Hello, now I have spent many hours to configure openswan for VPN connections without any success. My goal: VPN Server CentOS 6 with public IPv4 VPN Client (= road warrier) from private site with NAT router or from mobile cell with Linux, Windows 7, Mac, iPhone or Android Is there any how to in the net? When I read file:///usr/share/doc/openswan-doc-2.6.32/config.html then I belive, there is no solution. It is written, that I have to reconfigure the NAT router of the mobile provider or the hardware NAT router of the private dsl uplink. Both is impossible. Thank you for help in advance. Helmut Helmut Drodofsky Internet XS Service GmbH He?br?hlstra?e 15 70565 Stuttgart Gesch?ftsf?hrung Dr.-Ing. Roswitha Hahn-Drodofsky HRB 21091 Stuttgart USt.ID: DE190582774 Tel. 0711 781941 0 Fax: 0711 781941 79 Mail: info at internet-xs.de www.internet-xs.de
On Thu, Apr 5, 2012 at 9:55 AM, Helmut Drodofsky <drodofsky at internet-xs.de> wrote:> > now I have spent many hours to configure openswan for VPN connections > without any success. > > My goal: > > VPN Server CentOS 6 with public IPv4 > VPN Client (= road warrier) from private site with NAT router or from > mobile cell with Linux, Windows 7, Mac, iPhone or Android > > Is there any how to in the net? > > When I read > file:///usr/share/doc/openswan-doc-2.6.32/config.html > then I belive, there is no solution. It is written, that I have to > reconfigure the NAT router of the mobile provider or the hardware NAT > router of the private dsl uplink. > > Both is impossible. > > Thank you for help in advance.Can you use openvpn instead of IPsec? It can run over udp and is nat-friendly. I think you need root access on android and a jailbroken iphone to make the clients work there, though. -- Les Mikesell
On 04/05/2012 04:55 PM, Helmut Drodofsky wrote:> Hello, > > now I have spent many hours to configure openswan for VPN connections > without any success. > > My goal: > > VPN Server CentOS 6 with public IPv4 > VPN Client (= road warrier) from private site with NAT router or from > mobile cell with Linux, Windows 7, Mac, iPhone or Android > > Is there any how to in the net? > > When I read > file:///usr/share/doc/openswan-doc-2.6.32/config.html > then I belive, there is no solution. It is written, that I have to > reconfigure the NAT router of the mobile provider or the hardware NAT > router of the private dsl uplink. > > Both is impossible.Maybe you get better luck on the Openswan mailing list but I would not get my hopes up. One of the Openswan developers has repeatedly mentioned that IPsec does not like NAT. Les' suggestion to try OpenVPN is what I did and it works well assuming you can find the tun.ko kernel module for your Android phone. I don't know if there is an OpenVPN client for Windows phone or iPhone. Regards, Patrick
On Apr 5, 2012, at 10:55 AM, Helmut Drodofsky <drodofsky at internet-xs.de> wrote:> Hello, > > now I have spent many hours to configure openswan for VPN connections > without any success. > > My goal: > > VPN Server CentOS 6 with public IPv4 > VPN Client (= road warrier) from private site with NAT router or from > mobile cell with Linux, Windows 7, Mac, iPhone or Android > > Is there any how to in the net? > > When I read > file:///usr/share/doc/openswan-doc-2.6.32/config.html > then I belive, there is no solution. It is written, that I have to > reconfigure the NAT router of the mobile provider or the hardware NAT > router of the private dsl uplink. > > Both is impossible.Long, long time ago in a datacenter far far away I managed to cobble openswan/racoon to provide L2TP VPN connectivity for WinXP. It was a great big hack at the time, but it can be done. IPSec can work over NAT if the implementation supports the latest RFCs that allow for NAT traversal and I believe L2TP is the mobile IPSec VPN protocol of choice. It is basically PPTP wrapped in IPSec where the IPSec key is the client X.509 certificate and the PPTP uses mschap authentication. This is the most secure as it only allows those clients that have a certificate issued from your CA to connect. Don't have a CA, don't know about PKI, then use PPTP with 128-bit encryption as it's easier to get going and universally supported. -Ross