R help - Nov 2007 - decompose () vs stl () - reference search

Hi,

I have been having trouble finding references that compare the classical
decomposition methods [function decompose()] with the STL method of
Cleveland et al. (1990) [function stl()]. The decompose() help page refers
to the method as a ?much more sophisticated decomposition? but I am looking
for something more than this :). Can anybody supply me with some references
that may make comparisons between the two methods and/or discuss the
advantage/disadvantages of each one in different situations?

Thanks in advance,

Nuno Prista

______________________________________________ 
Instituto de Oceanografia - FCUL, Portugal
Center for Quantitative Fisheries Ecology - ODU, USA
?
Present address:
Center for Quantitative Fisheries Ecology - ODU
800W 46th Street
Norfolk, VA 23508
USA

Hi,

I have been having trouble finding references that compare the classical
decomposition methods [decompose()] with the STL method of
Cleveland et al. (1990) [stl()].

Can anybody indicate some references that make comparisons between the two
methods and the advantage/disadvantages of each one in different situations?

Thanks in advance,

Nuno

______________________________________________ 
Instituto de Oceanografia - FCUL, Portugal
Center for Quantitative Fisheries Ecology - ODU, USA