ogg dev - Sep 2007 - [Flac-dev] Support .cda as input files

On 2007-09-13, Ivo wrote:
> On 9/13/07, Daniel Aleksandersen <aleksandersen+xiphlists@runbox.com>
wrote:
> > I know that. However when you put an audio CD in a computer you will
> > see them as files with the .cda extension. Supporting this
'format'
> > would make encoding simpler as users would not need to 'rip'
to a
> > format, but could drag and drop the files from the CD to the computer.
>
> You still do not understand.  The only way for something like that to
> work would be for FLAC to rip the audio data from the CD, which is not
> something the FLAC encoder does, nor I believe Josh is planning to
> change it to perform such task.
What I mean is that most operating systems?exclusing Mac OS 10?provides 
audio files from CDs in this format by default. So being able to encode 
from it would make the process easier for users.
> Xiph provides you with cdparanoia to rip Audio CDs. There are other
> rippers around, too. Most can be configured to encode directly the
> extracted data as FLAC.
Yeah, I know about cdparanoia?which by the way does not work on my 64bit 
system?and other ripping tools. I am only suggesting supporting .cda as a 
way to avoid ripping alltogether (from a user's perspective anyways).
-- 
Daniel Aleksandersen

What are you using for FLAC now, Daniel?  flac.exe?  Or (one of) the  
Windows GUI apps?
I suppose you realize that flac.exe probably won't allow drag and  
drop encoding.
Why don't you contact one of the authors of the PC Windows GUI apps  
to suggest this feature?  That's the only place it will help the  
basic users.

I believe that this list is focused on the low-level FLAC source code  
- the stuff that's open source like the API and the command-line  
utilities.
The easy-to-use programs are developed and maintained by others.

Brian Willoughby
Sound Consulting


On Sep 13, 2007, at 13:47, Daniel Aleksandersen wrote:

On 2007-09-13, Ivo wrote:
> Xiph provides you with cdparanoia to rip Audio CDs. There are other
> rippers around, too. Most can be configured to encode directly the
> extracted data as FLAC.
Yeah, I know about cdparanoia?which by the way does not work on my 64bit
system?and other ripping tools. I am only suggesting supporting .cda  
as a
way to avoid ripping alltogether (from a user's perspective anyways).
-- 
Daniel Aleksandersen

On 2007-09-13, Brian wrote:
> What are you using for FLAC now, Daniel?  flac.exe?  Or (one of) the
> Windows GUI apps?
I am using the Linux command line. $ flac
-- 
Daniel Aleksandersen