dovecot - Feb 2011 - Dovecot + Solr does not index without break-imap-search?

Hi folks,

We are working with Dovecot 2.0.9 with Solr support and there is a 
thing, a little strange for us. Let me explain.

We have this conf for Solr:
   plugin {
      ...
      fts = solr
      fts_solr =   url=http:// solr.domain:8983/solr/ break-imap-search
      quota = maildir
      ...
   }

With 'break-imap-search', Dovecot connects with solr, solr indexes all, 
searchs are fast and all works fine. BUT if we don't add 
'break-imap-search', solr doesn't index anything.

Logs don't report errors with debug/verbose options enabled. Somebody 
has any idea about this?. Thank you very much for all.


Regards.

-- 
Jose ?lvaro Dom?nguez
adominguez at yaco.es

Yaco Sistemas S.L.
http://www.yaco.es/
C/ Rioja 5, 41001 Sevilla
Tel?fono +34 954 50 00 57
Fax      +34 954 50 09 29

On 9.2.2011, at 15.12, Jose ?lvaro Dom?nguez D?az wrote:
> With 'break-imap-search', Dovecot connects with solr, solr indexes
all, searchs are fast and all works fine. BUT if we don't add
'break-imap-search', solr doesn't index anything.
With break-imap-search the indexing is used for TEXT and BODY search keys.
Strictly looking at the IMAP RFC this makes Dovecot noncompliant, but then again
there already are so many servers doing that that probably no one cares.

Without break-imap-search, indexing is used only for Dovecot-specific
X-TEXT-FAST and X-BODY-FAST search keys, which of course nothing uses unless you
modify your webmail. In future once Dovecot supports FUZZY extension this is
going to be used by it to make it a bit more useful.