dovecot - Sep 2018 - v2.3.3 rc1 - Error: sieve: !!BUG!!: Binary compiled from dovecot.sieve is still corrupt

I have a sieve problem with dovecot v2.3.3 rc1 with either of pigeonhole 
0.5.2 or 0.5.3.rc1.  The the change that triggers this is in dovecot not 
pigeonhole.  Sieve filtering has been working with v2.3.2 and many 
earlier versions.


Log report:
Sep 24 10:36:13 mailhost dovecot: [ID 702911 mail.error] 
lmtp(user at domain.tld)<15816><RnikKw2wqFvIPQAAs831Jw>: Error:
sieve:
!!BUG!!: Binary compiled from /path/to/domain/user/dovecot.sieve is 
still corrupt; bailing out and reverting to default delivery


This is a sieve script with a vacation handler.  My other sieve filters 
are working.  My actual sieve filter worked before and was written by 
Roundcube web mail.  My failing test script is cut-n-paste from the 
sieve examples https://wiki2.dovecot.org/Pigeonhole/Sieve/Examples so 
should not be in doubt.

The text script compiles to dovecot.svbin and newly compiled files are 
identical to older versions, the compilation has not changed.



James.

Can you try with the sieve-test command-line tool, in particular with 
trace debugging enabled?



Op 24-9-2018 om 12:03 schreef James:
> I have a sieve problem with dovecot v2.3.3 rc1 with either of 
> pigeonhole 0.5.2 or 0.5.3.rc1.? The the change that triggers this is 
> in dovecot not pigeonhole.? Sieve filtering has been working with 
> v2.3.2 and many earlier versions.
>
>
> Log report:
> Sep 24 10:36:13 mailhost dovecot: [ID 702911 mail.error] 
> lmtp(user at domain.tld)<15816><RnikKw2wqFvIPQAAs831Jw>: Error:
sieve:
> !!BUG!!: Binary compiled from /path/to/domain/user/dovecot.sieve is 
> still corrupt; bailing out and reverting to default delivery
>
>
> This is a sieve script with a vacation handler.? My other sieve 
> filters are working.? My actual sieve filter worked before and was 
> written by Roundcube web mail.? My failing test script is cut-n-paste 
> from the sieve examples 
> https://wiki2.dovecot.org/Pigeonhole/Sieve/Examples so should not be 
> in doubt.
>
> The text script compiles to dovecot.svbin and newly compiled files are 
> identical to older versions, the compilation has not changed.
>
>
>
> James.

On 24/09/2018 11:51, Stephan Bosch wrote:
> Can you try with the sieve-test command-line tool, in particular with
> trace debugging enabled?
Thank you for the debugging tip, is this useful?


$ sieve-test -D -c dovecot.conf sieve message
sieve-test(james): Debug: sieve: Pigeonhole version 0.5.3.rc1 (716b1b49) 
initializing
sieve-test(james): Debug: sieve: include: sieve_global is not set; it is 
currently not possible to include `:global' scripts.
debug: file storage: Using Sieve script path: /home/james/sieve.
debug: file script: Opened script `sieve' from `/home/james/sieve'.
debug: Script `sieve' from /home/james/sieve successfully compiled.
sieve-test(james): Info: corrupt binary deleted.
sieve-test(james): Error: unlink((null)) failed: Bad address (in 
sieve-test.c:426)
sieve-test(james): Info: final result: failed; resolved with successful 
implicit keep




$ cat dovecot.conf
mail_uid = james
mail_gid = staff
mail_location = maildir:/path/to/%d/%n/Maildir
postmaster_address = postmaster at domain.tld



$ cat sieve
require ["vacation"];
vacation
   # Reply at most once a day to a same sender
   :days 1
   :subject "Out of office reply"
   # List of additional recipient addresses which are included in the 
auto replying.
   # If a mail's recipient is not the envelope recipient and it's not on
this list,
   # no vacation reply is sent for it.
   :addresses ["j.doe at company.dom", "john.doe at
company.dom"]
"I'm out of office, please contact Joan Doe instead.
Best regards
John Doe";



$ cat message
Subject: test
From: me at domain.tld

testing 123