Hi Team, I admit that I am not familiar with Tinc very well, but have Tinc running at approximately 20 sites and functioning as a mesh vpn/network. I am having issues adding an additional site as it will not communicate with the rest. I have taken the firmware of one and flashed it on another router to make it duplicate and then tested it working but when I change the hostname, and IP to what we need it to be (in this case 172.16.100.0) it no longer communicates with the rest of the network even though I have the same public key (they all have the same key) as well as adding it to the host folder and tinc config file on every other router. Am I missing something? The current system seems to be working now but having issues to add new. Thanks in advance for any advise assistance or referral you could provide. Regards, Chris Contents of the /etc/tinc/NETNAME/hosts/ folder (NOTE pfsense is just what we called the sites) pfsense1 pfsense100 pfsense11 pfsense12 pfsense16 pfsense17 pfsense19 pfsense2 pfsense20 pfsense201 pfsense26 pfsense27 pfsense4 pfsense7 All of the /etc/tinc/NETNAME/hosts/ files have the same public key on each router as well as each file above. Here is the current configuration setup. (OpenWRT router is .254 on all subnets) Pfsense1 is 172.16.1.0 Pfsense2 is 172.16.2.0 Pfsense4 is 172.16.4.0 Etc.. Partial file contents of /etc/config/tinc config tinc-net NETNAME option enabled 1 option logfile /tmp/log/tinc.log option debug 1 option AddressFamily ipv4 list ConnectTo=pfsense2 list ConnectTo=pfsense4 list ConnectTo=pfsense12 list ConnectTo=pfsense201 list ConnectTo=pfsense11 list ConnectTo=pfsense1 list ConnectTo=pfsense19 list ConnectTo=pfsense7 list ConnectTo pfsense26 list ConnectTo pfsense27 list ConnectTo pfsense100 option Name pfsense16 config tinc-host pfsense20 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address {PUBLICIPHERE for this site} option Subnet 172.16.20.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense7 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address {PUBLICIPHERE for this site} option Subnet 172.16.7.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense19 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address {PUBLICIPHERE for this site} option Subnet 172.16.19.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense100 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address {PUBLICIPHERE for this site} option Subnet 172.16.100.0/24 It continues with the rest of the sites that I did not list to limit email length. File contents of /etc/tinc/NETNAME/tinc-up #!/bin/sh ip=`uci get network.lan.ipaddr` ifconfig $INTERFACE $ip File contents of /etc/tinc/NETNAME/tinc-down #!/bin/sh ifconfig $INTERFACE down File contents of /etc/tinc/NETNAME/subnet-up #!/bin/sh [ $NODE = `uci get tinc.$NETNAME.Name` ] && exit case $SUBNET in */32) targetType=-host ;; *) targetType=-net ;; esac route add $targetType $SUBNET dev $INTERFACE File contents of /etc/tinc/NETNAME/subnet-down [ $NODE = `uci get tinc.$NETNAME.Name` ] && exit case $SUBNET in */32) targetType=-host ;; *) targetType=-net ;; esac route del $targetType $SUBNET dev $INTERFACE To be clear (also not sure how it works without it) but tinc.conf is not in the /etc/tinc/NETNAME folder. We can see it in the /tmp/tinc/NETNAME directory only and its contents are below. File contents of /tmp/tinc/NETNAME/tinc.conf (this is on the pfsense16 unit with subnet 172.16.16.0) AddressFamily = ipv4 ConnectTo = pfsense26 ConnectTo = pfsense27 Name = pfsense16 -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: <http://www.tinc-vpn.org/pipermail/tinc/attachments/20180315/b7c8d1eb/attachment.html>
On Thu, Mar 15, 2018 at 03:41:00PM +0000, Chris . wrote:> I admit that I am not familiar with Tinc very well, but have Tinc running at approximately 20 sites and functioning as a mesh vpn/network. I am having issues adding an additional site as it will not communicate with the rest. I have taken the firmware of one and flashed it on another router to make it duplicate and then tested it working but when I change the hostname, and IP to what we need it to be (in this case 172.16.100.0) it no longer communicates with the rest of the network even though I have the same public key (they all have the same key) as well as adding it to the host folder and tinc config file on every other router. Am I missing something? The current system seems to be working now but having issues to add new.I suspect you do have an error in your configuration somewhere. Either on the new node, or in the other node(s) that will have connections with the new node. Check for typos.> Partial file contents of /etc/config/tinc > > config tinc-net NETNAME > option enabled 1 > option logfile /tmp/log/tinc.log > option debug 1 > option AddressFamily ipv4 > > list ConnectTo=pfsense2 > list ConnectTo=pfsense4 > list ConnectTo=pfsense12 > list ConnectTo=pfsense201 > list ConnectTo=pfsense11 > list ConnectTo=pfsense1 > list ConnectTo=pfsense19 > list ConnectTo=pfsense7 > list ConnectTo pfsense26 > list ConnectTo pfsense27 > list ConnectTo pfsense100 > option Name pfsense16I'm no pfsense expert. But why do some lines have ConnectTo=pfsense with a = sign between ConnectTo and pfsense, and other lines have a space instead of the =?