Attached is an updated version of the FAQ, to be released right after 0.50 is out. Please have a look, and let me know where improvements are needed. Thanks, -k ******************************************* R FAQ Kurt Hornik v0.1-0, 1997/04/16 This document contains answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about R. Feedback is welcome. ______________________________________________________________________ Table of Contents: 1. Introduction 1.1. Legalese 1.2. Obtaining this Document 1.3. Notation 1.4. Feedback 2. R Basics 2.1. What Is R? 2.2. What Machines Does R Run on? 2.3. What Is the Current Version of R? 2.4. How Can R Be Obtained? 2.5. How Can R Be Installed? 2.5.1. How Can R Be Installed (Unix) 2.5.2. How Can R Be Installed (Windows) 2.5.3. How Can R Be Installed (Macintosh) 2.6. Are there Unix Binaries for R? 2.7. Which Documentation Exists for R? 2.8. Which Mailing Lists Exist for R? 2.9. What is CRAN? 3. R and S 3.1. What Is S? 3.2. What Is S-PLUS? 3.3. What Are the Differences between R and S? 4. R Add-On Packages 4.1. Which Add-on Packages Exist for R? 4.2. How Can Add-on Packages Be Installed? 4.3. How Can Add-on Packages Be Used? 4.4. How Can I Contribute to R? 5. R and Emacs 5.1. Is there Emacs Support for R? 5.2. Should I Run R from Within Emacs? 6. R Miscellania 6.1. How Can I Read a Large Data Set into R? 6.2. Why Can't R Source a `Correct' File? 6.3. How Can I Set Components of a List to NULL? 6.4. How Can I Save My Workspace? 6.5. How Can I Clean Up My Workspace? 7. Acknowledgments ______________________________________________________________________ 1. Introduction This document contains answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about R. 1.1. Legalese This document is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2, or (at your option) any later version. This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU General Public License for more details. If you do not have a copy of the GNU General Public License, write to the Free Software Foundation, 59 Temple Place - Suite 330, Boston, MA 02111-1307, USA. 1.2. Obtaining this Document The latest version of this document is always available from http://www.ci.tuwien.ac.at/~hornik/R/R-FAQ.html. From there, you can also obtain versions converted to plain ASCII text, DVI, and PostScript, as well as the SGML source used for creating all these formats using the SGML-Tools (formerly Linuxdoc- SGML) system. 1.3. Notation Everything should be pretty standard. `R>' is used for the R prompt, and a `$' for the shell prompt (where applicable). 1.4. Feedback Feedback is of course most welcome. In particular, note that I do not have access to Windows or Mac systems. If you have information on these systems that you think should be added to this document, please let me know. 2. R Basics 2.1. What Is R? R is a system for statistical computation and graphics. It consists of a language plus a run-time environment with graphics, a debugger, access to certain system functions, and the ability to run programs stored in script files. The design of R has been heavily influenced by two existing languages: Becker, Chambers & Wilks' S (see question ``What is S?'') and Sussman's Scheme. Whereas the resulting language is very similar in appearance to S, the underlying implementation and semantics are derived from Scheme. See question ``What Are the Differences between R and S?'' for a discussion of the differences between R and S. R is being developed by Ross Ihaka and Robert Gentleman, two Senior Lecturers at the Department of Statistics of the University of Auckland in Auckland, New Zealand. R is free software distributed under a GNU-style copyleft. 2.2. What Machines Does R Run on? R is being developed for the Unix, Windows and Mac platforms. R will configure and build under a number of common Unix platforms including dec-alpha-osf, freebsd, hpux, linux-elf, sgi-irix, solaris, and sunos. If you know about other platforms, please drop me a note. 2.3. What Is the Current Version of R? The current Unix version is 0.50, the previous one was 0.16.1. The jump in the version number is deliberate, because 0.50 added group methods and complex numbers and hence more or less provides a full implementation of S as described in ``The New S Language''. The versions for Windows and Mac are pre-alpha. With some good luck, the Windows version will soon catch up with the Unix version. 2.4. How Can R Be Obtained? Sources, binaries and documentation for R can be obtained via CRAN, the ``Comprehensive R Archive Network'' (see question ``What is CRAN?''). 2.5. How Can R Be Installed? 