Does Asterisk, currently using version 1.4, get any more information about the result of an outbound call made over a PRI line compared to a call via a SIP trunk? As an example, in a PRI call there is this message that shows up on the console: [2011-01-05 14:59:02] -- Channel 23 detected a CED tone from the network. for a call to a fax machine. Does asterisk set anything that a dialplan can access that can know the call was to a fax machine? If a call is placed to a number that is disconnected so a special information tone is played can either a PRI call or a SIP call know this without analyzing the audio stream? Are there reasons to prefer the use of PRI over SIP or SIP over PRI? I would like people's opinions as to if one form is better than the other in any meaningful way. Thanks for you feed-back. -- Jim Dickenson mailto:dickenson at cfmc.com CfMC http://www.cfmc.com/
On Thu, Jan 6, 2011 at 7:06 AM, Jim Dickenson <dickenson at cfmc.com> wrote:> Are there reasons to prefer the use of PRI over SIP or SIP over PRI?Assuming you are talking to connect a PBX to the PSTN... PRI advantages: 1. Relatively little equipment between the PTSN and the PBX. Less to break or go wrong. 2. Simple to set up. No need for QoS, routing, authentication, etc. Of course if you only know IP, SIP is easier, but if you learn both, ISDN is easier. 3. If compared to SIP over internet, PRI has guaranteed quality. Granted, SIP *can* have just as good (and better) quality, just not guaranteed if done over the internet (it can be guaranteed over a private circuit). 4. Less latency/delay so there is less "talk-over". 5. FAX, high speed modem, TTY, etc, pass-through actually works. (it *can* work over SIP, but Asterisk just isn't quite there yet) I run the PBX for my organization which has about 160 extensions. I wouldn't even think of doing anything but PRI for the main lines because (A) for our size organization where we are located, we're talking a couple hundred dollars a month difference between PRI and SIP in cost so it's nearly break-even in cost which means cost difference isn't a huge motivator, (B) it supports FAX, modems, and TTYs - perfectly, (C) Quality is 100% consistent. In addition, the reliability is good enough that I'm willing to use it for 911. Of course if this installation wasn't in downtown Denver, where ISDN PRI is very cheap (a full CLEC 23-channel ISDN PRI costs roughly what 6 or 7 ILEC POTS lines cost), then SIP would be interested. SIP advantages: 1. Cheap (at least SIP-over-internet) 2. Easy and quick to scale if you have bandwidth. 3. Great for disaster recovery if using SIP over internet 4. Very cheap to get "local" numbers from all around the world. 5. If using SIP over internet, easy to compare providers
PRICAUSE will give you lots of info on why a call was hungup on. Not sure if SIP will give you the same. On Thu, Jan 6, 2011 at 9:06 AM, Jim Dickenson <dickenson at cfmc.com> wrote:> Does Asterisk, currently using version 1.4, get any more information about the result of an outbound call made over a PRI line compared to a call via a SIP trunk? > > As an example, in a PRI call there is this message that shows up on the console: > > [2011-01-05 14:59:02] ? ? -- Channel 23 detected a CED tone from the network. > > for a call to a fax machine. Does asterisk set anything that a dialplan can access that can know the call was to a fax machine? > > If a call is placed to a number that is disconnected so a special information tone is played can either a PRI call or a SIP call know this without analyzing the audio stream? > > Are there reasons to prefer the use of PRI over SIP or SIP over PRI? > > I would like people's opinions as to if one form is better than the other in any meaningful way. > > Thanks for you feed-back. > -- > Jim Dickenson > mailto:dickenson at cfmc.com > > CfMC > http://www.cfmc.com/ > > > > > -- > _____________________________________________________________________ > -- Bandwidth and Colocation Provided by http://www.api-digital.com -- > New to Asterisk? Join us for a live introductory webinar every Thurs: > ? ? ? ? ? ? ? http://www.asterisk.org/hello > > asterisk-users mailing list > To UNSUBSCRIBE or update options visit: > ? http://lists.digium.com/mailman/listinfo/asterisk-users >