> To be clear (also not sure how it works without it) but tinc.conf is not in the /etc/tinc/NETNAME folder. We can see it in the /tmp/tinc/NETNAME directory only and its contents are below. > File contents of /tmp/tinc/NETNAME/tinc.conf (this is on the pfsense16 unit with subnet 172.16.16.0) > AddressFamily = ipv4 > ConnectTo = pfsense26 > ConnectTo = pfsense27 > Name = pfsense16I see only two ConnectTo's here, ConnectTo = pfsense100 is missing. Could that be the problem? -- Met vriendelijke groet / with kind regards, Guus Sliepen <guus at tinc-vpn.org> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: signature.asc Type: application/pgp-signature Size: 833 bytes Desc: not available URL: <http://www.tinc-vpn.org/pipermail/tinc/attachments/20180315/dc2cdf97/attachment.sig>
Regarding the connect to spaces and = is a great question which I do not know. What is the proper configuration for the connect to command and how should it be used. I do not see specifically I nthe documentation that specifies that for the /etc/config/tinc file. The pfsense is just the name given by the initial person that set it up and has nothing specific to do with pfsense. When I edit the /tmp/tinc/NETNAME/tinc.conf file and reboot it (I think obviously) changes. How would I make the change stick. Does it default look at the /etc/tinc/NETNAME/tinc.conf first before it looks at the /tmp...... location? I tried to create the file in /etc/tinc/NETNAME directory but that seemed to have no effect after adding the new site to an existing location. Here is an existing site called pfsense12 CONTENTS of /etc/tinc/NETNAME/hosts/pfsense100 (RSA PUBLIC KEY IS HERE) CONTENTS of /etc/config/tinc config tinc-net NETNAME option enabled 1 option logfile /tmp/log/tinc.log # option debug 1 option AddressFamily ipv4 list ConnectTo pfsense2 list ConnectTo pfsense4 list ConnectTo pfsense18 list ConnectTo pfsense201 list ConnectTo pfsense11 list ConnectTo pfsense7 list ConnectTo pfsense1 list ConnectTo pfsense16 list ConnectTo pfsense19 list ConnectTo pfsense17 list ConnectTo pfsense20 list ConnectTo pfsense26 list ConnectTo pfsense100 list ConnectTo pfsense27 option Name pfsense12 option PrivateKeyFile /etc/tinc/NETNAME/rsa_key.priv config tinc-host pfsense20 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address PUBLIC IP OF THIS SITE option Subnet 172.16.20.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense7 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address PUBLIC IP OF THIS SITE option Subnet 172.16.7.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense100 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address PUBLIC IP OF THIS SITE option Subnet 172.16.17.100/24 .... IT continues to list all of the sites. Below is the contents of the new site that we are trying to add. CONTENTS of /etc/tinc/NETNAME/hosts/pfsense12 (RSA PUBLIC KEY IS HERE) CONTENTS of /etc/config/tinc config tinc-net NETNAME option enabled 1 option logfile /var/log/tinc.log option debug 5 option AddressFamily ipv4 list ConnectTo pfsense201 list ConnectTo pfsense7 list ConnectTo pfsense4 list ConnectTo pfsense12 list ConnectTo pfsense11 list ConnectTo pfsense1 list ConnectTo pfsense16 list ConnectTo pfsense19 list ConnectTo pfsense2 list ConnectTo pfsense28 list ConnectTo pfsense29 option Name pfsense100 option PrivateKeyFile /etc/tinc/NETNAME/rsa_key.priv config tinc-host pfsense28 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address PUBLIC IP HERE option Subnet 172.16.28.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense12 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address PUBLIC IP HERE option Subnet 172.16.29.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense201 option enable 1 option net NETNAME option Address PUBLIC IP HERE option Subnet 172.16.201.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense7 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address PUBLIC IP HERE option Subnet 172.16.7.0/24 Does that look correct? Thank you for the response! Chris -----Original Message----- From: tinc [mailto:tinc-bounces at tinc-vpn.org] On Behalf Of Guus Sliepen Sent: Thursday, March 15, 2018 3:57 PM To: tinc at tinc-vpn.org Subject: Re: issues connecting in other sites On Thu, Mar 15, 2018 at 03:41:00PM +0000, Chris . wrote:> I admit that I am not familiar with Tinc very well, but have Tinc running at approximately 20 sites and functioning as a mesh vpn/network. I am having issues adding an additional site as it will not communicate with the rest. I have taken the firmware of one and flashed it on another router to make it duplicate and then tested it working but when I change the hostname, and IP to what we need it to be (in this case 172.16.100.0) it no longer communicates with the rest of the network even though I have the same public key (they all have the same key) as well as adding it to the host folder and tinc config file on every other router. Am I missing something? The current system seems to be working now but having issues to add new.I suspect you do have an error in your configuration somewhere. Either on the new node, or in the other node(s) that will have connections with the new node. Check for typos.