2.5.1. How Can R Be Installed (Unix) If binaries are available for your platform (see question ``Are there Unix Binaries for R?''), you can use these, following the instructions that come with them. Otherwise, you can compile and install R yourself, which can be done very easily under a number of common Unix platforms (see question ``What Machines Does R Run on?''). The file INSTALL that comes with the R distribution contains instructions. Choose a place to install the R tree (R is not just a binary, but has additional data sets, help files, font metrics etc). Let's call this place RHOME (given appropriate permissions, a natural choice would be `/usr/local/lib/R'). Untar the source code, and issue the following commands (at the shell prompt): $ ./configure $ make $ make install-help You can also build a LaTeX version of the manual entries with $ make install-latex and an HTML version of the manual with $ make install-html If these commands execute successfully, the R binary will be copied to the `$RHOME/bin' directory. In addition, a shell script font-end called `R' will be created and copied to the same directory. You can copy this script to a place where users can invoke it, for example to `/usr/local/bin'. You could also copy the man page `R.1' to a place where your man reader finds it, such as `/usr/local/man/man1'. 2.5.2. How Can R Be Installed (Windows) Get the file `Rexe.zip' from the `bin/ms-windows' directory of a CRAN site. This archive contains a binary Windows 3.xx distribution for R and installation instructions. Robert Gentleman has recently made an updated pre-alpha Windows executable file available for ftp at ftp://stat.auckland.ac.nz/pub/research/rgentlem/rbeta.zip. This binary should be more compatible with Windows 95 than the other (he does not know about 3.1). You still need all the other extra files from the previous Windows distribution, it is only an executable. 2.5.3. How Can R Be Installed (Macintosh) CRAN sites have a directory `bin/macintosh' which contains `R.sea.hqx', a binhexed self-extracting archive, and installation instructions in `README.MACINTOSH'. 2.6. Are there Unix Binaries for R? Experimental `.deb' packages for installation under Debian GNU/Linux can be found in `bin/ix86-linux'. No other binaries distributions for Unix systems have thus far been made publically available. 2.7. Which Documentation Exists for R? Currently, there is no R manual. Online documentation for most of the functions and variables in R exists, and can be printed on-screen by typing help(name) (or ?name) at the R prompt, where name is the name of the R object help is sought for. (In the case of unary and binary operators and control-flow special forms, the name may need to be be quoted.) This documentation can also be made available as HTML, and as hardcopy via LaTeX, see question ``How Can R Be Installed?''. An up-to-date HTML version is always available for web browsing at http://www.stat.math.ethz.ch/R-manual In the absence of a systematic introduction to R, one can mostly get along with introductions to S or S-PLUS, such as ``Notes on S-PLUS: A Programming Environment for Data Analysis and Graphics'' by Bill Venables <venables@stats.adelaide.edu.au> and David Smith <D.M.Smith@lancaster.ac.uk>. This document talks mostly about plain S features, and does not concentrate on features specific to S-PLUS, and is available from the Statlib S repository at http://lib.stat.cmu.edu/S/SplusNotes/ (LaTeX source and PostScript). An introduction to R based on it will soon be available. Last, but not least, Ross' and Robert's experience in designing and implementing R is described in: @Article{, author = {Ross Ihaka and Robert Gentleman}, title = {R: {A} Language for Data Analysis and Graphics}, journal = {Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics}, year = 1996, volume = 5, number = 3, pages = {299--314} } This is also the reference for R to use in publications. 2.8. Which Mailing Lists Exist for R? Thanks to Martin Maechler <maechler@stat.math.ethz.ch>, there are three mailing lists devoted to R. r-announce This list is for announcements about the development of R and the availability of new code. r-devel This list is for discussions about the future of R and pre- testing of new versions. It is meant for those who maintain an active position in the development of R. r-help The `main' R mailing list, for announcements about the development of R and the availability of new code, questions and answers about problems and solutions using R, enhancements and patches to the source code and documentation of R, comparison and compatibility with S and S-plus, and for the posting of nice examples and, benchmarks. To send a message to everyone on the r-help mailing list, send email to r-help@stat.math.ethz.ch To subscribe (or unsubscribe) to this list send subscribe (or unsub- scribe) in the BODY of the message (not in the subject!) to r-help- request@stat.math.ethz.ch. Information about the list can be obtained by sending an email with info as its contens to r-help- request@stat.math.ethz.ch. Subscription and posting to the other lists is done analogously, with `r-help' replaced by `r-announce' and `r-devel', respectively. Note that the r-announce list is gatewayed into r-help, so you don't need to subscribe to both of them. It is recommended