search for: geoffray_vmkitproject

...ain about scientific inaccuracy of the paper http://hal.inria.fr/docs/00/35/45/77/PDF/RR-6799.pdf written by Nicolas Geoffray, Gaël Thomas, Charles Clément, Bertil Folliot, Gilles Muller and presentation done by Nicolas Geoffray on LLVM conference supported by Google: http://llvm.org/devmtg/2008-08/Geoffray_VMKitProject.pdf They provide comparison of their system that uses LLVM, with our system Portable.NET that uses LibJIT for Just-In-Time compilation. All measures in this paper have been done for Portable.NET 0.7.4, which does not use LibJIT as its engine. However, the author provides results of Portable.NET 0....

...curacy of the paper > http://hal.inria.fr/docs/00/35/45/77/PDF/RR-6799.pdf written by > Nicolas Geoffray, Gaël Thomas, Charles Clément, Bertil Folliot, Gilles > Muller and presentation done by Nicolas Geoffray on LLVM conference > supported by Google: > http://llvm.org/devmtg/2008-08/Geoffray_VMKitProject.pdf > > They provide comparison of their system that uses LLVM, with our > system Portable.NET that uses LibJIT for Just-In-Time compilation. > All measures in this paper have been done for Portable.NET 0.7.4, > which does not use LibJIT as its engine. However, the author provides &g...

On Apr 20, 2009, at 12:42 PM, Kirill Kononenko wrote: > Dear all, > > > This new version of the paper at: > > http://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/docs/00/36/53/37/PDF/RR-6799.pdf > > got ride of libJIT. Now my question is the how scientific is this > research and research paper if instead of using libJIT and > Portable.NET JIT: > authors of "VMKit: a Substrate

Hi Chris How does this has nothing to do with llvm? Is not the VMKit project an official part of LLVM? Thanks, Kirill -- http://code.google.com/p/libjit-linear-scan-register-allocator/

...ibjit. > > End of the story. > > Nicolas > > Kirill Kononenko wrote: >> >> Hi Chris, >> >> >> Just in case that this information does not get corrupted I want to >> point to the issue: >> >> >> In http://llvm.org/devmtg/2008-08/Geoffray_VMKitProject.pdf it is on >> page 21: "VMKit, Mono, PNet", Array bounds checks. >> >> In http://hal.inria.fr/docs/00/35/45/77/PDF/RR-6799.pdf it is on page >> 17: "We compare N3 with Mono [9] version 1.2.6, and PNet version 0.7.4 >> [2], which uses libjit as dynamic...

Hi Chris, Just in case that this information does not get corrupted I want to point to the issue: In http://llvm.org/devmtg/2008-08/Geoffray_VMKitProject.pdf it is on page 21: "VMKit, Mono, PNet", Array bounds checks. In http://hal.inria.fr/docs/00/35/45/77/PDF/RR-6799.pdf it is on page 17: "We compare N3 with Mono [9] version 1.2.6, and PNet version 0.7.4 [2], which uses libjit as dynamic compiler...." This statement is false....

...r the LLVM developer meeting presentation, there is no mention of libjit. End of the story. Nicolas Kirill Kononenko wrote: > Hi Chris, > > > Just in case that this information does not get corrupted I want to > point to the issue: > > > In http://llvm.org/devmtg/2008-08/Geoffray_VMKitProject.pdf it is on > page 21: "VMKit, Mono, PNet", Array bounds checks. > > In http://hal.inria.fr/docs/00/35/45/77/PDF/RR-6799.pdf it is on page > 17: "We compare N3 with Mono [9] version 1.2.6, and PNet version 0.7.4 > [2], which uses libjit as dynamic compiler...." &...