thr3ads.net - llvm dev - [LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8 [Dec 2011]

If this information is useful, please help other people find it:
Share via:

David Fang

2011-Dec-15 21:17 UTC

[LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8

Hi,

I've bootstrapped llvm/clang from svn-trunk on powerpc-darwin8 (g++-4.0.1),
and
have the following test results to share.
Summary below, full log at:
http://www.csl.cornell.edu/~fang/sw/llvm/r146586-powerpc-darwin8-results.txt

The only edits required were those I posted to llvm-commits yesterday (re: 
"some missing clang libs").  And I also edited LitConfig.py to point
to
/sw/bin/bash (4.2) because /bin/bash is missing support for pipefail.

Some of the tests hung indefinitely on 'lli', so I had to kill them.

My question is: which of the following test failures should be addressed first 
as top priority?  Are there any low-hanging fruit that look easy to fix 
(looking at the full log)?

Fang

powerpc-darwin8-g++-4.0.1 bootstrap test summary:

********************
Testing Time: 65105.62s
********************
Unexpected Passing Tests (1):
      Clang :: CodeGenCXX/member-alignment.cpp

********************
Failing Tests (204):
     Clang : :  CXX/expr/expr.unary/expr.unary.noexcept/cg.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGen/2003-08-17-DeadCodeShortCircuit.c
     Clang : :  CodeGen/2004-06-17-UnorderedBuiltins.c
     Clang : :  CodeGen/bitfield-promote.c
     Clang : :  CodeGenCXX/2005-02-19-UnnamedVirtualThunkArgument.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGenCXX/conditional-expr-lvalue.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGenCXX/cxx0x-delegating-ctors.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGenCXX/expr.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGenCXX/nrvo.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGenCXX/throw-expressions.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGenCXX/vtable-debug-info.cpp
     Clang : :  CodeGenObjC/arc-ivar-layout.m
     Clang : :  CodeGenObjC/debug-info-class-extension.m
     Clang : :  CodeGenObjC/debug-info-class-extension2.m
     Clang : :  CodeGenObjC/debug-info-crash-2.m
     Clang : :  Index/c-index-api-loadTU-test.m
     Clang : :  Index/nested-binaryoperators.cpp
     Clang : :  Index/recursive-member-access.c
     Clang : :  Index/redeclarations.cpp
     Clang : :  Modules/decldef.mm
     Clang : :  Modules/diamond-pch.c
     Clang : :  Modules/diamond.c
     Clang : :  Modules/lookup.cpp
     Clang : :  Modules/module-private.cpp
     Clang : :  Modules/objc-categories.m
     Clang : :  Modules/on-demand-build.m
     Clang : :  Modules/submodules.cpp
     Clang : :  Modules/wildcard-submodule-exports.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-categories.m
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-categories2.m
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-conversion-lookup.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-cxx.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-empty-initial-namespace.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-friend-instantiation.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-implicit-definition.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-late-anonymous-namespace.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-pending-instantiations.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/chain-selectors.m
     Clang : :  PCH/check-deserializations.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cuda-kernel-call.cu
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-alias-decl.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-chain-function-template.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-for-range.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-friends.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-implicit-moves.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-member-init.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-method.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-ms-function-specialization-class-scope.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-namespaces.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-static_assert.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-templates.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-traits.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-typeid.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-using.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx-variadic-templates.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx0x-default-delete.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx0x-delegating-ctors.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/cxx_exprs.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/exprs.c
     Clang : :  PCH/headersearch.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/missing-file.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/ms-if-exists.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/namespaces.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/objc_import.m
     Clang : :  PCH/objc_methods.m
     Clang : :  PCH/objc_property.m
     Clang : :  PCH/objcxx-ivar-class.mm
     Clang : :  PCH/pragma-diag-section.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/reinclude.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/struct.c
     Clang : :  PCH/typo.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/typo.m
     Clang : :  PCH/va_arg.cpp
     Clang : :  PCH/working-directory.cpp
     Clang : :  Preprocessor/mmx.c
     Clang : :  Preprocessor/predefined-arch-macros.c
     Clang : :  Sema/arm-neon-types.c
     Clang : :  SemaObjC/cocoa.m
     Clang : :  SemaTemplate/instantiate-function-1.cpp
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2003-05-27-phifcmpd.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2003-05-27-useboolinotherbb.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2003-05-27-usefsubasbool.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2003-05-30-BadPreselectPhi.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2003-07-29-BadConstSbyte.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2006-02-12-InsertLibcall.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2006-03-01-dagcombineinfloop.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2006-06-28-SimplifySetCCCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2006-07-03-schedulers.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2007-04-30-LandingPadBranchFolding.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2007-12-17-InvokeAsm.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2008-01-30-LoadCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2008-02-04-Ctlz.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2009-03-17-LSR-APInt.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2009-11-16-BadKillsCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/2010-11-04-BigByval.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/add-with-overflow-128.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/badCallArgLRLLVM.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/badarg6.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/builtin-expect.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/crash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/exception-handling.