thr3ads.net - samba - [Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode [Sep 2017]

If this information is useful, please help other people find it:
Share via:

Dante Colo

2017-Sep-12 15:52 UTC

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

Hi Everyone ! 

I note that all of samba AD server that i maintain are not so fast in terms of
data transfer, more specifically none of them go over 40 MB/s , one particularly
which i'm trying to find out why doesn't go over 20 MB/s , transfering
data using other protocols like FTP , rsync , rsync over ssh on any of these
machines i can easily achieve 80 MB/s ,i also can get the same on Samba if i run
it as a basic standalone file server or classic pdc nt4 mode, is this normal ? I
didn't try yet to deploy a basic file server and join a samba AD , is this
better than use AD server itself in terms of data transfer performance ?

Regards 
Dante F. B. Colò

Jeremy Allison

2017-Sep-12 16:11 UTC

head link

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

On Tue, Sep 12, 2017 at 12:52:29PM -0300, Dante Colo via samba
wrote:> Hi Everyone ! 
> 
> I note that all of samba AD server that i maintain are not so fast in terms
of data transfer, more specifically none of them go over 40 MB/s , one
particularly which i'm trying to find out why doesn't go over 20 MB/s ,
transfering data using other protocols like FTP , rsync , rsync over ssh on any
of these machines i can easily achieve 80 MB/s ,i also can get the same on Samba
if i run it as a basic standalone file server or classic pdc nt4 mode, is this
normal ? I didn't try yet to deploy a basic file server and join a samba AD
, is this better than use AD server itself in terms of data transfer performance
?
ENODATA :-). We need much more information
on your setup in order to help.

Otherwise, this is equivalent to "my car won't
go faster than 40 mph, what's wrong ?"

There are a multitude of possible problems :-).

Dante Colo

2017-Sep-12 16:47 UTC

head link

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

Hello Jeremy

Thanks for reply , i'm using samba 4.5.10 compiled from source on CentOS 6
and 7 running as AD mode on all servers, network infrastructure components are
all Gigabit ethernet 1000 BaseT, clients are all windows 7 and 10 machines,
i'll post below Samba build options and smb.conf of one of my servers. I use
full_audit module on many shares, but i don't see any difference in transfer
performance on shares that don't have this module enabled. I also used
Sernet binary packages before but after upgrade to newer versions compiled from
source i didn't see any performance loss or gain in terms of data transfer.
Any recomendations ?



./configure --jobs=4 -vp --fatal-errors --slow --enable-debug --enable-selftest 
--with-logdir=/var/log/samba --sysconfdir=/etc --localstatedir=/var/lib/samba 
--oldincludedir=/usr/local/samba/old_include --man    dir=/usr/share/man 
--with-statedir=/var/lib/samba --with-privatedir=/var/lib/samba/private
--with-piddir=/var/run/samba --with-cachedir=/var/cache/samba
--with-lockdir=/var/lib/samba/locks --with-logfilebase=/var/log/samba
--with-sockets-dir=/var/run/samba --with-configdir=/etc/samba



[global]
        bind interfaces only = yes
        interfaces = lo em1
	workgroup = SOTOPIETRA
	realm = SOTOPIETRA.LOCAL
	netbios name = S11
        server string = SOTOPIETRA-PDC
	server role = active directory domain controller
	dns forwarder = 192.168.0.2
        time server = yes
	ntp signd socket directory = /var/lib/samba/ntp_signd
	server services = s3fs, rpc, nbt, wrepl, ldap, cldap, kdc, drepl, winbindd,
ntp_signd, kcc, dnsupdate, dns
        max log size = 4096
        debug class = yes
        debug prefix timestamp = yes
        log file = /var/log/samba/log.%I
       log level = 1 
        printing = bsd
        load printers = no
        printcap name = /dev/null
	disable spoolss = yes
	smb2 leases = no
	
