When people have audio trouble with programs in wine the first suggestion is always to remove pulseaudio, I'm not questing that - it often fixes the problem, but I do wonder if there are plans to make wine and pulseaudio work better together? Each new version of the major Linux distros seems to make pulse harder and harder to remove without messing up the system. Outside of wine pulse is great to keep installed for simplicity of audio management. In wine, default install going to pulse instead of alsa/oss, pulse works fine for all my game sound (WoW, CoH/V, Eve) it just falls over in Ventrilo and Teamspeak (I use the windows version through wine because the native Linux version has horrible sound quality). Are there any plans to help wine and pulse get along, and/or is there anyone working on this that we non-programmers can help by testing sound out on our systems and sending info to?
>When people have audio trouble with programs in wine the first >suggestion is always to remove pulseaudio, I'm not questing that - it >often fixes the problem, but I do wonder if there are plans to make wine >and pulseaudio work better together? > >Each new version of the major Linux distros seems to make pulse harder >and harder to remove without messing up the system. Outside of wine >pulse is great to keep installed for simplicity of audio management. > >In wine, default install going to pulse instead of alsa/oss, pulse works >fine for all my game sound (WoW, CoH/V, Eve) it just falls over in >Ventrilo and Teamspeak (I use the windows version through wine because >the native Linux version has horrible sound quality). > >Are there any plans to help wine and pulse get along, and/or is there >anyone working on this that we non-programmers can help by testing sound >out on our systems and sending info to?The problem with posting this on the wine list right now is that Linux (Ubuntu) is changing so fast that the rules seem to be re-written daily -- that is, if you keep up with the latest distro and all the upgrades, as I do. On my machine, for a long time only OSS worked. Last Thursday Alsa worked. Last Friday nothing worked, and it still doesn't. Pasuspender used to work, but now it doesn't. Padsp with OSS used to work. Now they don't. Killall pulseaudio worked if you edited /etc/pulse/client.conf to change "autospawn" to "no." See Ubuntu bug 409395, for example. Major upgrades are expected again, and soon. I'm ready for a pulseaudio vacation.
tparker wrote:> I do wonder if there are plans to make wine and pulseaudio work better together?Nothing real AFAIK, aside from hordes of unsatisfied users wanting something right now. The only real thing that did happen is some set of questionable quality patches in bugzilla. Unfortunately those patches are not good enough to be included into Wine.
You can quite easily get pulseaudio working well. Follow this guide:
http://pulseaudio.org/wiki/PerfectSetup .
http://pulseaudio.org/wiki/PerfectSetup
The general gist of it is that you need to set wine to use the alsa output
and then edit your .asoundrc file in your home directory to contain:
pcm.!default {
type pulse
}
ctrl.!default {
type pulse
}
Please note that I just wrote those lines from memory and your best to check
it with the Perfect setup guide.
2009/8/18 vitamin <wineforum-user at winehq.org>
>
> tparker wrote:
> > I do wonder if there are plans to make wine and pulseaudio work better
> together?
>
> Nothing real AFAIK, aside from hordes of unsatisfied users wanting
> something right now.
>
> The only real thing that did happen is some set of questionable quality
> patches in bugzilla. Unfortunately those patches are not good enough to be
> included into Wine.
>
>
>
>
>
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL:
<http://www.winehq.org/pipermail/wine-users/attachments/20090819/ce16297e/attachment.htm>
>The general gist of it is that you need to set wine to use the alsa output >and then edit your .asoundrc file in your home directory to contain:We don't have that any more. Asoundconf was discontinued in alsa-utils as of the current version. Getting it requires regressing alsa-utils.