Displaying 6 results from an estimated 6 matches for "peopleson".
2007 Sep 09
2
The use for an XML based metadata format
...> comment to some extent. But it is way to limited. Try describing
> > > > this with Voribs comments and you will see my point:
> > > > <person role="vocal instrument" uri="http://person.no/"
> > > > xml:lang="nb-NO">Person Peopleson</person>
>
> BTW: have you tried it yourself? If yes, and you have come up with a
> very terrible way of doing so, pasting it here for reference and as a
> good argument against using vorbiscomment for what you're after is a
> good thing. It supports your argument. Otherwis...
2007 Sep 09
2
The use for an XML based metadata format
...gh *a lot* about this. You can improve Vorbis comment to some
> extent. But it is way to limited. Try describing this with Voribs comments
> and you will see my point:
> <person role="vocal instrument" uri="http://person.no/"
> xml:lang="nb-NO">Person Peopleson</person>
So we're looking at replacing vorbiscomment with a xml version? How
intensively have you looked at improving/extending CMML? Subtitles for
one would definitely be better off being added to CMML than any other
place.
Regards,
Silvia.
2007 Sep 09
7
The use for an XML based metadata format
Daniel,
these are all good ideas and worth progressing. However, it may be
better not to merge too many goals in one format (MPEG-7 did that and
ended up as a big mess). So, I suggest to start by structuring the
types of things you want - then finding out which parts belong where
into existing formats such as vorbis comment, Skeleton and CMML, and
only then start to develop a new format.
For
2007 Sep 09
0
The use for an XML based metadata format
...s. You can improve Vorbis comment to
> > some extent. But it is way to limited. Try describing this with Voribs
> > comments and you will see my point:
> > <person role="vocal instrument" uri="http://person.no/"
> > xml:lang="nb-NO">Person Peopleson</person>
>
> So we're looking at replacing vorbiscomment with a xml version?
Yes.
To me, Vorbis comments are insufficient. Ask anyone playing in an ensamble
if they would like recognition. Ask the record label holding the rights to
a song. Ask the music geek that wants his music...
2007 Sep 09
0
The use for an XML based metadata format
...No. I have though *a lot* about this. You can improve Vorbis comment to some
extent. But it is way to limited. Try describing this with Voribs comments
and you will see my point:
<person role="vocal instrument" uri="http://person.no/"
xml:lang="nb-NO">Person Peopleson</person>
> All I ask for is *not* to reinvent the wheel when there are already
> working, semi-complete metadata formats for Ogg that have been
> carefully prepared to fit with the existing Ogg framework. It would be
> a sheer nightmare to create another new one that does not fit...
2007 Sep 09
0
The use for an XML based metadata format
...orbis comment to
> > > some extent. But it is way to limited. Try describing this with Voribs
> > > comments and you will see my point:
> > > <person role="vocal instrument" uri="http://person.no/"
> > > xml:lang="nb-NO">Person Peopleson</person>
BTW: have you tried it yourself? If yes, and you have come up with a
very terrible way of doing so, pasting it here for reference and as a
good argument against using vorbiscomment for what you're after is a
good thing. It supports your argument. Otherwise you are just waving
yo...