I have a data A which looks like author_id paper_id prob 731 24943 1 731 24943 1 731 688974 1 731 964345 .8 731 1201905 .9 731 1267992 1 736 249 .2 736 6889 1 736 94345 .7 736 1201905 .9 736 126992 .8 The output I am desiring is: author_id paper_id 731 24943,24943,688974,1201905,964345 736 6889,1201945,126992,94345,249 That is paper_id are arranged according to decreasing order of probability.How could this be done? Thanks [[alternative HTML version deleted]]