that you send mail to r-help rather than only to the R developers (who are also subscribed to the list, of course). This may save them precious time they can use for constantly improving R, and will typically also result in much quicker feedback for yourself. Of course, in the case of bug reports it would be very helpful to have code which reliably reproduces the problem. The developers of R can be reached for comments and reports at R@stat.auckland.ac.nz. 2.9. What is CRAN? The ``Comprehensive R Archive Network'' (CRAN) is a collection of sites which carry identical material, consisting of the R distribution(s), the contributed extensions, documentation for R, and binaries. The CRAN master site can be found at the URL ftp://ftp.ci.tuwien.ac.at/pub/R/ and is currently being mirrored daily at ftp://franz.stat.wisc.edu/pub/R/ ftp://ftp.stat.math.ethz.ch/R-CRAN/ Please use the CRAN site closest to you to reduce network load. The structure of the CRAN tree is as follows. `src/base' contains the official R distribution as provided by Ross Ihaka and Robert Gentleman. `src/contrib' contains code for extension packages. `doc' is for additional documentation and information on R. `bin' is for prebuilt R binaries (the base distribution and extensions), grouped according to platforms. Currently, there are only experimental packages for Debian GNU/Linux. I hope that `.tar.gz' files with contents relative to an installation tree (e.g. `bin', `lib/R/', and `man/man1/R.1') can be made available soon for all major supported Unix platforms. The process of ``submitting'' to CRAN currently is very simple: upload to ftp://ftp.ci.tuwien.ac.at/incoming and send email to Kurt Hornik <Kurt.Hornik@ci.tuwien.ac.at>. Please indicate the copyright situation (GPL, ...) in your submission. 3. R and S 3.1. What Is S? S is a very high level language and an environment for data analysis and graphics. S was written by Richard A. Becker, John M. Chambers, and Allan R. Wilks of AT&T Bell Laboratories Statistics Research Department. The primary references for S are two books by the creators of S. o Richard A. Becker, John M. Chambers and Allan R. Wilks (1988), ``The New S Language,'' Chapman & Hall, London. This book is often called the ``Blue Book''. o John M. Chambers and Trevor J. Hastie (1992), ``Statistical Models in S,'' Chapman & Hall, London. This is also called the ``White Book''. There is a huge amount of user-contributed code for S, available at the S Repository at CMU. See the ``Frequently Asked Questions about S'' (http://lib.stat.cmu.edu/S/faq) for further information about S. 3.2. What Is S-PLUS? S-PLUS is a value-added version of S sold by Statistical Sciences, Inc. (now a division of Mathsoft, Inc.) S is a subset of S-PLUS, and hence anything which may be done in S may be done in S-PLUS. In addition S-PLUS has extended functionality in a wide variety areas, including robust regression, modern nonparametric regression, time series, survival analysis, multivariate analysis, classical statistical tests, quality control, and graphics drivers. Add-on modules add additional capabilities for wavelet analysis, spatial statistics, and design of experiments. See the MathSoft S-PLUS page (http://www.mathsoft.com/splus.html) for further information. 3.3. What Are the Differences between R and S? Whereas the developers of R have tried to stick to the S language as defined in ``The New S Language'' (Blue Book, see question ``What is S?''), they have adopted the evaluation model of Scheme. This difference becomes manifest when free variables occur in a function. Free variables are those which are neither formal parameters (occurring in the argument list of the function) nor local variables (created by assigning to them in the body of the function). Whereas S (like C) by default uses static scoping, R (like Scheme) has adopted lexical scoping. This means the values of free variables are determined by a set of global variables in S, but in R by the bindings that were in effect at the time the function was created. Consider the following function: cube <- function(n) { sq <- function() n * n n * sq() } Under S, sq() does not ``know'' about the variable n unless it is defined globally: S> cube(2) Error in sq(): Object "n" not found Dumped S> n <- 3 S> cube(2) [1] 18 In R, the ``environment'' created when cube() was invoked is also looked in: R> cube(2) [1] 8 Both R and S employ the principle of lazy evaluation, meaning that expressions are evaluated only when their values are needed in computations. As one consequence of the above, S sometimes evaluates assignments in function argument lists (named arguments) immediately. I.e., S uses eager evaluation in these cases. R always uses lazy evaluation. (Folks, correct me if I am wrong here, but I think this was what caused Martin's function plot.step() to behave differently under R and S.) Lexical scoping allows using function closures and maintaining local state. A simple example (taken from Abelson and Sussman) can be found in the `demos/language' subdirectory of the R distribution. Further information is provided in the standard R reference ``R: A Language for Data Analysis and Graphics'' (see question ``Which Documentation Exists for R?'') and a paper on ``Lexical Scope and Statistical Computing'' by Robert Gentleman and Ross Ihaka which can be obtained from the `doc/misc' directory of a CRAN site. Lexical scoping also implies a further major difference. Whereas S stores all objects as separate files in a directory somewhere (usually `.Data' under the current directory), R does not. All objects in R are stored internally. When R is started up it grabs a very large piece of memory and uses it to store the objects. R performs its own memory management of this piece of memory. Having everything in memory is necessary because it is not really possible to externally maintain all relevant ``environments'' of symbol/value pairs. This difference also seems to make R much faster than S. The down side is that if R crashes you will lose all the work for the current session. Saving and restoring the memory ``images'' (the functions and data stored in R's internal memory at any time) can be a bit slow, especially if they are big. In S this does not happen, because everything is saved in disk files and if you crash nothing is likely to happen to them. R is still in an alpha stage, and does crash from time to time. Hence, for important work you should consider saving often, see question ``How Can I Save My Workspace?'' (other possibilities are logging your sessions, or have your R commands stored in text files which can be read in using source()). Apart from lexical scoping and its implications, R follows the S language definition in the Blue Book as much as possible, and hence really is an ``implementation'' of S. There are some intentional differences where the behavior of S is considered ``not clean''. In general, the rationale is that R should help you detect programming errors, while at the same time being as compatible as possible with S. Some known differences are the following. o In R, if x is a list, then x[sub] <- NULL and x[[sub]] <- NULL remove the specified elements from x. The first of these is incompatible with S, where it is a no-op. o In S, the functions named .First and .Last in the `.Data' directory can be used for customizing, as they are executed at the very beginning and end of a session, respectively. R looks for files called `.Rprofile' in the user's home directory and the current directory, and sources these. (It also loads a saved image from `.RData' in case there is one.) If a .First function exists then, it is executed. The .Last mechanism is not supported yet. o Attaching library sections works differently. In S, library(name) adds the data directory for the library section name to the search list. If a function object named `.First.lib' exists in the directory, it is executed; this is typically used to dynamically load compiled code required by the functions in the section. In R, library(name) currently simply sources the file $RHOME/library/name, and compiled code can be loaded by calling library.dynam() in this file. The .First.lib mechanism is not really supported. (Note that a library file is only loaded once, so that any code in the library that is not in a function is executed the first time the library is loaded.) o R does not try as hard as S to preserve dimnames attributes (examples are apply, rbind, and cbind, but also arithmetic ops). o R presently does not support IEEE Inf and NaN. o In R, attach currently only works for lists and data frames (not for directories). o Categories do not exist in R, and never will as they are deprecated now in S. Use factors instead. o In R, For() loops are not necessary and hence not supported. o In R, assign() uses the argument envir= rather than where= as in S. o The random number generators are different, and the seeds have different length. o The glm family objects are implemented differently in R and S. The same functionality is available but the components have different names. o terms objects are stored differently. In S a terms object is an expression with attributes, in R it is a formula with attributes. The attributes have the same names but are mostly stored differently. The major difference in functionality is that a terms object is subscriptable in S but not in R. If you can't imagine why this would matter then you don't need to know. There are also differences which are not intentional, and result from missing or incorrect code in R. The developers would appreciate hearing about any deficiencies you may find (in a written report fully documenting the difference as you see it). Of course, it would be useful if you were to implement the change yourself and make sure it works. 