Vorbis dev - Jun 2006 - Where should I put an Bugreport of OggEnc

Hi There,


I have a problem with OggEnc v1.0.2.

Can you tell me, where to put or to post a bug report?




The problems eare with some speciel charakters - used in Europe
(Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Germany, Austria, etc..)

Some Examples:

Hin Vordende Sod & S?
                    ^
02_Bruderov paa H?gstadtun.ogg
                 ^
03_Huldradans - Hin Gr?nnkledde.ogg
                      ^
05_Over ?girs vidstragte Sletter.ogg
        ^
04_N?r Slaget ?r Vunnet.ogg
    ^         ^
06_F?rd Mot Thrudvang.ogg
    ^  
10_...Ty M?rkret Skall Falla.ogg
          ^
If this "european characters" are inside the track information, then
OggEnc v1.0.2 repleced them by an "#". The Filename is fine, but the
tag is always wrecked.

Encoding with Lame is Okay. Those charakters are well done.

With oggenc I have to repair all tracks with easytag. :-(

Heino

On 6/25/06, Heino Tiedemann <rotkaps_spam_trap@gmx.de>
wrote:
> The problems eare with some speciel charakters - used in Europe
> (Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Germany, Austria, etc..)
Hi, could you tell us how you created the files, please? The more
detailed the description the better. Thank you. :)

Since EasyTAG is for GTK, I assume you're using *nix. Does your locale
currently support those characters? oggenc should definitely work fine
if your locale is UTF-8.

Cheers,
Kyungjoon Lee

Heino Tiedemann wrote:
> Hi There,
> 
> 
> I have a problem with OggEnc v1.0.2.
> 
> Can you tell me, where to put or to post a bug report?
<http://trac.xiph.org/>
> 
> The problems eare with some speciel charakters - used in Europe
> (Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Germany, Austria, etc..)
> 
> Some Examples:
> 
> Hin Vordende Sod & S?
>                     ^
> 02_Bruderov paa H?gstadtun.ogg
>                  ^
> 03_Huldradans - Hin Gr?nnkledde.ogg
>                       ^
> 05_Over ?girs vidstragte Sletter.ogg
>         ^
> 04_N?r Slaget ?r Vunnet.ogg
>     ^         ^
> 06_F?rd Mot Thrudvang.ogg
>     ^  
> 10_...Ty M?rkret Skall Falla.ogg
>           ^
> If this "european characters" are inside the track information,
then
> OggEnc v1.0.2 repleced them by an "#". The Filename is fine, but
the
> tag is always wrecked.
>
FC5:

$ oggenc in.flac -o l.ogg -a "?ric Clapt?n"
...

$ vorbiscomment l.ogg
artist=?ric Clapt?n
...
(can also do Greek)

I seem to remember something about this on the mailing list a while
back, you may want to search for unicode on vorbis and vorbis-dev.
I also have the following set in my shell:
CHARSET="UTF-8"
Which may or may not be related, if you want to try it remember to do:
$ export CHARSET=UTF-8
before running oggenc in the same shell.

I've got it in my ~/.bashrc at the end as follows:
# For vorbistools
export CHARSET=UTF-8

-- 
imalone

"Kyungjoon Lee" <kjoonlee@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 6/25/06, Heino Tiedemann <rotkaps_spam_trap@gmx.de> wrote:
>> Thanks f?r the tipp, but then /it is/ a bug,
>>
>> de_DE.ISO8859-15
>> de_DE.ISO8859-1
>>
>> should also work with the chrakters from germany and Austria (and
>> Switzerland?) ??????oe
>
> OK, have you tried running just oggenc from the console, like Mr Ian
> Malone suggested?
>
> oggenc in.wav -o output.ogg -c "comment=?, ?, ? / ?, ?, ?oe"
The Same Bug (used --title tag):
,----
| oggenc audio.wav -o audio.ogg --title "Over ?girs Vidstragte
Sletter"
`----

In my Player (xmms or winamp) is the ? replaced by sharp(#).

Is it Possible, that oggenc can only work with UTF-8? How knows the
player (xmms, Winamp) what charset was used during creation?

Heino

Heino Tiedemann wrote:
> If this "european characters" are inside the track information,
then
> OggEnc v1.0.2 repleced them by an "#". The Filename is fine, but
the
> tag is always wrecked.
This problem was fixed 9 months ago but for some reason xiph.org seems 
to be vehemently opposed to doing actual releases:

http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=vorbis-dev&m=113318093909270&w=2

At the bottom of that trac.xiph.org link mentioned, there's the option 
to download the patch as a unidiff. If you apply and recompile, it'll 
work again.

Rene.

Heino Tiedemann wrote:
> "Kyungjoon Lee" <kjoonlee@gmail.com> wrote:
> 
>> On 6/25/06, Heino Tiedemann <rotkaps_spam_trap@gmx.de> wrote:
>>> Thanks f?r the tipp, but then /it is/ a bug,
>>>
>>> de_DE.ISO8859-15
>>> de_DE.ISO8859-1
>>>
>>> should also work with the chrakters from germany and Austria (and
>>> Switzerland?) ??????oe
>> OK, have you tried running just oggenc from the console, like Mr Ian
>> Malone suggested?
>>
>> oggenc in.wav -o output.ogg -c "comment=?, ?, ? / ?, ?, ?oe"
> 
> The Same Bug (used --title tag):
> ,----
> | oggenc audio.wav -o audio.ogg --title "Over ?girs Vidstragte
Sletter"
> `----
> 
> In my Player (xmms or winamp) is the ? replaced by sharp(#).
> 
> Is it Possible, that oggenc can only work with UTF-8? How knows the
> player (xmms, Winamp) what charset was used during creation?
> 
Not sure about oggenc, but under linux vorbiscomment (which is
part of the same vorbis-tools package) uses one of:
the environment variable CHARSET
nl_langinfo from langinfo.h

(svn.xiph.org/trunk/vorbis-tools/share/utf8.c)

Possibly you could try CHARSET=ISO8859-15

-- 
imalone