R help - Jun 2013 - Clogit R and Stata

Sorry to once again write a message but I'm once again stumped and am having
no luck finding a solution anywhere else.


This question requires some finesse in both R and STATA so hopefully I will be
able to get an answer here. I am much more adept in R and am trying to replicate
the results of a STATA file in R. Hopefully this is a proper forum for such
questions. 


This is the code for the clogit in STATA
clogit sftpcons sftptv2a3 sftptv2a4 sftptv2a5 sftptv2a2 sftptv2a6 logim maccat
disp4cat if sample==1 & glb_ind=="Y", group(stratida)
and I tried to replicate it using
clogit1<-clogit(sftpcons~sftptv2a3+sftptv2a4+sftptv2a5+sftptv2a2+sftptv2a6+logim+maccat+disp4cat+strata(stratida),
dframe, sample==1 | glb_ind=="Y")
but got different results
What did I do wrong here? I interpreted the STATA clogit as run this logit as
long as the sample is 1 and glb_ind="Y" What should I be doing
instead?
	[[alternative HTML version deleted]]

On Jun 7, 2013, at 15:34 , Richard Beckett wrote:
> Sorry to once again write a message but I'm once again stumped and am
having no luck finding a solution anywhere else.
> 
> 
> This question requires some finesse in both R and STATA so hopefully I will
be able to get an answer here. I am much more adept in R and am trying to
replicate the results of a STATA file in R. Hopefully this is a proper forum for
such questions.
> 
> 
> This is the code for the clogit in STATA
> clogit sftpcons sftptv2a3 sftptv2a4 sftptv2a5 sftptv2a2 sftptv2a6 logim
maccat disp4cat if sample==1 & glb_ind=="Y", group(stratida)
> and I tried to replicate it using
>
clogit1<-clogit(sftpcons~sftptv2a3+sftptv2a4+sftptv2a5+sftptv2a2+sftptv2a6+logim+maccat+disp4cat+strata(stratida),
dframe, sample==1 | glb_ind=="Y")
> but got different results
> What did I do wrong here? I interpreted the STATA clogit as run this logit
as long as the sample is 1 and glb_ind="Y" What should I be doing
instead?

An "&" rather than "|" in the R version might help.
Other than that, we're a bit short on clues unless you provide some output.

-- 
Peter Dalgaard, Professor,
Center for Statistics, Copenhagen Business School
Solbjerg Plads 3, 2000 Frederiksberg, Denmark
Phone: (+45)38153501
Email: pd.mes at cbs.dk  Priv: PDalgd at gmail.com