4. R Add-On Packages 4.1. Which Add-on Packages Exist for R? The R distribution comes with the following extra libraries: eda Exploratory Data Analysis. Currently only contains functions for robust line fitting, and median polish and smoothing. mva Multivariate Analysis. Currently contains code for principal components (prcomp), canonical correlations (cancor), hierarchichal clustering (hclust), and metric multidimensional scaling (cmdscale). More functions for clustering and scaling, biplots, profile and star plots, and code for ``real'' discriminant analysis will be added soon. The following packages are available from the CRAN `src/contrib' area. acepack ace (Alternating Conditional Expectations) and avas (Additivity and variance stabilization for regression) for selecting regression transformations. bootstrap Software (bootstrap, cross-validation, jackknife), data and errata for the book ``An Introduction to the Bootstrap'' by B. Efron and R. Tibshirani, 1993, Chapman and Hall. ctest A library of classical tests, including the Bartlett, Fisher, Kruskal-Wallis, Kolmogorov-Smirnov, and Wilcoxon tests. date Functions for dealing with dates. The most useful of them accepts a vector of input dates in any of the forms 8/30/53, 30Aug53, 30 August 1953, ..., August 30 53, or any mixture of these. e1071 Miscellaneous functions used at the Department of Statistics at TU Wien (E1071). fracdiff Maximum likelihood estimation of the parameters of a fractionally differenced ARIMA(p,d,q) model (Haslett and Raftery, Applied Statistics, 1989). gee An implementation of the Liang/Zeger generalized estimating equation approach to GLMs for dependent data. jpn A function to plot Japan's coast-line and prefecture boundaries. oz Functions for plotting Australias coastline and state boundaries. snns An R interface to the Stuttgart Neural Networks Simulator (SNNS). splines Regression spline functions. survival4 Functions for survival analysis (requires splines). See CRAN `src/contrib/INDEX' for more information. Paul Gilbert <pgilbert@bank-banque-canada.ca> has a written a multivariate time series library for S called time.series that is mostly converted to run in R. He will make this port generally available when complex numbers are implemented (see question ``What is the current version of R?''). According to Paul, the PADI interface from the Bank of Canada also works with minor changes. PADI can be used to access Fame time series data bases and potentially other databases, even remotely over the Internet. For further information see http:www.bank-banque- canada.ca/pgilbert. According to Arne Kovac <A.Kovac@Bristol.ac.uk>, Guy Nason's WaveThresh package for S worked with only minor modifications under R version 0.12. More code has been posted to the r-help mailing list, and can be obtained from the mailing list archive. 4.2. How Can Add-on Packages Be Installed? (Unix only.) Untar the add-on packages in $RHOME/src/library/ and type $ make libs $ cd ../.. $ ./etc/install-libhelp at the shell prompt. 4.3. How Can Add-on Packages Be Used? To find out which add-ons have already been installed, type R> library() at the R prompt. This produces something like NAME DESCRIPTION acepack ace() and avas() for selecting regression transformations bootstrap Functions for the book "An Introduction to the Bootstrap" ctest Classical Tests date Functions for handling dates eda Exploratory Data Analysis fracdiff Fractionally differenced ARIMA (p,d,q) models gee Generalized Estimating Equation models mva Classical Multivariate Analysis splines Regression spline functions survival4 Survival analysis [needs library(splines)] You can ``load'' an add-on with name name by R> library(name) You can then find out which functions it provides by typing R> help(library = name) 4.4. How Can I Contribute to R? R is currently still in alpha (or pre-alpha) state, so simply using it and communicating problems is certainly of great value. One place where functionality is still missing is the modeling software as described in ``Statistical Models in S'' (see question ``What is S?''. The functions add1 kappa alias labels drop1 proj are missing; many of these are interpreted functions so anyone that is bored and wants to have a go at implementing them it would be appreci- ated. In addition, only linear and generalized linear models are cur- rently available, aov, gam, loess, tree, and the nonlinear modelling code are not there yet. Many of the packages available at the Statlib S Repository might be worth porting to R. If you are interested in working on any of these projects, please notify Kurt Hornik. 