On 20/06/2023 19:48, Ingo Asche via samba wrote:> There was a Travis Wenks here, who has/had the same problems. > > I'm still hoping, he's reading the Samba mail list and tell me if he has > still the same problems and we maybe can ally for this.Multiple users having the same problem always help.> > Maybe the maintainers who has answered to the bug report can give some > advice, too.Try adding to the bug report.> > The problem for me is that the developers from Synology think it can't > be their fault. It's a little bit frustrating.I don't think that it is their fault, but we will never know, I don't think we will ever see what modifications they have made to the Samba code. However, you do not seem to get the problem with a later Samba version and the SID S-1-18-1 (which is only mentioned as an 'aside' to the bug) appears to have something to do with S4U2Self and I think quite a bit of work has been done on that. It may just be that synology needs to use a later version of Samba. Rowland
Rowland Penny via samba schrieb am 20.06.2023 um 21:01:> Try adding to the bug report.Would that be ok even it's happening on a Synology? Just don't want to mess around.> I don't think that it is their fault, but we will never know, I don't > think we will ever see what modifications they have made to the Samba > code. However, you do not seem to get the problem with a later Samba > version and the SID S-1-18-1 (which is only mentioned as an 'aside' to > the bug) appears to have something to do with S4U2Self and I think > quite a bit of work has been done on that.You're right fault was the wrong word, ment more caused through their changes to Samba.> It may just be that synology needs to use a later version of Samba.As I wrote before, I have set up a member server using Samba 4.15.9 and 4.15.13, the versions they use as a base. And even they worked without problems. So in my opinion it can only be caused through their extensions. But of course as 4.15 is already EOL a newer version would be better.> > Rowland >Regards Ingo https://github.com/WAdama