Adri wrote:> tparker wrote:
>> abb4 wrote:
>>> I see a lot of programs tested in the database without any
reference
>>> how it
>>> was installed. One has to reinvent the wheel once again.
>> I don't know that this has anything to do with install directions
>> specifically, but there are several people who stopped trying to
>> contribute to the appdb quite a while ago. The form was set up in a
>> non-intuitive way, especially for non-techie users. Very often people
>> would slog through getting the info put in and submit it then have it
>> never show up in the db or show up breifly and be removed with no
>> reason given, just an email saying it was removed. With no feedback
>> on why it was removed it got discouraging since the people assumed
>> they had done something wrong but didn't know how to improve their
>> submissions, so they stopped trying. I know that is why I stopped
>> submitting for the programs I use well over a year ago and have
>> spoken in person and on distribution forums with others that did the
>> same.
> According to the howto, everyone can become a maintainer.
> Why not become a maintainer..then you have it all in your own hands.
Thanks for the suggestions and I had considered it, but being a
maintainer is not for everyone. It comes with responsibilities and
someone should not sign up to maintain a program if they know they can
not do the job. I do not keep up-to-date with all the releases. I need
my programs to be stable so I update my wine in fits and spurts to keep
it so. I would not always be grabbing the newest version as it comes
out. I have tried to keep a separate wine-git of the newest version and
test programs in that to help out, but I am not a programmer and was not
able to figure out how to keep it current. Also, the programs I use
already have maintainers, in some cases several of them.
When I posted I wasn't meaning it as a criticism to people. You had said
you would like to see more information on installation, and I was just
wondering if some of the people who got scared off from using the db
might have been ones who would have provided that information in their
submissions.
Right now the db is the first place new people are sent, but it is
fairly new user unfriendly. The first hit that shows up when searching
for an app is often for an old/obsolete version. This works fine once
you've been around a while and understand the site layout and can worm
your way over to the page for the current version. If you just did your
first wine install and are trying to see if City of Heroes or Eve works,
it can add a lot of confusion. The submission form (last time I looked)
was very hard to understand and I would bet a fair number of
rejected/removed submission came from people not being able to figure
out the form.