The addition of a single line:
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,
initial-scale=1.0">
at in the <head> of the R HTML generated manuals would make them much
easier to read on mobile devices.
texi2any (which generates the HTML files) is based on long-working Perl code
that includes many modern HTML elements but does not include this one.
A Perl one-liner in the install-html: Makefile directive in Makefile.in:
install-html: installdirs
@for f in $(OBJECTS_HTML); do \
if test -f $${f} ; then \
$(INSTALL_DATA) $${f} "$(DESTDIR)$(rdocdir)/manual"; \
perl -pi -e 's/\<meta name="desc/<meta
name="viewport" content="width=device-width,
initial-scale=1.0">\n<meta name="desc/'
"$(DESTDIR)$(rdocdir)/manual/*.html"; \
fi \
done
would insert this (I still need to read Makefile.win to see where it should go
there) and I'd be glad to create a PR unless folks do not think better
accessibility on mobile is a good idea.
$(PERL) does not seem to be defined but Perl itself is a requirement for
texi2any so it is definitely something that would work in the current
installation process.
-Bob
Martin Maechler
2019-Jul-15 09:51 UTC
[Rd] Addition of a meta viewport tag to HTML manuals
>>>>> Bob Rudis >>>>> on Tue, 9 Jul 2019 14:24:24 -0400 writes:> The addition of a single line: > <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0"> > at in the <head> of the R HTML generated manuals would make them much easier to read on mobile devices. > texi2any (which generates the HTML files) is based on long-working Perl code that includes many modern HTML elements but does not include this one. > A Perl one-liner in the install-html: Makefile directive in Makefile.in: > install-html: installdirs > @for f in $(OBJECTS_HTML); do \ > if test -f $${f} ; then \ > $(INSTALL_DATA) $${f} "$(DESTDIR)$(rdocdir)/manual"; \ > perl -pi -e 's/\<meta name="desc/<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0">\n<meta name="desc/' "$(DESTDIR)$(rdocdir)/manual/*.html"; \ > fi \ > done > would insert this (I still need to read Makefile.win to see where it should go there) and I'd be glad to create a PR unless folks do not think better accessibility on mobile is a good idea. To the contrary. Thank you very much, Bob, for bringing this up, here! > $(PERL) does not seem to be defined but Perl itself is a requirement for texi2any so it is definitely something that would work in the current installation process. > -Bob Hmm,.. a very long time ago, perl was an absolute requirement for building R from the sources, but in the mean time, it's not been required anymore strictly *). AFAIK, there are alternative versions of versions/alternatives to texi2any (say on Windoze .. or bizarre Linux distros or non-linux unices), and I'm almost sure we do not want to require perl explicitly. We are using R itself in many places for installation things, but here, it should be possible to use smaller unix tools (such as 'sed' and 'grep' say) instead. If you (or someone else) provided a small patch for using those instead of perl, I don't see a reason not to be grateful and apply it to the sources. Thank you once more Martin -- *) perl is mentioned twice in the "R Administration and Installation" manual: 1. maybe needed for 'install-info' *if* there's no 'install-info' command on the system [but on my Fedora and probably most "math-y" Linux dist there is a binary] 2. On Windoze, the texinfo 5.x package needs perl
Thanks for both the support & sage advice, Martin! And, aye, tis straightforward to convert the perl one-liner to a shell/sed idiom. A kind soul from the list has also offered to walk me through the "provide a patch" process and I'll do my best to get it right on Par 1 :-) -Bob On Mon, Jul 15, 2019 at 5:54 AM Martin Maechler <maechler at stat.math.ethz.ch> wrote:> > >>>>> Bob Rudis > >>>>> on Tue, 9 Jul 2019 14:24:24 -0400 writes: > > > The addition of a single line: > > <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0"> > > > at in the <head> of the R HTML generated manuals would make them much easier to read on mobile devices. > > > texi2any (which generates the HTML files) is based on long-working Perl code that includes many modern HTML elements but does not include this one. > > > A Perl one-liner in the install-html: Makefile directive in Makefile.in: > > > install-html: installdirs > > @for f in $(OBJECTS_HTML); do \ > > if test -f $${f} ; then \ > > $(INSTALL_DATA) $${f} "$(DESTDIR)$(rdocdir)/manual"; \ > > perl -pi -e 's/\<meta name="desc/<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0">\n<meta name="desc/' "$(DESTDIR)$(rdocdir)/manual/*.html"; \ > > fi \ > > done > > > would insert this (I still need to read Makefile.win to see where it should go there) and I'd be glad to create a PR unless folks do not think better accessibility on mobile is a good idea. > > To the contrary. > Thank you very much, Bob, for bringing this up, here! > > > $(PERL) does not seem to be defined but Perl itself is a requirement for texi2any so it is definitely something that would work in the current installation process. > > > -Bob > > Hmm,.. a very long time ago, perl was an absolute requirement > for building R from the sources, but in the mean time, it's not > been required anymore strictly *). AFAIK, there are alternative versions > of versions/alternatives to texi2any (say on Windoze .. or > bizarre Linux distros or non-linux unices), and I'm almost sure > we do not want to require perl explicitly. > > We are using R itself in many places for installation things, > but here, it should be possible to use smaller unix tools (such > as 'sed' and 'grep' say) instead. > > If you (or someone else) provided a small patch for using those > instead of perl, I don't see a reason not to be grateful and > apply it to the sources. > > Thank you once more > Martin > > > -- > *) perl is mentioned twice in the "R Administration and > Installation" manual: > 1. maybe needed for 'install-info' *if* there's no > 'install-info' command on the system [but on my Fedora and > probably most "math-y" Linux dist there is a binary] > > 2. On Windoze, the texinfo 5.x package needs perl