asterisk users - Oct 2012 - Asterisk does not re-register as a sip client after a "sip reload" if "sip.conf" or "users.conf" is changed

Hi all,

I have a confusing problem with "sip reload".
I have an outgoing registration in my sip.conf in the form of
"register=>"
, and generally when ever I do a sip reload , asterisk sends out a new
registration and re-registers.
But if I change anything in sip.conf or users.conf , the re-registration
does not work anymore after a sip reload (even if I don't change the files
and just re-save them).
in this case after a sip reload when I issue "sip show registry" I see
0
registrations and not even a pending reg.
I need to add /delete users and extensions on a frequently basis and don't
want to lose my registrations to outside or my active calls , and I suppose
a "sip reload" after changing the configs is the only way .
I am really confused why it is not working.
I am sure that asterisk is re-reading the new config files --new users are
added-- but registration is not triggered again.
I am not sure if it is a misconfiguration on my side or some kind of bug in
asterisk but any help on this issue would be really appreciated.

* I tried including an external config file in sip.conf or users.conf but
in this case even without changing anything, after a sip reload , I lost my
registration.
* I tried mysql real time module but since I am working with some websocket
clients I have some issues to forward calls from udp clients to websocket
ones.
*I am working with trunk asterisk 11  (r 373330 ) and I tried it with the
latest trunk and same results .

Regards
Hadi Ams
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL:
<http://lists.digium.com/pipermail/asterisk-users/attachments/20121030/30df591f/attachment.htm>

Hadi Ams wrote:
> Hi all,
Hola,
> I have a confusing problem with "sip reload".
> I have an outgoing registration in my sip.conf in the form of
> "register=>" , and generally when ever I do a sip reload ,
asterisk
> sends out a new registration and re-registers.
> But if I change anything in sip.conf or users.conf , the re-registration
> does not work anymore after a sip reload (even if I don't change the
> files and just re-save them).
> in this case after a sip reload when I issue "sip show registry"
I see 0
> registrations and not even a pending reg.
> I need to add /delete users and extensions on a frequently basis and
> don't want to lose my registrations to outside or my active calls , and
> I suppose a "sip reload" after changing the configs is the only
way .
> I am really confused why it is not working.
> I am sure that asterisk is re-reading the new config files --new users
> are added-- but registration is not triggered again.
> I am not sure if it is a misconfiguration on my side or some kind of bug
> in asterisk but any help on this issue would be really appreciated.
Unfortunately this appears to be an issue with Asterisk 11. You can 
follow progress on solving it at 
https://issues.asterisk.org/jira/browse/ASTERISK-20611

Cheers,

-- 
Joshua Colp
Digium, Inc. | Senior Software Developer
445 Jan Davis Drive NW - Huntsville, AL 35806 - USA
Check us out at:  www.digium.com  & www.asterisk.org