Just to make sure this morning, I created another VM and it behaves the
same, so obviously we have something slightly different in our configs.?
I think we have gone through the client side pretty thoroughly and they
are the same.? That leaves:
* our security settings on the share -? but you said that your machine
isn't in domain users and domain computers doesn't have access to
the share.? What else there to test here?
* file server samba settings
* possibly version differences
o Client: Version 4.15.13-Ubuntu
o File Server: Version 4.19.0pre1-GIT-1e793357906
o Domain Controller: Version 4.18.0pre1-GIT-d385058ce7c
o I was doing some work on generic user level linux GPOs which is
why the DC and FS are running from source
* or even at the DC.?
What's the easiest way to proceed?? I can post pretty much any config
needed.
Peter
On 1/29/24 03:54, Rowland Penny via samba wrote:> On Sun, 28 Jan 2024 15:06:38 -0800
> Peter Carlson via samba<samba at lists.samba.org> wrote:
>
>> ok, I have gone back to my original recipe after working though this
>> piece by piece and the only thing I had wrong was that the machine is
>> not a member of Domain Users (or Domain Computers didn't have
>> permissions on the root of the share).
>>
> The problem with that statement is, in my domain there is no connection
> between computers and the Domain Users group and Domain Computers
> doesn't have permissions on the share, but it works.
>
> Rowland
>
On Mon, 29 Jan 2024 07:55:05 -0800 Peter Carlson via samba <samba at lists.samba.org> wrote:> Just to make sure this morning, I created another VM and it behaves > the same, so obviously we have something slightly different in our > configs. I think we have gone through the client side pretty > thoroughly and they are the same.? That leaves: > > * our security settings on the share -? but you said that your > machine isn't in domain users and domain computers doesn't have > access to the share.? What else there to test here? > * file server samba settings > * possibly version differences > o Client: Version 4.15.13-Ubuntu > o File Server: Version 4.19.0pre1-GIT-1e793357906 > o Domain Controller: Version 4.18.0pre1-GIT-d385058ce7c > o I was doing some work on generic user level linux GPOs which > is why the DC and FS are running from source > * or even at the DC.? > > What's the easiest way to proceed?? I can post pretty much any config > needed. >The share I am mounting is a simple share on a Unix domain member using the 'rid' backend (as is the client), these are the permissions on the share: ls -lad /srv/share drwxrwx--- 3 rowland domain users 4096 Jan 28 21:48 /srv/share The share in smb.conf is this: [data] path=/srv/share read only = no With that, I can start my VM and find the share in /mnt/test I think my next step will have to be to set up a new share on the server, but this time set the permissions from Windows and see if that mounts on the Unix client. But it will have to be tomorrow now. Rowland