samba - Mar 2015 - migrate from win2012srv to samba 4.1.17-Sernet-Debian-9.wheezy

Hello,

I'm trying to join a debian/samba4 to a win 2012 srv with this scripts : 
https://secure.bazuin.nl/scripts/this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts/
( the join method is available only on
"this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts")
I'm facing different problems with the dns (bind9)

My question is :
in 2-setup-sernet-samba4-ADDC-wheezy-JOIN-DC.sh script, What value 
should I put for SETIPDC1 under BIND9/DNS related settings? Is it the 
windows 2012 server ip or the new samba4 ip?
I'm asking this because in this script, we can read :
## the ip of DC1 should match the hostname above. ( which is set by 
default at
## hostname in single word, but you dont need to change this
SETHOSTNAME=`hostname -s`)
and we can read more down :
## Put here the IP of the first DC you installed.
SETIPDC1SETIPDC2
Just a bit strange, so I would like to be sure for put these value 
correctly...

Thanks! :)

On 17/03/15 14:00, Sam wrote:
>  Hello,
>
> I'm trying to join a debian/samba4 to a win 2012 srv with this scripts 
> : https://secure.bazuin.nl/scripts/this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts/
> ( the join method is available only on
"this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts")
> I'm facing different problems with the dns (bind9)
>
> My question is :
> in 2-setup-sernet-samba4-ADDC-wheezy-JOIN-DC.sh script, What value 
> should I put for SETIPDC1 under BIND9/DNS related settings? Is it the 
> windows 2012 server ip or the new samba4 ip?
> I'm asking this because in this script, we can read :
> ## the ip of DC1 should match the hostname above. ( which is set by 
> default at
> ## hostname in single word, but you dont need to change this
> SETHOSTNAME=`hostname -s`)
> and we can read more down :
> ## Put here the IP of the first DC you installed.
> SETIPDC1> SETIPDC2>
> Just a bit strange, so I would like to be sure for put these value 
> correctly...
>
> Thanks! :)
>
>
It says '## Put here the IP of the first DC you installed' it may better
put as ' ## Put here the IP of the DC with the PDC FSMO.'
Which in your case would be the windows DC.

Rowland

Hello Sam,

Am 17.03.2015 um 15:00 schrieb Sam:
> I'm trying to join a debian/samba4 to a win 2012 srv with this scripts
:
> https://secure.bazuin.nl/scripts/this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts/
> ( the join method is available only on
"this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts")
> I'm facing different problems with the dns (bind9)
> 
> My question is :
> in 2-setup-sernet-samba4-ADDC-wheezy-JOIN-DC.sh script, What value
> should I put for SETIPDC1 under BIND9/DNS related settings? Is it the
> windows 2012 server ip or the new samba4 ip?
> I'm asking this because in this script, we can read :
> ## the ip of DC1 should match the hostname above. ( which is set by
> default at
> ## hostname in single word, but you dont need to change this
> SETHOSTNAME=`hostname -s`)
> and we can read more down :
> ## Put here the IP of the first DC you installed.
> SETIPDC1> SETIPDC2
You can't join a Samba DC to a AD forest, that has a AD schema newer
than 2008R2. Samba doesn't support the later schemas at the moment.


Regards,
Marc

I just go down in the script and found an acl called "thisserverip"
with
value SETIPPDC1.
And this variable is used for this line :
listen-on port 53 {"thisserverip", 127.0.0.1; ];
Is it not strange that the pdc1 windows server Ip is coming here?
Thanks.

Sam

Le 17/03/2015 15:14, Rowland Penny a ?crit :
> On 17/03/15 14:00, Sam wrote:
>>  Hello,
>>
>> I'm trying to join a debian/samba4 to a win 2012 srv with this 
>> scripts : 
>> https://secure.bazuin.nl/scripts/this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts/
>> ( the join method is available only on
"this_is_the_old_set_of_scripts")
>> I'm facing different problems with the dns (bind9)
>>
>> My question is :
>> in 2-setup-sernet-samba4-ADDC-wheezy-JOIN-DC.sh script, What value 
>> should I put for SETIPDC1 under BIND9/DNS related settings? Is it the 
>> windows 2012 server ip or the new samba4 ip?
>> I'm asking this because in this script, we can read :
>> ## the ip of DC1 should match the hostname above. ( which is set by 
>> default at
>> ## hostname in single word, but you dont need to change this
>> SETHOSTNAME=`hostname -s`)
>> and we can read more down :
>> ## Put here the IP of the first DC you installed.
>> SETIPDC1>> SETIPDC2>>
>> Just a bit strange, so I would like to be sure for put these value 
>> correctly...
>>
>> Thanks! :)
>>
>>
> It says '## Put here the IP of the first DC you installed' it may 
> better put as ' ## Put here the IP of the DC with the PDC FSMO.'
> Which in your case would be the windows DC.
>
> Rowland
>

Am 17.03.2015 um 15:59 schrieb Sam:
> I have read about it but I try to do that :
> https://lists.samba.org/archive/samba/2013-May/173079.html
> unfortunately there is not a lot of details on how to do
> accurately...:-\
> The actual forest and domain level on the 2012 is still on 2008R2...
Can you check, what schema version you're having:
http://eightwone.com/references/ad-schema-versions/

Regards,
Marc