flac dev - Sep 2004 - cd archival (revisited/again)

merry christmas everybody.

i've recently begun working on a project to load my cds and i must say
single file flac-as-a-cd-container with an embedded cuesheet is
brilliant.  So i figured no problem.  rip, single file flac and then its
just a matter of playlists and such...  a nobrainer... but i keep
getting stuck.

ok, so what i set out to do is simple.  read cds into either pcm or
lossless compression.  but i want it to play nice with playlists (by
selecting song/album names).  also would like to take a defined playlist
and convert to lossy format flavor of the month for portables.  would
also like to have a small computer integrated into home theater system
so i can do digital audio out and IR remote control.  (playstation2
seems ideal except for the cost of linux).

ok, so nothing new, but i'm trying to do a good job, so i have a plextor
drive and so far i've only found one ripper that supports the plextor
perfect audio extraction - cdrdao driver=plextor-scan.  can't beat it. 
you do 2 consecutive rips and md5sum's are the same.

this means i'm stuck with toc files and toc2cue seems a bit orphaned. 
it created zero length cue files so i put a out.close(); in the
appropriate place and now it works, but the cue file seems kind of
minimal.  i would prefer to transfer all the info to the flac file if
possible.  is there a cuesheet syntax document someplace?

so next task is to add song titles and such.  (assuming single
flac-as-cd-container with embedded cuesheet), I looked all over and I
can't find anything which discusses vorbis comments where file is not
1-to-1 with track.  I read a little bit of xmms flac plugin trying to
see how it parses flac files but i didn't see anything.  is it supported
at all?

i would also be interested if anybody has any favorite playlist editors
which can deal with flac-as-cd-container and then batch encode to lossy.
(if everything works under linux that would be ideal).

sorry for all the basic questions, but i'm willing to do a little bit of
plumbing to get this to fly.  i just need to understand how it should
work...

if you got this far, thank you for reading my diatribe :)

jason

--- jason <jason@doomba.com> wrote:
> is there a cuesheet syntax document someplace?
it's not really standardized that well.   there are some links
here: http://flac.sourceforge.net/documentation.html (search
for --cuesheet)
 
> so next task is to add song titles and such.  (assuming single
> flac-as-cd-container with embedded cuesheet), I looked all over and I
> can't find anything which discusses vorbis comments where file is not
> 1-to-1 with track.  I read a little bit of xmms flac plugin trying to
> see how it parses flac files but i didn't see anything.  is it
> supported
> at all?
none of that is standardized.  there's a question in the faq
as to why it isn't.

Josh


__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Protect your identity with Yahoo! Mail AddressGuard
http://antispam.yahoo.com/whatsnewfree

On Thu, 2003-12-25 at 21:35, Josh Coalson wrote:
> --- jason <jason@doomba.com> wrote:
> > is there a cuesheet syntax document someplace?
> it's not really standardized that well.   there are some links
> here: http://flac.sourceforge.net/documentation.html (search
> for --cuesheet)
hmmmm.... i just reread the faq and your right... i'm kind of losing
interest in cuesheets except as a mechanism for preserving everything
the cd stored.

>  
> > so next task is to add song titles and such.  (assuming single
> > flac-as-cd-container with embedded cuesheet), I looked all over and I
> > can't find anything which discusses vorbis comments where file is
not
> > 1-to-1 with track.  I read a little bit of xmms flac plugin trying to
> > see how it parses flac files but i didn't see anything.  is it
> > supported
> > at all?
> none of that is standardized.  there's a question in the faq
> as to why it isn't.
> 
even better.  i'll just do my own thing then.  I'm thinking XML.  throw
together a DTD or something and go from there.  or is there a better way
(IE: has anybody already suggested?)

after all, for my purposes, i'm just preserving information until such
time that a real system is devised, and then I'll convert.

jason