On 1 Mar 2020, at 20:00, Gordon Messmer wrote:> On 3/1/20 12:40 AM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: >> borgbackup is a very interesting backup tool with a lot of features. >> It is ready for "production" or I should expect some bad surprise? > > > I don't know the answer to that, but to me that implies two questions: > 1) Are there failure conditions that it doesn't handle, especially > with an interrupted backup, and 2) Does it perform poorly under any > specific circumstances.? If anyone has experience with those > questions, or is familiar enough with the implementation to explain > why those should not be an issue, I'd be interested in their input as > well. > > I use borgbackup for several laptops backing up to a local file server > with sshfs, and that's been good so far.We have around 50 linux clients with borg backups to two different backup server, provisioned with Ansible. A new host is in the backup in around 30 seconds :) One backup server is internal for DMZ and LAN and one is for external hosts. The internal backup server syncs its backup to the external server. Storage is made with ZFS summed up to 16 TB each server. This runs nicely for around two years without interruption. We learned a bit her e and there about some side effects with borg cache in the beginning and invested some time in hardening and Ansible role. Before we choosed borg restic was on the list. Looks good too. Do not now anymore why we decided for borg. Maybe the name :) We startet here https://borgbackup.readthedocs.io/en/stable/deployment/central-backup-server.html Tobias -- collect at shift.agency
On 3/1/20 11:18 AM, Tobias Kirchhofer wrote:> This runs nicely for around two years without interruption.It's been working for me, too, but I think that people who've seen the tool fail are better equipped to answer whether a tool is "production ready" than those who haven't.
Il 01/03/20 20:18, Tobias Kirchhofer ha scritto:> On 1 Mar 2020, at 20:00, Gordon Messmer wrote: > >> On 3/1/20 12:40 AM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: >>> borgbackup is a very interesting backup tool with a lot of features. >>> It is ready for "production" or I should expect some bad surprise? >> >> >> I don't know the answer to that, but to me that implies two >> questions: 1) Are there failure conditions that it doesn't handle, >> especially with an interrupted backup, and 2) Does it perform poorly >> under any specific circumstances.? If anyone has experience with >> those questions, or is familiar enough with the implementation to >> explain why those should not be an issue, I'd be interested in their >> input as well. >> >> I use borgbackup for several laptops backing up to a local file >> server with sshfs, and that's been good so far. > > We have around 50 linux clients with borg backups to two different > backup server, provisioned with Ansible. A new host is in the backup > in around 30 seconds :) One backup server is internal for DMZ and LAN > and one is for external hosts. The internal backup server syncs its > backup to the external server. Storage is made with ZFS summed up to > 16 TB each server. > > This runs nicely for around two years without interruption. We learned > a bit her e and there about some side effects with borg cache in the > beginning and invested some time in hardening and Ansible role. > > Before we choosed borg restic was on the list. Looks good too. Do not > now anymore why we decided for borg. Maybe the name :) > > We startet here > https://borgbackup.readthedocs.io/en/stable/deployment/central-backup-server.html > > Tobias >Hi Tobias, How do you secure the process? Thanks in advance
On 2 Mar 2020, at 12:58, Alessandro Baggi wrote:> Il 01/03/20 20:18, Tobias Kirchhofer ha scritto: >> On 1 Mar 2020, at 20:00, Gordon Messmer wrote: >> >>> On 3/1/20 12:40 AM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: >>>> borgbackup is a very interesting backup tool with a lot of >>>> features. It is ready for "production" or I should expect some bad >>>> surprise? >>> >>> >>> I don't know the answer to that, but to me that implies two >>> questions: 1) Are there failure conditions that it doesn't handle, >>> especially with an interrupted backup, and 2) Does it perform poorly >>> under any specific circumstances.? If anyone has experience with >>> those questions, or is familiar enough with the implementation to >>> explain why those should not be an issue, I'd be interested in their >>> input as well. >>> >>> I use borgbackup for several laptops backing up to a local file >>> server with sshfs, and that's been good so far. >> >> We have around 50 linux clients with borg backups to two different >> backup server, provisioned with Ansible. A new host is in the backup >> in around 30 seconds :) One backup server is internal for DMZ and LAN >> and one is for external hosts. The internal backup server syncs its >> backup to the external server. Storage is made with ZFS summed up to >> 16 TB each server. >> >> This runs nicely for around two years without interruption. We >> learned a bit her e and there about some side effects with borg cache >> in the beginning and invested some time in hardening and Ansible >> role. >> >> Before we choosed borg restic was on the list. Looks good too. Do not >> now anymore why we decided for borg. Maybe the name :) >> >> We startet here >> https://borgbackup.readthedocs.io/en/stable/deployment/central-backup-server.html >> >> Tobias >> > Hi Tobias, > > How do you secure the process?Plain ssh: authorized_keys on the backup server: ``` ? command="borg serve --restrict-to-path /borgbackup/vm/host-name-of-backup-client --append-only" ssh-ed25519 AAAAC3NzaC1? root at host-name-of-backup-client ? ``` -- collect at shift.agency
On 2 Mar 2020, at 12:58, Alessandro Baggi wrote:> Il 01/03/20 20:18, Tobias Kirchhofer ha scritto: >> On 1 Mar 2020, at 20:00, Gordon Messmer wrote: >> >>> On 3/1/20 12:40 AM, Alessandro Baggi wrote: >>>> borgbackup is a very interesting backup tool with a lot of >>>> features. It is ready for "production" or I should expect some bad >>>> surprise? >>> >>> >>> I don't know the answer to that, but to me that implies two >>> questions: 1) Are there failure conditions that it doesn't handle, >>> especially with an interrupted backup, and 2) Does it perform poorly >>> under any specific circumstances.? If anyone has experience with >>> those questions, or is familiar enough with the implementation to >>> explain why those should not be an issue, I'd be interested in their >>> input as well. >>> >>> I use borgbackup for several laptops backing up to a local file >>> server with sshfs, and that's been good so far. >> >> We have around 50 linux clients with borg backups to two different >> backup server, provisioned with Ansible. A new host is in the backup >> in around 30 seconds :) One backup server is internal for DMZ and LAN >> and one is for external hosts. The internal backup server syncs its >> backup to the external server. Storage is made with ZFS summed up to >> 16 TB each server. >> >> This runs nicely for around two years without interruption. We >> learned a bit her e and there about some side effects with borg cache >> in the beginning and invested some time in hardening and Ansible >> role. >> >> Before we choosed borg restic was on the list. Looks good too. Do not >> now anymore why we decided for borg. Maybe the name :) >> >> We startet here >> https://borgbackup.readthedocs.io/en/stable/deployment/central-backup-server.html >> >> Tobias >> > Hi Tobias, > > How do you secure the process?On more thing - the borg mailing list is responsive. I had a question. Answer arrived directly https://www.borgbackup.org/support/free.html -- collect at shift.agency