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/fwdtwice.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/llvm-ct-intrinsics.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/nested-select.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/overflow.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/print-mul.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/print-shift.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/select-cc.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/Generic/select.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2006-04-19-vmaddfp-crash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2006-09-28-shift_64.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2007-03-30-SpillerCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2007-05-14-InlineAsmSelectCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2007-05-22-tailmerge-3.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2007-08-04-CoalescerAssert.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2007-10-18-PtrArithmetic.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2007-11-16-landingpad-split.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-02-05-LiveIntervalsAssert.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-03-05-RegScavengerAssert.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-03-17-RegScavengerCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-04-23-CoalescerCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-06-23-LiveVariablesCrash.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-07-15-Bswap.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-07-15-Fabs.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-09-12-CoalescerBug.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2008-10-28-f128-i32.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2009-07-16-InlineAsm-M-Operand.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2009-08-17-inline-asm-addr-mode-breakage.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2009-09-18-carrybit.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2010-02-12-saveCR.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2010-04-01-MachineCSEBug.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2011-12-05-NoSpillDupCR.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/2011-12-06-SpillAndRestoreCR.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/Atomics-32.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/Frames-large.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/addc.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/atomic-1.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/atomic-2.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/available-externally.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/branch-opt.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/div-2.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/fp-branch.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/iabs.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/indirectbr.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/int-fp-conv-0.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/int-fp-conv-1.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/lsr-postinc-pos.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/ppc32-vaarg.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/ppcf128-4.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/rlwimi-keep-rsh.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/rlwimi3.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/select-cc.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/shift128.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/stack-protector.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/tailcall1-64.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/tailcall1.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/tailcallpic1.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/varargs.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/vec_auto_constant.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/vec_br_cmp.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/vec_buildvector_loadstore.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/vec_misaligned.ll
     LLVM : :  CodeGen/PowerPC/vec_splat_constant.ll
     LLVM : :  DebugInfo/array.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2002-12-16-ArgTest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-01-04-ArgumentBug.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-01-04-LoopTest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-01-04-PhiTest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-01-09-SARTest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-01-10-FUCOM.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-01-15-AlignmentTest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-05-06-LivenessClobber.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-05-07-ArgumentTest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-05-11-PHIRegAllocBug.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-06-04-bzip2-bug.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-06-05-PHIBug.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-08-15-AllocaAssertion.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-08-21-EnvironmentTest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2003-08-23-RegisterAllocatePhysReg.ll
     LLVM : : 
ExecutionEngine/2003-10-18-PHINode-ConstantExpr-CondCode-Failure.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/2005-12-02-TailCallBug.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/hello.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/hello2.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/simplesttest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/simpletest.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/stubs.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-arith.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-branch.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-call.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-cast.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-constantexpr.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-fp.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-loadstore.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-logical.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-loop.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-phi.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-ret.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-setcond-fp.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-setcond-int.ll
     LLVM : :  ExecutionEngine/test-shift.ll
     LLVM : :  Instrumentation/AddressSanitizer/bug_11395.ll
     LLVM : :  Transforms/LICM/2003-12-11-SinkingToPHI.ll
     LLVM : :  Transforms/LoopStrengthReduce/2011-11-29-postincphi.ll
     LLVM : :  Transforms/LoopStrengthReduce/2011-12-04-loserreg.ll

    Expected Passes    : 6537
    Expected Failures  : 40
    Unsupported Tests  : 2881
    Unexpected Passes  : 1
    Unexpected Failures: 204
make[3]: *** [tools/clang/test/CMakeFiles/check-all] Error 1
make[2]: *** [tools/clang/test/CMakeFiles/check-all.dir/all] Error 2
make[1]: *** [tools/clang/test/CMakeFiles/check-all.dir/rule] Error 2
make: *** [check-all] Error 2

