dovecot - Jan 2009 - Sieve filters forwarding erratic after upgrade to 1.1.8

On 22.01.2009 20:42 David Anderson wrote:
> Upon upgrading Dovecot from 1.1.7 to 1.1.8, one of my sieve filters 
> (generated with avelsieve) no longer works.
Please show the filter rule.
> The filter is intended to redirect to another address when the header 
> from contains something like @example.com. However, it simply never 
> performs the redirection.
Here it works:

Jan 22 21:49:15 vh3 deliver(user at test.tld): Sending a forward to <user at
example.org> with return path <<john.doe at example.com>>
Jan 22 21:49:15 vh3 postfix/pickup[13961]: 5C3B165CF: uid=70005
from=<john.doe at example.com>
Jan 22 21:49:15 vh3 deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<6Zd0$2460.john.doe at
example.com>: forwarded to <user at example.org>
Jan 22 21:49:15 vh3 deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<6Zd0$2460.john.doe at
example.com>: saved mail to INBOX
> Tests show that if the filter also has the "keep copy in mailbox as
well
> as redirecting" open on, then the copy is kept. If that option is off,
> then no redirection happens and no copy is kept- i.e. the mail is 
> simply lost.
Works also w/o explicit "keep;" 
> Deleting and recreating the filter makes no difference, and neither does 
> moving its order in the list of filters. In the same list of filters a 
> vacation message works.
> On a second mailbox where a filter is redirecting all mail with header 
> precedence not equal to "list", the redirection always takes
place, so
> this isn't a generic problem with all redirections. I also updated 
> avelsieve from 1.9.7 (July 2007) to the latest SVN and this made no 
> difference.
> 
> I am using the dovecot-1.1.8-0_85.el5 and dovecot-sieve-1.1.5-8.el5 RPMs 
> from http://atrpms.net.
I'm using dovecot-sieve-1.1.6, compiled from source.


Regards,
Pascal

-- 
Ubuntu is an ancient African word meaning ?I can?t install Debian.?
                                                         -- unknown

On 23.01.2009 07:59 David Anderson wrote:
> On Thursday 22 January 2009, Pascal Volk wrote:
>> On 22.01.2009 20:42 David Anderson wrote:
>>> Upon upgrading Dovecot from 1.1.7 to 1.1.8, one of my sieve filters
>>> (generated with avelsieve) no longer works.
>> Please show the filter rule.
> 
> Thanks for the reply. Here it is (with vacation message and personal 
> info changed):
> 
> 
> require 
>
["fileinto","envelope","reject","vacation","imapflags","relational","comparator-i;ascii-numeric","notify"];
> if allof (not header :contains "Subject" "Re:",
> not header :contains "From" "support at example.com")
> {
> vacation :days 1 :addresses ["support at example.com"] text:
> Blah blah blah
> (snipped)
> .
> ;
> stop;
> }
> 
> if header :contains "From" "@example.com"
> {
> keep;
> redirect "sysadmin at example.com";
> }
> 
I've tested your sieve script. Here it works:

From: support at example.com; Subject: Test; MID: mail_0001 at example.com:
deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<mail_0001 at example.com>: saved mail to
INBOX
deliver(user at test.tld): Sending a forward to <sysadmin at example.com>
with return path <<support at example.com>>

From: support at example.com; Subj: Re: Test; MID: mail_0001_RE at example.com:
deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<mail_0001_RE at example.com>: saved mail
to INBOX
deliver(user at test.tld): Sending a forward to <sysadmin at example.com>
with return path <<support at example.com>>

From: support at example.com; Subject: What means Re:?;
MID: mail_0001_What_means_RE at example.com:
deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<mail_0001_What_means_RE at example.com>:
saved mail to INBOX
deliver(user at test.tld): Sending a forward to <sysadmin at example.com>
with return path <<support at example.com>>

From: john.doe at example.com; Subject: Test;
MID: 0003_john.doe at example.com:
deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<0003_john.doe at example.com>: sent
vacation response to <"john.doe"@example.com>
deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<0003_john.doe at example.com>: saved
mail to INBOX

From: john.doe at example.com; Subject: Re: Test;
MID: 0004_RE.john.doe at example.com:
deliver(user at test.tld): msgid=<0004_RE.john.doe at example.com>: saved
mail to INBOX
deliver(user at test.tld): Sending a forward to <sysadmin at example.com>
with return path <<john.doe at example.com>>

Please add "mail_debug = yes" to your protocol lda {...} section and
see
what deliver will log.


Regards,
Pascal
-- 
Ubuntu is an ancient African word meaning ?I can?t install Debian.?
                                                         -- unknown

On 24.01.2009 09:49 David Anderson wrote:
> 
> Thanks for the reply again. Here it is:
> ...
> Jan 24 08:38:04 levi deliver(support at example.com):
msgid=<200901241137.59870.david at example.com>: sent vacation response to
<david at example.com>
> Jan 24 08:38:04 levi deliver(support at example.com):
msgid=<200901241137.59870.david at example.com>: saved mail to INBOX
OK, let me guess: This was this part:
	if allof (not header :contains "Subject" "Re:",
	not header :contains "From" "support at example.com")
	{
	vacation :days 1 :addresses ["support at example.com"] text:
	Blah blah blah
	(snipped)
	.
	;
	stop;
	^^^^

After "stop;" the execution of the sieve script is done.
What happens if you send an e-mail with the following headers?
To: <support at example.com>
From: <david at example.com>
Subject: whatever


Regards,
Pascal

-- 
Ubuntu is an ancient African word meaning ?I can?t install Debian.?
                                                         -- unknown