I tried VT-d pass-through with the latest xen-unstable and encounter the following issue(s) - 1) When I pass through a network adapter (doesn''t matter which kind), while I see the device within guest OS (tested with Vista and XP guest), I encounter a machine reset when the driver for the passed through network adapter is being installed (either through plug and play or by manual installation). I have attached information about the system in question. Has anyone tried pass-through on a system with the exact configuration provided in the attachment (including stepping; Note - network pass-through works on a machine with almost similar configuration except for stepping # difference)? Also, attached is bug check info if that is useful. 2) On a different machine, I encounter a bugcheck similar to the one entered in http://bugzilla.xensource.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=1244 only when I shutdown a domain that pass-through a Intel 82566DM-2 network adapter. As the bug report wasn''t specific about the device that is passed through when the machine reset happens, thought I would mention in case this helps narrow down the problem. Thanks, Kamala _______________________________________________ Xen-devel mailing list Xen-devel@lists.xensource.com http://lists.xensource.com/xen-devel
Hi Kamala, Our nightly testing didn''t encounter issue 1) before, but we didn''t test on the same machine you attached. Anyway, we will investigate it. And also, can you try out adding "hap=0" in your hvm.conf? For issue 2), I think it''s already fixed by c/s 17584. Randy (Weidong) Kamala Narasimhan wrote:> I tried VT-d pass-through with the latest xen-unstable and encounter > the following issue(s) - > > 1) When I pass through a network adapter (doesn''t matter which kind), > while I see the device within guest OS (tested with Vista and XP > guest), I encounter a machine reset when the driver for the passed > through network adapter is being installed (either through plug and > play or by manual installation). I have attached information about > the system in question. Has anyone tried pass-through on a system > with the exact configuration provided in the attachment (including > stepping; Note - network pass-through works on a machine with almost > similar configuration except for stepping # difference)? Also, > attached is bug check info if that is useful. > 2) On a different machine, I encounter a bugcheck similar to the one > entered in http://bugzilla.xensource.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=1244 > only when I shutdown a domain that pass-through a Intel 82566DM-2 > network adapter. As the bug report wasn''t specific about the device > that is passed through when the machine reset happens, thought I would > mention in case this helps narrow down the problem. > > Thanks, > Kamala_______________________________________________ Xen-devel mailing list Xen-devel@lists.xensource.com http://lists.xensource.com/xen-devel
> Hi Kamala, > > Our nightly testing didn''t encounter issue 1) before, but we didn''ttest> on the same machine you attached. Anyway, we will investigate it. And > also, can you try out adding "hap=0" in your hvm.conf?Adding "hap=0" to the conf file did not help, unfortunately; crashes at the same place. Let me know if I can try something else or get any further info you need to help solve this issue. Thanks, Kamala> For issue 2), I think it''s already fixed by c/s 17584. > > Randy (Weidong) > > Kamala Narasimhan wrote: > > I tried VT-d pass-through with the latest xen-unstable and encounter > > the following issue(s) - > > > > 1) When I pass through a network adapter (doesn''t matter whichkind),> > while I see the device within guest OS (tested with Vista and XP > > guest), I encounter a machine reset when the driver for the passed > > through network adapter is being installed (either through plug and > > play or by manual installation). I have attached information about > > the system in question. Has anyone tried pass-through on a system > > with the exact configuration provided in the attachment (including > > stepping; Note - network pass-through works on a machine with almost > > similar configuration except for stepping # difference)? Also, > > attached is bug check info if that is useful. > > 2) On a different machine, I encounter a bugcheck similar to the one > > entered inhttp://bugzilla.xensource.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=1244> > only when I shutdown a domain that pass-through a Intel 82566DM-2 > > network adapter. As the bug report wasn''t specific about the device > > that is passed through when the machine reset happens, thought Iwould> > mention in case this helps narrow down the problem. > > > > Thanks, > > Kamala_______________________________________________ Xen-devel mailing list Xen-devel@lists.xensource.com http://lists.xensource.com/xen-devel
Hi Kamala, It is caused by the Video ram dirty shadow optimization (cs. 17564) which wants to touch m2p for passthrough MMIO, while m2p entries for direct MMIO pages (e.g. 0xffxxx000) don''t exist. We will work out a patch for it later. Randy (Weidong) Kamala Narasimhan wrote:>> Hi Kamala, >> >> Our nightly testing didn''t encounter issue 1) before, but we didn''t >> test on the same machine you attached. Anyway, we will investigate >> it. And also, can you try out adding "hap=0" in your hvm.conf? > Adding "hap=0" to the conf file did not help, unfortunately; > crashes at the same place. Let me know if I can try something else or > get any further info you need to help solve this issue. > > Thanks, > Kamala > >> For issue 2), I think it''s already fixed by c/s 17584. >> >> Randy (Weidong) >> >> Kamala Narasimhan wrote: >>> I tried VT-d pass-through with the latest xen-unstable and >>> encounter the following issue(s) - >>> >>> 1) When I pass through a network adapter (doesn''t matter which >>> kind), while I see the device within guest OS (tested with Vista >>> and XP guest), I encounter a machine reset when the driver for the >>> passed through network adapter is being installed (either through >>> plug and play or by manual installation). I have attached >>> information about the system in question. Has anyone tried >>> pass-through on a system with the exact configuration provided in >>> the attachment (including stepping; Note - network pass-through >>> works on a machine with almost similar configuration except for >>> stepping # difference)? Also, attached is bug check info if that >>> is useful. 2) On a different machine, I encounter a bugcheck >>> similar to the one entered in > http://bugzilla.xensource.com/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=1244 >>> only when I shutdown a domain that pass-through a Intel 82566DM-2 >>> network adapter. As the bug report wasn''t specific about the device >>> that is passed through when the machine reset happens, thought I >>> would mention in case this helps narrow down the problem. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> Kamala_______________________________________________ Xen-devel mailing list Xen-devel@lists.xensource.com http://lists.xensource.com/xen-devel