samba - May 2018 - Dcs Replication

On Thu, 17 May 2018 17:19:17 -0300
Carlos via samba <samba at lists.samba.org> wrote:
> I understand, but dont replication between sites, is my problem....
> 
> Regards;
> 
Lets start by confirming if this is your setup:

         Matriz site          Filail
            DC1 --------------- DC3
             |                   |
             |                   |
            DC2                 DC4  

That is, DC1 & DC2 are in the Matriz site and DC3 & DC4 are the Filail
site

If that is correct, does DC1 replicate to DC2 and does DC3 replicate to
DC4 ?

Following on from that, does DC1 replicate to DC3

Rowland

Matriz site          		Filial site
             DC1 -------(OPENVPN)-------- DC3
              |
              |
             DC2

DC1 -> DC2 = OK
DC1 -> DC3 = OK

DC2 -> DC1 = OK
DC2 -> DC3 = NO

DC3 -> DC1 = OK
DC3 -> DC2 = NO

Then used option "kcc srv:samba kcc=No" or "created link",
replication full is ok, but(not well recommendation used this configuration),
and more error i received.

Regards;


On 17-05-2018 17:30, Rowland Penny wrote:
> On Thu, 17 May 2018 17:19:17 -0300
> Carlos via samba <samba at lists.samba.org> wrote:
>
>> I understand, but dont replication between sites, is my problem....
>>
>> Regards;
>>
> Lets start by confirming if this is your setup:
>
>           Matriz site          Filail
>              DC1 --------------- DC3
>               |                   |
>               |                   |
>              DC2                 DC4
>
> That is, DC1 & DC2 are in the Matriz site and DC3 & DC4 are the
Filail
> site
>
> If that is correct, does DC1 replicate to DC2 and does DC3 replicate to
> DC4 ?
>
> Following on from that, does DC1 replicate to DC3
>
> Rowland

On Thu, 17 May 2018 17:37:28 -0300
Carlos <carlos.hollow at gmail.com> wrote:
> 	Matriz site          		Filial site
>              DC1 -------(OPENVPN)-------- DC3
>               |
>               |
>              DC2
> 
> DC1 -> DC2 = OK
> DC1 -> DC3 = OK
> 
> DC2 -> DC1 = OK
> DC2 -> DC3 = NO
> 
> DC3 -> DC1 = OK
> DC3 -> DC2 = NO
THERE IS NOTHING WRONG, that is how it is supposed to work!
As I said, you are using SITES.
DC2 should not replicate to DC3 (or DC3 to DC2)
> 
> Then used option "kcc srv:samba kcc=No" or "created
link",
> replication full is ok, but(not well recommendation used this
> configuration), and more error i received.
Pretty obvious really, do not do this.

PS Where did DC4 come from/go to ?

Rowland