> Partial file contents of /etc/config/tinc > > config tinc-net NETNAME > option enabled 1 > option logfile /tmp/log/tinc.log > option debug 1 > option AddressFamily ipv4 > > list ConnectTo=pfsense2 > list ConnectTo=pfsense4 > list ConnectTo=pfsense12 > list ConnectTo=pfsense201 > list ConnectTo=pfsense11 > list ConnectTo=pfsense1 > list ConnectTo=pfsense19 > list ConnectTo=pfsense7 > list ConnectTo pfsense26 > list ConnectTo pfsense27 > list ConnectTo pfsense100 > option Name pfsense16I'm no pfsense expert. But why do some lines have ConnectTo=pfsense with a = sign between ConnectTo and pfsense, and other lines have a space instead of the =?> To be clear (also not sure how it works without it) but tinc.conf is not in the /etc/tinc/NETNAME folder. We can see it in the /tmp/tinc/NETNAME directory only and its contents are below. > File contents of /tmp/tinc/NETNAME/tinc.conf (this is on the pfsense16 > unit with subnet 172.16.16.0) AddressFamily = ipv4 ConnectTo = > pfsense26 ConnectTo = pfsense27 Name = pfsense16I see only two ConnectTo's here, ConnectTo = pfsense100 is missing. Could that be the problem? -- Met vriendelijke groet / with kind regards, Guus Sliepen <guus at tinc-vpn.org>
I did notice the that interface we have named br-lan did not have the proper broadcast and netmask information. I adjusted that and it looks like its now connecting but still running into issues. Here is a snipet from the new system we are trying to connect in (from the /var/log/tinc.log file) 2018-03-15 22:57:26 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:57:26 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:31 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:57:31 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:35 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got KEY_CHANGED from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305): 14 247954dd pfsense29 2018-03-15 22:57:35 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Forwarding KEY_CHANGED from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305): 14 247954dd pfsense29 2018-03-15 22:57:36 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:57:36 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:41 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:57:41 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:46 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:57:46 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:51 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:57:51 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:56 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:57:56 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:56 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Trying to connect to pfsense12 (PFSENSE12-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:57:59 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Error while connecting to pfsense12 (PFSENSE12-PUBLICIP port 655): No route to host 2018-03-15 22:57:59 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Could not set up a meta connection to pfsense12 2018-03-15 22:57:59 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Trying to re-establish outgoing connection in 155 seconds 2018-03-15 22:58:01 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:01 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:06 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:06 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:11 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:11 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:16 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:16 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:21 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:21 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:22 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got PING from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305): 8 2018-03-15 22:58:22 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending PONG to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305): 9 2018-03-15 22:58:22 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending 2 bytes of metadata to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305) 2018-03-15 22:58:22 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Flushing 2 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305) 2018-03-15 22:58:23 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending PING to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305): 8 2018-03-15 22:58:23 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending 2 bytes of metadata to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305) 2018-03-15 22:58:23 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Flushing 2 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305) 2018-03-15 22:58:23 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got MTU probe length 1459 from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:23 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got