openssh unix dev - Apr 2004 - FW: filexfer draft and uid / gid resolution ...

Matthew Grooms wrote:
> Damien,
> 
>      Thanks for the response. Are you aware of any sftp server products
> that currently implement the uid / gid resolution or is this new draft
> just too unrefined / recent. Also, is there a definitive source for
> these drafts and where might they be published? Up till now I have just
> been reading the documentation available from www.openssh.org.
http://ftp.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-secsh-filexfer-05.txt

Is the most recent draft. Discussion of the protocols occurs on the
ietf-secsh at netbsd.org mailing list.

I don't know of any server implementations that do filexfer-05. Perhaps
some of the commercial ones do, but I haven't checked (and won't
without licenses to do so).

If it wants to interoperate with the majority of deployed software, any
implementation that supports filexfer-05 will also have to support
filexfer-03.

Therefore I don't see a point in implementing the new draft until some
issues are cleared up (including an O_NOFOLLOW equivalent for opening
files) because then we would have to implement filexfer-03, 05 and
whatever replaces it.

The new draft is an improvement in a few areas, though. One of them
being the transmission of user/group info.

-d

Damien,

     Thanks for the response. Are you aware of any sftp server products
that currently implement the uid / gid resolution or is this new draft
just too unrefined / recent. Also, is there a definitive source for
these drafts and where might they be published? Up till now I have just
been reading the documentation available from www.openssh.org.

     I hope these questions aren't too annoying. If there is a better
place to get answers for questions of this nature, please just let me
know and I will get out of your hair.

Thanks again for your help. I really appreciate it.

-Matthew
>________________________________
>
>From: Damien Miller [mailto:djm at mindrot.org]
>Sent: Tue 4/27/2004 6:39 PM
>To: Grooms, Matthew
>Cc: openssh-unix-dev at mindrot.org
>Subject: Re: filexfer draft and uid / gid resolution ...
>
>
>The version of the filexfer draft that OpenSSH supports doesn't support
>user/group name resolution. We have access to numeric user and group IDs
>only.
>
>Later versions of the filexfer draft do support this, but I have some
>misgiving about them that I would like to see resolved before
>implementing support for a new revision.
>
>-d
>
>
>