samba - Jun 2013 - Fwd: Users cannot rename/delete files on Samba share

I'm starting a new thread because the issue now is different from the
one I was originally experiencing.

Here are two level 10 debug logs one from each of two servers:

http://w4fbc.org/samba/DC.log

http://w4fbc.org/samba/FS.log

Each has a test share setup like this:

chgrp -R staff-faculty /test
chmod 0770 /test
chmod g+s /test
setfacl -m g::rwx /test

[test]
path = /test
read only = no
inherit acls = yes
inherit permissions = yes

DC.log is from a Samba domain controller running 3.6.9. This test
share works as expected. Members of the staff-faculty group can
create/modify/delete/rename files regardless of user ownership in the
test share on this server.

FS.log is from a Samba domain member server now running 3.6.9. This
test share does not quite work. Members of the staff-faculty group can
create/modify files regardless of user ownership but cannot
delete/rename files regardless of user ownership.

FWIW, I have yet another Samba member server (PS) running 3.4.7 which
does not normally have shares. I have set up a test share on it
configured exactly the same as the two above mentioned servers. This
share behaves as expected (same as DC). Furthermore, PS is configured
exactly as FS with the exception of server name and shares.

The DC runs over an ldap backend and getent passwd and group behave as
expected on all Samba servers.

So any ideas on why the share on FS does not function as expected?

Kind Regards,
Chris

On Thu, Jun 27, 2013 at 10:00 AM, Chris Nighswonger
<cnighswonger at foundations.edu> wrote:
> FS.log is from a Samba domain member server now running 3.6.9. This
> test share does not quite work. Members of the staff-faculty group can
> create/modify files regardless of user ownership but cannot
> delete/rename files regardless of user ownership.
In case it might help someone else: removing winbind fixed the problem.

Kind Regards,
Chris