Speex dev - Jul 2009 - VAD performance worse on version 1.2rc1 than 1.1.12

Hi, I decide to write to the list because of a strange behaviour when
updating from version 1.1.12 to 1.2rc1.

My software was running fine with version 1.1.12, but now I want to benefit
from advances on AEC.
After updating the library to 1.2rc1 and do few changes on my sources, I run
the application and discovered that VAD doesn't work so fine as in previous
version 1.1.12 (3 years ago).

I have seem on speex sources that the VAD is under reconstruction, but I
don't understand why it has been replaced with that poor one and it
hasn't
been repaired after 2 years from 1.2beta1.

Is there a way to use the VAD like the one in version 1.1.12 and benefit
from advances in version 1.2?

Merci Jean-Marc, j'esp?re que tu pourras m'aider.



Cecile Dumotier.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL:
http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/speex-dev/attachments/20090727/dcb648f3/attachment.htm

Hi, I decide to write to the list because of a strange behaviour when
updating from version 1.1.12 to 1.2rc1.

My software was running fine with version 1.1.12, but now I want to benefit
from advances on AEC.
After updating the library to 1.2rc1 and do few changes on my sources, I run
the application and discovered that VAD doesn't work so fine as in previous
version 1.1.12 (3 years ago).

I have seem on speex sources that the VAD is under reconstruction, but I
don't understand why it has been replaced with that poor one and it
hasn't
been repaired after 2 years from 1.2beta1.

Is there a way to use the VAD like the one in version 1.1.12 and benefit
from advances in version 1.2?

Merci Jean-Marc, j'esp?re que tu pourras m'aider.



Cecile Dumotier.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL:
http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/speex-dev/attachments/20090731/f7d26c5b/attachment.htm

Hi Cecile,

it seems it is a tabu theme, or nobody uses VAD on speex. I've tried 
with external EasyVAD solution but the result was not as spected.
Other users of the list suggest an algorithm to filter voice based on 
the power of the signal, but of course, it is not a voice activity 
detection.

I am waiting also a solution for this, while so I use version 1.1.12.

Regards.


Cecile Dumotier escribi?:
> Hi, I decide to write to the list because of a strange behaviour when 
> updating from version 1.1.12 to 1.2rc1.
>
> My software was running fine with version 1.1.12, but now I want to 
> benefit from advances on AEC.
> After updating the library to 1.2rc1 and do few changes on my sources, 
> I run the application and discovered that VAD doesn't work so fine as 
> in previous version 1.1.12 (3 years ago).
>
> I have seem on speex sources that the VAD is under reconstruction, but 
> I don't understand why it has been replaced with that poor one and it 
> hasn't been repaired after 2 years from 1.2beta1.
>
> Is there a way to use the VAD like the one in version 1.1.12 and 
> benefit from advances in version 1.2?
>
> Merci Jean-Marc, j'esp?re que tu pourras m'aider.
>
>
>
> Cecile Dumotier.
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> _______________________________________________
> Speex-dev mailing list
> Speex-dev at xiph.org
> http://lists.xiph.org/mailman/listinfo/speex-dev
>