Hello, I am beginner of Samba, but today I have made update of Samba to RC3. I have two users:root and tomek. tomek is in linux groups: smbadmins, smbusers and nothing more. There is a folder for everyone and file made by the root in it: total 4 -rw------- 1 root root 1195 Jul 1 00:11 group.txt User tomek is not able to read the file, but is able to delete it, why? I have no entries in group map. -- Pozdrawiam, "Przeznaczenie - wym?wka g?upca w chwili kl?ski", Wywrotowiec
On Sat, Jul 01, 2006 at 12:20:42AM +0200, TSZ wrote:> Hello, > > I am beginner of Samba, but today I have made update of Samba to RC3. I > have two users:root and tomek. tomek is in linux groups: smbadmins, > smbusers and nothing more. There is a folder for everyone and file made > by the root in it: > > total 4 -rw------- 1 root root 1195 Jul 1 00:11 group.txt > > User tomek is not able to read the file, but is able to delete it, why? > I have no entries in group map.Because in UNIX, permission to delete a file is granted by the permissions on the directory containing it, not on the file itself. Jeremy.
and you can solve this with the sticky bit http://docsrv.sco.com:507/en/OSAdminG/ssC.stickydirs.html you could also try to play with "map read only (S)" parameter. greez Jeremy Allison wrote:> On Sat, Jul 01, 2006 at 12:20:42AM +0200, TSZ wrote: > >>Hello, >> >>I am beginner of Samba, but today I have made update of Samba to RC3. I >>have two users:root and tomek. tomek is in linux groups: smbadmins, >>smbusers and nothing more. There is a folder for everyone and file made >>by the root in it: >> >>total 4 -rw------- 1 root root 1195 Jul 1 00:11 group.txt >> >>User tomek is not able to read the file, but is able to delete it, why? >>I have no entries in group map. > > > Because in UNIX, permission to delete a file is granted by the > permissions on the directory containing it, not on the file > itself. > > Jeremy.