Jeff Sadowski
2016-Dec-02 15:28 UTC
[Samba] Future AD domain currently want FreeRadius Samba or FreeIPA?
My main home server runs Fedora 25. I have experimented in the past with an Ubuntu samba AD domain controller(in a VM). Which was really cool because I could join Windows 10 pro machines to it and assign GPO's just like my AD at work. Currently I'm looking into setting up a FreeRadius server. I want to eventually be able to have the same authentication across machines and wifi and the lot. And I'd like to set up machines using GPO's. It looks like Fedora is working on getting FreeIPA as the LDAP for AD samba? Is this correct? If I set up FreeIPA as my LDAP and connect my FreeRadius server to authenticate against it; would I then, in the not to distant future, be able to set up samba to use it for an AD domain that I could set up GPO's for? Or would I be better of using my AD DC VM as my LDAP server?
Andrew Bartlett
2016-Dec-02 18:35 UTC
[Samba] Future AD domain currently want FreeRadius Samba or FreeIPA?
On Fri, 2016-12-02 at 08:28 -0700, Jeff Sadowski via samba wrote:> My main home server runs Fedora 25. I have experimented in the past > with an > Ubuntu samba AD domain controller(in a VM). Which was really cool > because I > could join Windows 10 pro machines to it and assign GPO's just like > my AD > at work. Currently I'm looking into setting up a FreeRadius server. I > want > to eventually be able to have the same authentication across machines > and > wifi and the lot. And I'd like to set up machines using GPO's. It > looks > like Fedora is working on getting FreeIPA as the LDAP for AD samba? > Is this > correct? > > If I set up FreeIPA as my LDAP and connect my FreeRadius server to > authenticate against it; would I then, in the not to distant future, > be > able to set up samba to use it for an AD domain that I could set up > GPO's > for?No. Samba can't use another LDAP server as a backend, when acting as an AD DC. We may be able to trust it with an inter-forest trust, but that is a very different thing.> Or would I be better of using my AD DC VM as my LDAP server?I think so. Andrew Bartlett