samba - Jul 2012 - Samba Share - MS Excel when saving “can't access the file, there are several possible reasons”

Hello all samba fans.., Long live open source :)
Thanks for the @adminbot for approving me to joining this milis.

Please allow me to ask the question,
I have a weird problem in my samba share. I have one share definition
for 3 client (A,B,C) This share contain some excel file which having a
lot of formula and linked each other.
Client A access the file with libre office (ubuntu), client B access
with WinXP & MS Office 2003, The write and read process working
successfuly on Both of them.

The problem occur when client C accessing the same file with MS Excel
2003 (windows xp). This messagebox appear when he saving the file :

"Microsoft office excel cannot access the \\192.168.1.23\myshare\
There are several possible reasons:

     - The File ort path does not exist The file is being used by
another program.
     - The workbook you are trying to save has the same name as a
     - Currently open workbooks."

I was trying http://support.microsoft.com/kb/291204 but it didnt work.
Below is my share definition :

[brainshare]
comment = brainshare
path = /opt/brainshare/
valid users = @brainshare
force group = brainshare
read only = No
create mask = 0775
veto files = /*.scr/*.eml/thumbs.com/

Help me please... Thanks in advance !
Server: Ubuntu 10.10, Samba version 3.5.4

--
Thinking out of the box

Am Dienstag, 3. Juli 2012, 06:16:45 schrieb Gibransyah
Fakhri:
> Hello all samba fans.., Long live open source :)
> Thanks for the @adminbot for approving me to joining this milis.
> 
> Please allow me to ask the question,
> I have a weird problem in my samba share. I have one share definition
> for 3 client (A,B,C) This share contain some excel file which having a
> lot of formula and linked each other.
> Client A access the file with libre office (ubuntu), client B access
> with WinXP & MS Office 2003, The write and read process working
> successfuly on Both of them.
> 
> The problem occur when client C accessing the same file with MS Excel
> 2003 (windows xp). This messagebox appear when he saving the file :
> 
> "Microsoft office excel cannot access the \\192.168.1.23\myshare\
> There are several possible reasons:
> 
>      - The File ort path does not exist The file is being used by
> another program.
>      - The workbook you are trying to save has the same name as a
>      - Currently open workbooks."
> 
> I was trying http://support.microsoft.com/kb/291204 but it didnt work.
> Below is my share definition :
> 
> [brainshare]
> comment = brainshare
> path = /opt/brainshare/
> valid users = @brainshare
> force group = brainshare
> read only = No
> create mask = 0775
> veto files = /*.scr/*.eml/thumbs.com/
> 
> Help me please... Thanks in advance !
> Server: Ubuntu 10.10, Samba version 3.5.4
> 
> --
> Thinking out of the box
what does "smbstatus" (run as root) on the samba server show when
all 3 clients have the same file open?

Does this only happen when _all_ 3 clients access that file at the same time?

So, does it work when only B and C (windows xp) clients access that file?

Cheers, G?nter