Vorbis - Sep 2005 - oggdec and ogg123 playing audio from an Ogg Theora+Vorbis file?

Are oggdec and ogg123 supposed to be able to extract or play audio from an Ogg 
Theora+Vorbis file?

OggDec 1.0 and ogg123 from vorbis-tools 1.0.1 don't seem to be able to do
so.

If the programs are not supposed to do this job now, are any improvements 
planned so they can do this job in the future?

Thanks for info on this.

On Fri, Sep 02, 2005 at 06:50:44PM -0500, J.B. Nicholson-Owens wrote:
> Are oggdec and ogg123 supposed to be able to extract or play audio from an 
> Ogg Theora+Vorbis file?
Unfortunately not. Both of these utilites use the vorbisfile convenience 
library, which has never been updated to handle multiplexed streams. 
Patches very welcome.
> If the programs are not supposed to do this job now, are any improvements 
> planned so they can do this job in the future?
Updating vorbisfile to (at least) just take the first vorbis substream 
in every multiplexed chain segment would be the ideal fix. It's a small 
matter of programming, but not trivial; the way vorbisfile tracks the 
file segments needs to be generalized.

If you just want something that works now, you can use the oggzsplit 
utility from annodex.net to break out the audio stream you're interested 
in and pipe that to ogg123 or oggenc.

HTH
 -r