I'm currently looking to deploy an Asterisk server using an FXO media gateway to connect to the PSTN and was looking for any user experiences that may aid in selecting a gateway. Specifically i'm looking for a 4-port model under 500 dollars. Within this category exists: MediaTrix 1204 Grandstream GXW-4104 AudioCodes MP114 I've read over Voip-info.org regarding these products and numerous mentions of problematic setup and configuration seems to be a common theme. Can anyone provide a recommendation based on user experience? Feel free to suggest an alternative gateway if one stands out. Thanks, Jameson -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.digium.com/pipermail/asterisk-users/attachments/20070214/a6c7ab17/attachment.htm
On Thu, 15 Feb 2007, jameson asterisk wrote:> I'm currently looking to deploy an Asterisk server using an FXO media > gateway to connect to the PSTN and was looking for any user experiences that > may aid in selecting a gateway. Specifically i'm looking for a 4-port model > under 500 dollars. > > Within this category exists: > MediaTrix 1204 > Grandstream GXW-4104 > AudioCodes MP114 > > I've read over Voip-info.org regarding these products and numerous mentions > of problematic setup and configuration seems to be a common theme. > > Can anyone provide a recommendation based on user experience? > Feel free to suggest an alternative gateway if one stands out.I've no experience of anything like this other than experiments with a Grandtream HT-488 (one port), but I'm curious as to why you want an external box to do the work rather than put a PCI card inside your asterisk box (eg. Digium TDM400, Sangoma, etc.) Gordon
On Feb 15, 2007, at 1:12 AM, jameson asterisk wrote:> Can anyone provide a recommendation based on user experience? > Feel free to suggest an alternative gateway if one stands out.I've been working with the Grandstream GXW-4108 (the 8 port version of the 4108), and it was a rough start, but I *think* all my issues have been worked out. Initial setup wasn't too bad, it helped that I found someone else's notes on it on the Trixbox forum. It it hadn't been for two problems, I'd have probably been up and running with it in just a few hours. The two issues I had were 1: I had major logging problems that I originally blamed on the GXW, but turned out to by my syslog server. When I changed to a different syslog server, the GXW's logs started working fantastically. I needed that logging to debug the 2nd issue. The 2nd problem was more involved, the GXW didn't like my PSTN connection. It worked wonderfully when connected to my VoIP ATA, but when I went to PSTN, it had all sorts of problems. I had some back and forth dialog with Grandstream and they think they found the problem and fixed it, and sent me a beta test firmware to try out. I put that online yesterday, and so far it has been working fine, but yesterday my office was closed due to snow, so I wasn't able to really stress test it (but I also was not able to reproduce my PSTN connection problem, which previously I could do with ease, so it gives me hope that the problem is indeed fixed). I'll know better today when the office is open and I expect the 8 lines to be in use for a good part of the day with a solid mix of inbound and outbound calling. If all goes well, then I might be able to recommend the GXW-410x as a viable unit. However, it does have one feature that might be a show stopper for some. It selects the next outbound FXO port in a round robin manner. There does not appear to be port level control over which FXO port is used on a given outbound call. This is probably fine for most of the targeted users (going on price, I'd say they are aiming at the SoHo market, which is likely to have a single bank of numbers in a single hunt group, so round robin would work fine). But for some, this could be a show stopper and prevent them from being able to use the unit. I personally have to see if it is going to work for me as I actually have two different hunt groups in my 8 lines, so round robin is less than ideal for me as it can cause one group to busy out from outbound calls, while the other has no calls at all. I do plan to send a feature request to Grandstream to give better control over selecting outbound ports. -chris <www.mythtech.net>
On 2007-02-14 22:12:23 -0800, "jameson asterisk" <mp3man.ast@gmail.com> said:> > > I'm currently looking to deploy an Asterisk server using an FXO media > gateway to connect to the PSTN and was looking for any user experiences that > may aid in selecting a gateway. Specifically i'm looking for a 4-port model > under 500 dollars. > Within this category exists: > MediaTrix 1204 > Grandstream GXW-4104 > AudioCodes MP114 > > I've read over Voip-info.org regarding these products and numerous mentions > of problematic setup and configuration seems to be a common theme. > > Can anyone provide a recommendation based on user experience? > Feel free to suggest an alternative gateway if one stands out.I am using the Audiocodes 114 and it's very reliable and passes good quality audio for all of my users. I would stay away from Grandstream, unless you want grey hair. There are MANY configuration options on the Audiocodes unit, which I see as a positive, but it might also increase the initial setup and learning curve. Marty
Linksys SPA400 is a 4 port FXO gateway. Cameron ___________________________________________________________ New Yahoo! Mail is the ultimate force in competitive emailing. Find out more at the Yahoo! Mail Championships. Plus: play games and win prizes. http://uk.rd.yahoo.com/evt=44106/*http://mail.yahoo.net/uk -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.digium.com/pipermail/asterisk-users/attachments/20070228/2989c0ab/attachment.htm