Fang

-- 
David Fang
http://www.csl.cornell.edu/~fang/

Eli Friedman

2011-Dec-15 21:32 UTC

head link

[LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8

On Thu, Dec 15, 2011 at 1:17 PM, David Fang <fang at csl.cornell.edu>
wrote:> Hi,
>
> I've bootstrapped llvm/clang from svn-trunk on powerpc-darwin8
(g++-4.0.1), and
> have the following test results to share.
> Summary below, full log at:
>
http://www.csl.cornell.edu/~fang/sw/llvm/r146586-powerpc-darwin8-results.txt
>
> The only edits required were those I posted to llvm-commits yesterday (re:
> "some missing clang libs").  And I also edited LitConfig.py to
point to
> /sw/bin/bash (4.2) because /bin/bash is missing support for pipefail.
>
> Some of the tests hung indefinitely on 'lli', so I had to kill
them.
>
> My question is: which of the following test failures should be addressed
first
> as top priority?  Are there any low-hanging fruit that look easy to fix
> (looking at the full log)?
All the tests that say "No available targets" are incorrectly
configured; they assume the x86 backend is available.  They can be
"fixed" easily, but that won't really get you closer to a usable
compiler.

I would guess that all the PCH tests are crashing for the same reason,
so fixing that could fix a lot of failures at once on the clang side.

If you're interested in actually having a usable compiler for your
system, I would say the crashes in CodeGen/Generic and CodeGen/PowerPC
are the highest priority.

-Eli

David Fang

2011-Dec-16 06:51 UTC

head link

[LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8

Hi,
 	Thanks for the quick reply again.
> On Thu, Dec 15, 2011 at 1:17 PM, David Fang <fang at csl.cornell.edu>
wrote:
>> Hi,
>>
>> I've bootstrapped llvm/clang from svn-trunk on powerpc-darwin8
(g++-4.0.1), and
>> have the following test results to share.
>> Summary below, full log at:
>>
http://www.csl.cornell.edu/~fang/sw/llvm/r146586-powerpc-darwin8-results.txt
>>
>> The only edits required were those I posted to llvm-commits yesterday
(re:
>> "some missing clang libs").  And I also edited LitConfig.py
to point to
>> /sw/bin/bash (4.2) because /bin/bash is missing support for pipefail.
>>
>> Some of the tests hung indefinitely on 'lli', so I had to kill
them.
>>
>> My question is: which of the following test failures should be
addressed first
>> as top priority?  Are there any low-hanging fruit that look easy to fix
>> (looking at the full log)?
>
> All the tests that say "No available targets" are incorrectly
> configured; they assume the x86 backend is available.  They can be
> "fixed" easily, but that won't really get you closer to a
usable
> compiler.
I think these can be ignored for the time being...
> I would guess that all the PCH tests are crashing for the same reason,
> so fixing that could fix a lot of failures at once on the clang side.
> If you're interested in actually having a usable compiler for your
> system, I would say the crashes in CodeGen/Generic and CodeGen/PowerPC
> are the highest priority.
Indeed I am interested.  :)

Here's another interesting data point.
My full build/test log of release-3.0, bootstrapping with 
powerpc-darwin8-g++-4.0.1 is here:
http://www.csl.cornell.edu/~fang/sw/llvm/llvm-clang-release-3.0-powerpc-darwin8-g++-4.0.1-fink-build-log.txt
(append .bz2 to URL for compressed version)
fink info file (for darwin8 only): 
http://fink.cvs.sourceforge.net/viewvc/fink/experimental/fangism/finkinfo/llvm30.info?view=log
at revision 1.9.  (also patch file needed from the same dir.)

These results have far fewer failures than svn-trunk, and are also 
comparable to bootstrapping with gcc-4.6.2, summarized here: 
http://paste.lisp.org/display/126363
(Unfortunately, I no longer have the whole build/test log for the gcc46
bootstrap.)
This consistency between different bootstraps of the release gives me some 
hope that g++-4.0.1 is yet usable.

I don't know how far diverged trunk is from the 3.0-branch, but there are 
far fewer CodeGen test failures than with svn-trunk.  Both trunk and 
branch exhibit numerous PCH failures.  Does this suggest some code-gen 
regression on the trunk that others could hunt for?

In the full bootstrap log, I see numerous compiler warnings.  Could any of 
them be related to potential PCH errors?  For example, I see:
tools/clang/include/clang/Serialization/ASTBitCodes.h:100: warning: passing
negative
value '-0x00000000000000001' for argument 1 to
'clang::serialization::TypeIdx::TypeIdx(uint32_t)'
Is the Serialization code involved PCH reading/writing?

Thanks for entertaining my questions.  I know I'm just getting my feet wet 
with llvm/clang.

Fang
(I'm fangism in IRC.)

-- 
David Fang
http://www.csl.cornell.edu/~fang/

Reasonably Related Threads

Search for more possibly parallel threads

llvm dev - Dec 2011 - [LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8

[LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8

[LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8

[LLVMdev] llvm/clang test failures on powerpc-darwin8

Reasonably Related Threads