5. R and Emacs 5.1. Is there Emacs Support for R? There is an Emacs-Lisp interface to S/S-PLUS called S-mode. Its current version is 4.8 and can be obtained at http://www.maths.lancs.ac.uk:2080/~maa036/elisp/S-mode/. The earlier versions which can be found at the Statlib S repository (gnuemacs3 and gnuemacs4) are outdated. It contains code for interacting with an inferior S process from within Emacs including an interface to the help system, editing S source code, and transcript manipulation, and comes with detailed instructions for installation. Martin Maechler <maechler@stat.math.ethz.ch> and Tony Rossini <rossini@math.sc.edu> have integrated support for R into this package. The current version is at ftp://ftp.math.sc.edu/rossini/S-mode-4.8.MM6.XE2.tar.gz and runs under both GNU Emacs and XEmacs. To install, put the byte-compiled `.el' files into a place where Emacs can find them, and add (if (not (assoc "\\.R$" auto-mode-alist) (add-to-list 'auto-mode-alist (cons "\\.R$" 'R-mode)))) (autoload 'R "S" "Run an inferior R process" t) (autoload 'R-mode "S" "Mode for editing R source" t) (autoload 'r-mode "S" "Mode for editing R source" t) to one of your Emacs startup files, typically `~/.emacs'. You can then fire up R from within Emacs by typing `M-x R' (note however that many interface functions will not work), and if you use the extension `.R' for your files with R code, Emacs will automagically turn on R edit mode whenever you visit such a file. Tony Rossini, Martin Maechler and Kurt Hornik have officially taken over the development of S-mode. Version 4.9 (based on the current 4.8.MM series) will be released shortly; version 5.0 (codenamed ``istat'') should be out by the end of 1997. 5.2. Should I Run R from Within Emacs? Yes. Inferior R mode provides a readline/history mechanism, object name completion, and syntax-based highlighting of the interaction buffer using Font Lock mode, as well as a very convenient interface to the R help system. Of course, it also integrates nicely with the mechanisms for editing R source using Emacs. 6. R Miscellania 6.1. How Can I Read a Large Data Set into R? R (currently) uses a static memory model. This means that when it starts up, it asks the operating system to reserve a fixed amount of memory for it. The size of this chunk cannot be changed subsequently. Hence, it can happen that not enough memory was allocated. In these cases, you should restart R with more memory available, using the command line options -n and -v. To understand these options, one needs to know that R maintains separate areas for fixed and variable sized objects. The first of these is allocated as an array of SEXPRECs assembled in a list using ``cons cells'' (ordered pairs each containing an element of the list and a pointer to the next cell), and the second as an array of VECRECs. The -n option can be used to specify the number of cons cells (each occupying 16 bytes) which R is to use (the default is 200000), and the -v option to specify the size of the vector heap in megabytes (the default is 2). Only integers are allowed for both options. E.g., to read in a table of 5000 observations on 40 numeric variables, R -v 6 should do. Note that the information where to find vectors and strings on the heap is stored using cons cells. Thus, it may also be necessary to allocate more space for cons cells in order to perform computations with very ``large'' variable-size objects. You can find out the current memory comsumption by typing gc() at the R prompt. 6.2. Why Can't R Source a `Correct' File? R sometimes has problems parsing a file which does not end in a newline. This can happen for example when Emacs is used for editing the file and next-line-add-newlines is set to nil. To avoid the problem, either set require-final-newline to a non-nil value in one of your Emacs startup files, or make sure R-mode (see question ``Is there Emacs Support for R?'') is used for editing R source files (which locally ensures this setting). Earlier R versions had a similar problem when reading in data files, but this should have been taken care of now. 6.3. How Can I Set Components of a List to NULL? You can use x[i] <- list(NULL) to set component i of the list x to NULL, similarly for named compo- nents. Do not set x[i] or x[[i]] to NULL, because this will remove the corresponding component from the list. For dropping the row names of a matrix x, it may be easier to use rownames(x) <- NULL, similarly for column names. 6.4. How Can I Save My Workspace? The expression save(list = ls(), file = ".RData") saves the objects in the currently active environment (typically the user's .GlobalEnv) to the file `.RData' in the R startup directory. 6.5. How Can I Clean Up My Workspace? To remove all objects in the currently active environment (typically the user's .GlobalEnv), you can do rm(list = ls()) 7. Acknowledgments Of course, many many thanks to Robert and Ross for the R system, and to the package writers and porters for adding to it. Special thanks go to Peter Dalgaard, Paul Gilbert, Martin Maechler, and Anthony Rossini for their comments which helped me improve this FAQ. More to some soon ... =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- r-devel mailing list -- Read http://www.ci.tuwien.ac.at/~hornik/R/R-FAQ.html Send "info", "help", or "[un]subscribe" (in the "body", not the subject !) To: r-devel-request@stat.math.ethz.ch =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-