[netlogon]
	path = /var/lib/samba/sysvol/sotopietra.local/scripts
	read only = yes 
        browsable = no
[sysvol]
	path = /var/lib/samba/sysvol
	read only = No
        browsable = yes 
[profiles]
        path = /samba/profiles
        writable = yes
        browsable = yes 
[Homedirs]
        path = /samba/homedirs
        writable = yes
        browsable = yes
[RH]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/rh
[Gerencia]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/gerencia
[Financeiro]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/financeiro
[Administrativo-Thais]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/administrativo_thais
[Virtua]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/virtua
[Base Virtua]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        write list = leonardo.soares
        read list = administrator
        path = /Virtua
[Juridico-Evandro]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/juridico_evandro
[Diretoria-Sotopietra]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/diret_sotopietra
[Iniciais]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/iniciais
[TI]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/ti
[Scanner]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/scanner
[Desktop]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files/desktop
[IntraChat]
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/intrachat
[SRC_COBRANCA_WEB]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
        full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
        full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
        full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
        full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writeable = yes
	browseable = yes
	path = /var/httpd/htdocs/src_cobranca_web
[SFTP]
	vfs objects = full_audit
        full_audit:prefix = "%u|%I|%P"
	full_audit:success = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:failure = rmdir unlink rename
	full_audit:facility = LOCAL0
	full_audit:priority = NOTICE
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /data/soto/sftp
[Arquivos]
	writable = yes
	browsable = yes
        path = /samba/files
        valid users = administrator,leonardo.soares



----- Original Message -----
From: "Jeremy Allison" <jra at samba.org>
To: "Dante Colo" <dante.colo at stwbrasil.com>
Cc: "samba" <samba at lists.samba.org>
Sent: Tuesday, September 12, 2017 1:11:11 PM
Subject: Re: [Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

On Tue, Sep 12, 2017 at 12:52:29PM -0300, Dante Colo via samba
wrote:> Hi Everyone ! 
> 
> I note that all of samba AD server that i maintain are not so fast in terms
of data transfer, more specifically none of them go over 40 MB/s , one
particularly which i'm trying to find out why doesn't go over 20 MB/s ,
transfering data using other protocols like FTP , rsync , rsync over ssh on any
of these machines i can easily achieve 80 MB/s ,i also can get the same on Samba
if i run it as a basic standalone file server or classic pdc nt4 mode, is this
normal ? I didn't try yet to deploy a basic file server and join a samba AD
, is this better than use AD server itself in terms of data transfer performance
?
ENODATA :-). We need much more information
on your setup in order to help.

Otherwise, this is equivalent to "my car won't
go faster than 40 mph, what's wrong ?"

There are a multitude of possible problems :-).

Andrew Bartlett

2017-Sep-12 18:53 UTC

head link

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

On Tue, 2017-09-12 at 09:11 -0700, Jeremy Allison via samba
wrote:> On Tue, Sep 12, 2017 at 12:52:29PM -0300, Dante Colo via samba wrote:
> > Hi Everyone ! 
> > 
> > I note that all of samba AD server that i maintain are not so fast in
terms of data transfer, more specifically none of them go over 40 MB/s , one
particularly which i'm trying to find out why doesn't go over 20 MB/s ,
transfering data using other protocols like FTP , rsync , rsync over ssh on any
of these machines i can easily achieve 80 MB/s ,i also can get the same on Samba
if i run it as a basic standalone file server or classic pdc nt4 mode, is this
normal ? I didn't try yet to deploy a basic file server and join a samba AD
, is this better than use AD server itself in terms of data transfer performance
?
> 
> ENODATA :-). We need much more information
> on your setup in order to help.
> 
> Otherwise, this is equivalent to "my car won't
> go faster than 40 mph, what's wrong ?"
> 
> There are a multitude of possible problems :-).
However, the first problem is that on the AD DC, smb signing is
required, which will make things slower than unprotected rsync.

Andrew Bartlett

-- 
Andrew Bartlett                       http://samba.org/~abartlet/
Authentication Developer, Samba Team  http://samba.org
Samba Developer, Catalyst IT          http://catalyst.net.nz/services/samba

Possibly Parallel Threads

Search for more maybe matching threads

samba - Sep 2017 - SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

[Samba] SMB data transfer performance on AD mode

Possibly Parallel Threads