search for: sel_i

Hi Vincent, On 25/10/2012 18:14, Vincent Lejeune wrote: > When examining the debug output of regalloc, it seems that joining 32bits reg also joins 128 parent reg. > > If I look at the : > %vreg34<def> = COPY %vreg6:sel_y; R600_Reg32:%vreg34 R600_Reg128:%vreg6 > > instructions ; it gets joined to : > 928B%vreg34<def> = COPY %vreg48:sel_y; > > when vreg6 and

Thank for your help. You're right, merging vreg32 and vreg48 is perfectly fine, sorry I missed that. I "brute force" debuged by adding MachineFunction dump after each join, I think I found the issue : it's when vreg32 and vreg10 are merged. vreg10 only appears in BB#3, and the join only occurs in BB#3 apparently even if vreg32 lives in the 4 machine blocks After joining, there

Vincent, File a bug report so you can get a fix for it. Ivan On 25/10/2012 23:01, Vincent Lejeune wrote: > Thank for your help. You're right, merging vreg32 and vreg48 is perfectly fine, sorry I missed that. > I "brute force" debuged by adding MachineFunction dump after each join, I think I found the issue : it's when vreg32 and vreg10 are merged. > vreg10 only

When examining the debug output of regalloc, it seems that joining 32bits reg also joins 128 parent reg. If I look at the : %vreg34<def> = COPY %vreg6:sel_y; R600_Reg32:%vreg34 R600_Reg128:%vreg6 instructions ; it gets joined to : 928B%vreg34<def> = COPY %vreg48:sel_y;  when vreg6 and vreg48 are joined. It's right. But joining the following copy 

> > PHIElim and TwoAddress passes leave SSA form. > May be a missed something in your code but %vreg48 seems to be there > after PHI elimination. PHIElim tags those kind of registers as being > PHIJoin regs, updating LiveVariables pass, so the regcoalescer is aware > of them (some SSA info is still alive but the reg coalescer will > invalidate that information after

Hi, I don't know if my llvm ir code is faulty, or if I spot a bug in the RegisterCoalescing Pass, so I'm posting my issue on the ML. Shader and print-before-all dump are given below. The interessing part is the vreg6/vreg48 reduction : before RegCoalescing, the machine code is : // BEFORE LOOP ... Some COPYs.... 400B%vreg47<def> = COPY %vreg2<kill>; R600_Reg32:%vreg47,%vreg2

Hi Vincent, On 24/10/2012 23:26, Vincent Lejeune wrote: > Hi, > > I don't know if my llvm ir code is faulty, or if I spot a bug in the RegisterCoalescing Pass, so I'm posting my issue on the ML. Shader and print-before-all dump are given below. > > The interessing part is the vreg6/vreg48 reduction : before RegCoalescing, the machine code is : > > // BEFORE LOOP >

Hi, below is an output of "llc -march=r600 -mcpu=cayman -print-before-all -debug-only=regalloc file.shader" command from llvm3.2svn. The register coalescing pass crashes when joining vreg12:sel_z with vreg13 registers, because it tries to access the interval liveness of vreg13... which is undefined. I don't know if it's a bug of the pass, or if my backend should do something

Tom, I think it might be productive to fork this thread to discuss making the requirements for upstreaming a new LLVM target more explicit and open. I'd also like to gauge interest in an idea I've discussed privately with a few community members, namely the concept of having a semi-official "incubation" system whereby proposed backends could get a trial run before becoming part