R devel - Aug 2018 - Segfault when performing match on POSIXlt object

Hi All,
I found a possible unexpected behavior when performing match/%in% on
POSIXlt objects, e.g. :

  d <- as.POSIXlt('2018-01-01')

  # match(<anything>,<POSIXlt>) --> segfault
  match(0,d)

  # consequently also this fails :
  0 %in% d

REPORTED ERROR ON LINUX:
   *** caught segfault ***
  address 0x16dc2, cause 'memory not mapped'

Verified on 3.5.0 on linux, 3.5.1 on Windows.

I think this could be a bug, since even if that match operation makes no
sense, the R session is not supposed to crash with segmentation fault, but
rather throw an exception.

Thanks in advance

	[[alternative HTML version deleted]]

>>>>> Marco Giuliano 
>>>>>     on Fri, 31 Aug 2018 08:53:02 +0200 writes:
    > Hi All, I found a possible unexpected behavior when
    > performing match/%in% on POSIXlt objects, e.g. :

    >   d <- as.POSIXlt('2018-01-01')

    >   # match(<anything>,<POSIXlt>) --> segfault match(0,d)

    >   # consequently also this fails : 0 %in% d

    > REPORTED ERROR ON LINUX: *** caught segfault *** address
    > 0x16dc2, cause 'memory not mapped'

    > Verified on 3.5.0 on linux, 3.5.1 on Windows.

Confirmed (Linux, I think all version >= 3.4.0, but not in R
3.3.3 (or earlier, presumably).

Note the segfault happens inspite of the match_transform() utility
which explicitly checks for "POSIXlt" and the code comment which
says that "POSIXlt" should have been transformed to character, 
but seems to fail in recent versions of R.

    > I think this could be a bug, since even if that match
    > operation makes no sense, the R session is not supposed to
    > crash with segmentation fault, but rather throw an
    > exception.

Definitely.  It is a bug.

    > Thanks in advance

Thank you for reporting!

Martin Maechler, ETH Zurich

>>>>> Martin Maechler  on Fri, 31 Aug 2018 16:00:07 +0200 writes:
>>>>> Marco Giuliano on Fri, 31 Aug 2018 08:53:02 +0200 writes:
    >> Hi All, I found a possible unexpected behavior when
    >> performing match/%in% on POSIXlt objects, e.g. :

    >> d <- as.POSIXlt('2018-01-01')

    >> # match(<anything>,<POSIXlt>) --> segfault
match(0,d)

    >> # consequently also this fails :

    > 0 %in% d

    >> REPORTED ERROR ON LINUX: *** caught segfault *** address
    >> 0x16dc2, cause 'memory not mapped'

    >> Verified on 3.5.0 on linux, 3.5.1 on Windows.

    > Confirmed (Linux, I think all version >= 3.4.0, but not in
    > R 3.3.3 (or earlier, presumably).

ooops that was an offset error:

      Bug in all versions >= 3.3.3,
      but not in 3.2.5 (or earlier, presumably)