MTU probe length 1459 from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:23 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got PONG from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 45305): 9 2018-03-15 22:58:23 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got MTU probe length 1459 from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:25 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending MTU probe length 1467 to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:25 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending MTU probe length 1459 to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:25 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending MTU probe length 1459 to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:25 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending MTU probe length 1459 to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:25 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got MTU probe length 1459 from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:25 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got MTU probe length 1459 from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:25 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Got MTU probe length 1459 from pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:26 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:26 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:31 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:31 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) 2018-03-15 22:58:36 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Read packet of 74 bytes from Linux tun/tap device (tun mode) 2018-03-15 22:58:36 tinc.NETNAME[871]: Sending packet of 74 bytes to pfsense201 (PFSENSE201-PUBLICIP port 655) I changed the /etc/config/tinc file for testing just listed only two sites to connect to. Below is for the new 100 site im trying to connect into the network. config tinc-net NETNAME option enabled 1 option logfile /var/log/tinc.log option debug 5 option AddressFamily ipv4 list ConnectTo pfsense201 list ConnectTo pfsense12 option Name pfsense100 option PrivateKeyFile /etc/tinc/NETNAME/rsa_key.priv config tinc-host pfsense201 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME option Address PUBLICIPOFTHISSITEHERE option Subnet 172.16.201.0/24 config tinc-host pfsense12 option enabled 1 option net NETNAME list Address PUBLICIPOFTHISSITEHERE option Subnet 172.16.12.0/24 Summary, it looks like its connecting BUT when I ping I get time out and I cannot visit any http either. I looked at other users issues with connectivity and no ping but cannot determine the issue running wireshark. Any ideas? Thank you again for the guidance! Chris -----Original Message----- From: tinc [mailto:tinc-bounces at tinc-vpn.org] On Behalf Of Guus Sliepen Sent: Thursday, March 15, 2018 3:57 PM To: tinc at tinc-vpn.org Subject: Re: issues connecting in other sites On Thu, Mar 15, 2018 at 03:41:00PM +0000, Chris . wrote:> I admit that I am not familiar with Tinc very well, but have Tinc running at approximately 20 sites and functioning as a mesh vpn/network. I am having issues adding an additional site as it will not communicate with the rest. I have taken the firmware of one and flashed it on another router to make it duplicate and then tested it working but when I change the hostname, and IP to what we need it to be (in this case 172.16.100.0) it no longer communicates with the rest of the network even though I have the same public key (they all have the same key) as well as adding it to the host folder and tinc config file on every other router. Am I missing something? The current system seems to be working now but having issues to add new.I suspect you do have an error in your configuration somewhere. Either on the new node, or in the other node(s) that will have connections with the new node. Check for typos.> Partial file contents of /etc/config/tinc > > config tinc-net NETNAME > option enabled 1 > option logfile /tmp/log/tinc.log > option debug 1 > option AddressFamily ipv4 > > list ConnectTo=pfsense2 > list ConnectTo=pfsense4 > list ConnectTo=pfsense12 > list ConnectTo=pfsense201 > list ConnectTo=pfsense11 > list ConnectTo=pfsense1 > list ConnectTo=pfsense19 > list ConnectTo=pfsense7 > list ConnectTo pfsense26 > list ConnectTo pfsense27 > list ConnectTo pfsense100 > option Name pfsense16I'm no pfsense expert. But why do some lines have ConnectTo=pfsense with a = sign between ConnectTo and pfsense, and other lines have a space instead of the =?> To be clear (also not sure how it works without it) but tinc.conf is not in the /etc/tinc/NETNAME folder. We can see it in the /tmp/tinc/NETNAME directory only and its contents are below. > File contents of /tmp/tinc/NETNAME/tinc.conf (this is on the pfsense16 > unit with subnet 172.16.16.0) AddressFamily = ipv4 ConnectTo = > pfsense26 ConnectTo = pfsense27 Name = pfsense16I see only two ConnectTo's here, ConnectTo = pfsense100 is missing. Could that be the problem? -- Met vriendelijke groet / with kind regards, Guus Sliepen <guus at tinc-vpn.org>