smb@asdfghjkl.org
2004-Apr-06 17:35 UTC
[Samba] Resources forks 'dot underscore' files locked indefinitely from MacOSX clients
We have a central samba file share for our designers (who all use OSX boxes, and mostly use Macromedia products) to work off of. I've lately been able to track down a lot of application quirks (mostly problems with errors when saving, about files being locked) to the Mac resource fork files being indefinitely locked. Here's a sample from a `smbstatus` 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/images/._neckpain.jpg Tue Apr 6 10:41:22 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/images/._golfers.jpg Tue Apr 6 10:41:18 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/._index.php Tue Apr 6 11:03:38 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/forms/._shoulderrepair.pdf Tue Apr 6 11:03:38 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/images/._spine.jpg Tue Apr 6 10:41:22 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/images/._hip.jpg Tue Apr 6 10:41:18 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/images/._box.gif Tue Apr 6 10:41:18 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/images/._hand.jpg Tue Apr 6 10:41:18 2004 14853 DENY_NONE 0x1 RDONLY NONE /files/HCMG/mainline/proto1/images/._bgimage.gif Tue Apr 6 10:41:18 2004 (the entries here aren't populated with really ancient data due to a recent server restart) These files stay locked long after any application dealing with them has been quit, excluding the finder. I've noticed on casual smbstatus's seeing locked files that have not been accessed in over a week. Although the problem seems to mostly occur with Macromedia's Studio products, it is not limited to that application suite. The permanent locks are also created with MS Word, Acrobat, BBEdit, and many other applications; they still manage to save properly, with occasionally displaying a warning message about a file being locked. It just seems that Macromedia products aren't horribly fault tolerant and just prefer to error and delete the working file (which I chock up to bad programming). Added note: Macromedia has been contacted about this problem as well, but their developers were not able to reproduce the problem. The main question: Does anyone know why MacOSX creates these permanent locks on the resource forks, and is it preventable? (short of disabling locking in samba or setting up a 'veto files', both of which just skirt around the actual problem) The computers involved in this senario are: Server, running Debian-woody, with samba 2.2.8a compiled from source Clients, running MacOSX 10.3.3 and below (to 10.2, but we noticed problems even earlier) Thanks -- Gabe Martin-Dempesy
Apparently Analagous Threads
- Recipe/advice for Samba 4.11 on Ubuntu 20.04 as member server joining Windows Server 2019 AD
- Recipe/advice for Samba 4.11 on Ubuntu 20.04 as member server joining Windows Server 2019 AD
- Oplock break failed for file XXX-- replying anyway?
- Sudden unexplained slowness on share (caused by duplicate UID?)
- Possible memory leak in smbd?