PATH with the home dir location. Am I going to have to replace this with some code that generates an appropriate path for my system or is there a better way? And while I am here: Has any thought been given to being able to pull sieve scripts from LDAP? At the moment sieve really does not buy me much because the end users still do not have any way to edit their sieve files on the server (no shells and can't code sieve's language) but it would be nice if I could create a web interface somewhere which could generate basic filters from templates and store their sieve filters in LDAP so I didn't have to deal with somehow writing to files in their virtual home dirs on the mail server. I have found old conversations such as: http://www.mhonarc.org/archive/html/ietf-mta-filters/1999-06/msg00000.html but do not see where any standard way of doing this has come about. Or really even any implementations at all of sieve stored in LDAP. Thanks! -- Tracy R Reed http://ultraviolet.org A: Because we read from top to bottom, left to right Q: Why should I start my reply below the quoted text
On Wed, 2006-05-24 at 14:04 -0700, Tracy R Reed wrote:> This seems to be a common topic but I haven't seen anyone ask this exact > question and get a decent answer: > > I use virtual mailboxes with all of the db's in LDAP. Last night I > upgraded to the latest CVS version of dovecot and dovecot-lda and got > global sieve filtering working by setting the global_script_path to a > sieve like /home/vmail/mydomain/sieve and it works great. Now I need to > figure out how to get per-user sieve filtering to work. I googled on > this and found: > > http://www.dovecot.org/list/dovecot/2005-August/008568.html > > How do I tell dovecot where the "virtual home directory" is? Yes, I > could use /home/vmail/mydomain/user as my virtual home directory (that > is where I originally tried to put .dovecot.sieve but it did not seem to > work) but I don't see how I can tell dovecot about it. I see that in > deliver.c > > #define SIEVE_SCRIPT_PATH "~/.dovecot.sieve" > > we hard code SIEVE_SCRIPT_PATH with the home dir location. Am I going to > have to replace this with some code that generates an appropriate path > for my system or is there a better way? > > And while I am here: Has any thought been given to being able to pull > sieve scripts from LDAP? At the moment sieve really does not buy me much > because the end users still do not have any way to edit their sieve > files on the server (no shells and can't code sieve's language) but it > would be nice if I could create a web interface somewhere which could > generate basic filters from templates and store their sieve filters in > LDAP so I didn't have to deal with somehow writing to files in their > virtual home dirs on the mail server. I have found old conversations > such as: > > http://www.mhonarc.org/archive/html/ietf-mta-filters/1999-06/msg00000.html > > but do not see where any standard way of doing this has come about. Or > really even any implementations at all of sieve stored in LDAP.While I don't have a solution I can add a "me too" to needing an answer to this in the near future. I would expect that virtual hosting with LDAP or sql backends and no shell is quite a common occurrence. Karl.
On Wed, May 24, 2006 at 02:04:43PM -0700, Tracy R Reed wrote:> How do I tell dovecot where the "virtual home directory" is? Yes, I > could use /home/vmail/mydomain/user as my virtual home directory (that > is where I originally tried to put .dovecot.sieve but it did not seem to > work) but I don't see how I can tell dovecot about it. I see that in > deliver.cWe had virtual per-user home directories working practically out of the box with: user_attrs = uid,homeDirectory,mailDirectory,mailQuota=quota,mailClass=mailclass in dovecot-ldap.conf. ~/.dovecot.sieve is automatically honored, if it exists, where ~ is replaced with the value of homeDirectory. (The LDAP attributes you don't recognise are just ia5strings in our own schema). What's your user_attrs setting? Joshua. -- Josh "Koshua" Goodall "as modern as tomorrow afternoon" joshua at roughtrade.net - FW109