Am 02.07.2018 um 15:13 schrieb Rowland Penny via samba:> You really need to speak to Louis about email, but I think he would > suggest investigating Kopano.I like it and checked it out in the past, but I cannot rent software, I can only buy. And nightly builds in the CE aren't my cup of tea.>> Nextcloud works out of the box, but if I want to manage quotas there, >> I'll need to use extra attributes... > Is there a schema available ?Not that I know of, but you can configure Nextcloud to use any attribute, so we created our own attribute in our schema for nextcloud:> attributetype ( 1.3.6.1.4.1.35502.1.2.3.1 NAME 'owncloudQuota' > DESC 'Quota for ownCloud' > EQUALITY integerMatch > SYNTAX 1.3.6.1.4.1.1466.115.121.1.27 > SINGLE-VALUE )>> ... which I need to configure somehow. Does anybody have good advice >> in that regard? GOsa seems to be dead (that's what we are using now, >> I fear it'll die with our last server supporting PHP5), LAM has to be >> rented, which I cannot do. > There is a free version of LAM, but there are some restrictions.As far as I understood, it also restricts managing your own attributes, which would be necessary for me.>> Maybe I'll just use a general purpose LDAP >> client, then I'll be independent from that kind of developments. But >> if anybody is in a similar situation and has a good tool I missed, I >> would be grateful. > Wouldn't we all ;-) > > Have considered writing your own scripts around ldapsearch etc ?Sure, but I prefer tested solutions. But if I don't find anything suitable, maybe we'll really do a simple web interface... I got another hint off list, GOsa was forked into Fusion Directory. Will check this out as well. Thanks, this shows me at least that I didn't miss anything obvious. Best, Jakob
On Tue, 3 Jul 2018 09:50:35 +0200 Jakob Lenfers via samba <samba at lists.samba.org> wrote:> I got another hint off list, GOsa was forked into Fusion Directory. > Will check this out as well. >I had a quick look at Fusion Directory and it seems to be making the same mistake that all the others do, it is ignoring AD and is concentrating on NT4-style domains. These are dying and I believe before long, Microsoft will finally shut the door on them, they are well on the way now. Rowland
"I had a quick look at Fusion Directory and it seems to be making the same mistake that all the others do, it is ignoring AD and is concentrating on NT4-style domains. These are dying and I believe before long, Microsoft will finally shut the door on them, they are well on the way now. Rowland " As for our samba3 NT4 domain, 1803 Win10 built (april update) is a no-go. New pcs can not be added to the domain and users can not log into the domain. So it seems to me the door was shut just now. Michal
Am 03.07.2018 um 11:21 schrieb Rowland Penny via samba:> On Tue, 3 Jul 2018 09:50:35 +0200 > Jakob Lenfers via samba <samba at lists.samba.org> wrote:>> I got another hint off list, GOsa was forked into Fusion Directory. >> Will check this out as well. > I had a quick look at Fusion Directory and it seems to be making the > same mistake that all the others do, it is ignoring AD and is > concentrating on NT4-style domains. These are dying and I believe > before long, Microsoft will finally shut the door on them, they are > well on the way now.Currently I'm inclined to use a general purpose ldap client like phpldapadmin or Apache Directory Studio, since we don't need to take care of the Samba-NT4 fields anymore. Maybe with a user limited to the attributes in question to make it easier to overview. Best, Jakob