Orange Ubuntero
2012-Aug-25 09:02 UTC
[opus] Why does opus scale down frequency from 22k to 20k ?
Why does opus scale down frequency from 22k to 20k ? 64kbps<https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-DGsEd1ijTBs/UDE3OFVrE5I/AAAAAAAADBo/bFcWQ6I4-Zk/s588/opus_64_test.png> 128kbps<https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-3Wfvq6OPGRw/UDE3OClxEdI/AAAAAAAADBk/vsBJ9Gcd_pU/s589/opus_test.png> 192kbps<https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-tfDAtdGM2Aw/UDE3N3mrFJI/AAAAAAAADBg/38weacOnQ7I/s588/opus_192_test.png> this action will affect the quality of audio. *Can this feature be disable in future ?* And *Can opus add no noise and echo in audio at high kbps *(192kbps +) *?* -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/opus/attachments/20120825/4ba237ff/attachment.htm
Timothy B. Terriberry
2012-Aug-25 14:12 UTC
[opus] Why does opus scale down frequency from 22k to 20k ?
Orange Ubuntero wrote:> this action will affect the quality of audio.Any affect will be inaudible to human ears. For a more detailed explanation, see http://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html> *Can this feature be disable in future ?*No. It is not possible to encode information for frequencies above 20 kHz in the bitstream, even if an encoder wanted to.> *Can opus add no noise and echo in audio at high kbps *(192kbps +) *?*Opus is a lossy codec, so it will always change the numerical values in the actual signal. But if you can find a sample that you can distinguish from the original in an ABX _listening_ test (as opposed to by looking at a spectrogram) at 192 kbps, then we'd certainly be interested in knowing about it.